Showing posts sorted by date for query Nicolson. Sort by relevance Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by date for query Nicolson. Sort by relevance Show all posts

Thursday, July 16, 2026

Next Week We’ll Learn Whether Past Elections Foretold the Outcome of the 2026 Election

Past two elections revealed a geographic voting pattern
The results of Oro Valley’s Mayoral 2022 and Council 2024 elections suggest that where voters live may help explain how they vote. In both elections, a group of precincts centered in Rancho Vistoso voted differently from four precincts that include and surround the Town’s municipal golf courses. The candidates and issues changed, but the geographic divide remained.

Rancho Vistoso provided Winfield’s winning margin in 2022
In the 2022 mayoral election, Joe Winfield narrowly defeated former Oro Valley Police Chief Danny Sharp in the Mayoral election. This result was a bit surprising because Danny Sharp was a well-known, well respected figure in our Valley for many years. Sharp carried four precincts by a combined 920 votes. Winfield overcame that deficit by carrying  seven other precincts by 1,251 votes. His strength in Rancho Vistoso and the surrounding precincts provided the margin needed for his 285-vote townwide victory. That was close!

The 2022 council vote showed the same divide

The 2022 council race followed a similar pattern. Melanie Barrett, Joyce Jones-Ivey and Josh Nicolson won a majority of the council votes in nine of the Town’s eleven precincts. Their strongest support came from Rancho Vistoso. Their weakest results came from the precincts that include the Town’s two municipal golf courses, although they still received almost 48% of the vote there.

The same pattern appeared again in 2024
The 2024 council election produced another geographic split. Mary Murphy and Mo Greene received their strongest support in the golf-oriented precincts. Elizabeth Robb and Tim Bohen performed better in the Rancho Vistoso-oriented precincts. Murphy also received strong support in the Rancho Vistoso precincts. Robb received strong support in the community center precints. The election also produced substantial undervoting, as many residents used only one or two of their three available council votes.

A pattern is not a prediction... but tomorrow we will know more
Two elections do not establish how Oro Valley residents will vote in the future. Candidates, issues and turnout change from one election to the next. Still, the results of 2022 and 2024 suggest that Oro Valley has two identifiable geographic voting coalitions. And, as the panel shows, one is much larger in terms of voters than the other. The 2026 election will show whether that pattern continues or whether voters create a different one. 

Tomorrow: Will Social Media Spell The Difference?
- - -

Friday, June 26, 2026

Bits and Pieces

Council approves next year’s budget
Last week, the Oro Valley Town Council unanimously approved the Town’s final budget for fiscal year 2026-27. The budget sets a maximum expenditure limit of $127.99 million and includes the Town’s General Pay Plan and ten-year Capital Improvement Program. The projected ending balance across all Town funds is approximately $47.85 million. The new fiscal year begins July 1.

Council Member Murphy opposes use tax without an efficiency audit
Also last week, the Oro Valley Town Council approved a 2.5% use tax by a 4-3 vote. The tax generally applies to taxable business purchases from out-of-state sellers when an equivalent local sales tax was not collected. Vice Mayor Barrett and Councilmembers Murphy and Nicolson voted against the measure. Murphy told LOVE: “I will never vote for a new tax without an operational efficiency audit. It does not mean that I believe we aren’t operating efficiently, but I absolutely believe our residents and businesses deserve us to do our due diligence before ever enacting a new tax.” Council had first approved the tax in January, but that action became void after the Arizona Department of Revenue failed to update the Town’s tax code within the required period. The tax takes effect July 1.

Floodplain update protects access to insurance and disaster aid
The Oro Valley Town Council unanimously approved updates to the Town’s floodplain and erosion-hazard regulations. These changes keep Oro Valley in compliance with state and FEMA standards, helping preserve residents’ access to federally backed flood insurance and the Town’s eligibility for disaster assistance and flood-mitigation grants after a major storm.

Oro Valley plans a larger July Fourth celebration
Oro Valley will celebrate America’s 250th anniversary on July 4 at James D. Kriegh Park from 6:00 to 9:20 p.m. The free event will include live music, food trucks, children’s activities, a beer garden and fireworks beginning at 9 p.m. Parking will be available at the Oro Valley Aquatic Center and Canyon del Oro High School. Residents should note that pets, outside alcohol, smoking, glass containers, personal shade tents and personal fireworks are not permitted. Coolers are allowed but may be inspected.

- - -



Thursday, May 14, 2026

Council Approves OVPath Forward General For November Vote

Residents strongly supported the process
Last week, the Oro Valley Town Council voted unanimously to place the Oro Valley Path Forward General Plan on the November ballot. The vote followed a public hearing, staff presentation, and nearly 42 minutes of council discussion. Most resident speakers supported both the process and the final draft. Several praised Principal Planner Milini Sims, Bayer Vella, and Rene Olvera for managing what staff described as the Town’s largest public engagement effort for any project.

More than 10,700 resident comments shaped the plan
Staff said the plan was based on more than 10,700 resident comments gathered over roughly three years. Input came through surveys, meetings, working groups, online discussions, and public events. Sims told council the final version remained very similar to the previously reviewed 60 percent and 90 percent drafts. She said there were no significant directional changes from earlier versions reviewed by council and residents.

Speaker recalled earlier General Plan controversy

Resident Shirl Lamona contrasted the current process with the Town’s earlier General Plan effort in the early 2000s. The 2001 General Plan update failed because significant land use changes were included in the plan. There was inadequate public vetting. It took several years, through the efforts of Oro Valley resident Bill Adler, to get it right. Lamona told council the current process was different because residents remained directly involved throughout development of the draft plan.

Council focused on wording and implementation timing
Much of the council discussion involved wording refinements and clarification of intent. Mayor Joe Winfield led much of the discussion, proposing edits intended to make portions of the document more action-oriented. Councilmember Josh Nicolson also successfully requested moving the proposed Vistoso Trails Nature Preserve restoration planning action from the three-to-six-year category into the one-to-two-year category. The change advances the timeline for a project that has already undergone years of planning, debate, redesign, and council review before reaching the current restoration phase.

Rooney Ranch amendment will update the land use map
One discussion late in the meeting clarified that the Path Forward land use map will automatically reflect the Rooney Ranch and Town Center General Plan amendment approved later that evening. Staff explained that the Path Forward map mirrors the current General Plan map, so the approved amendment will be incorporated into the version voters see in November.

Next phase focuses on voter outreach
The council approved Resolution (R)26-20 on a 6-0 vote, placing the Path Forward General Plan on the November ballot. Later this summer, staff plans to begin the “Residents Decide” phase of the process. That public information effort is expected to include roadway signs, postcards, newsletters, videos, and social media outreach. And, of course, more LOVE coverage!
- - -

Tuesday, May 12, 2026

Town Council Approves "Town Center" Amendment...Limited Housing...Lots Of Open Space

Council approves two related actions
The Oro Valley Town Council voted Wednesday to approve two related actions for the Town-owned portions of the Oro Valley Town Center property near Oracle Road and Pushview Lane. Council approved a general plan amendment for part of Area 4 and a PAD rezoning amendment for portions of the former Rooney Ranch property. 

Provides for significant opens space...
According to Town staff, the approved plan increases permanent open space from 69 acres to about 88 acres, about 78 percent of the subject area. It also eliminates 77 previously approved single-family lots in Area 4 and increases the buffer to nearby El Conquistador patio homes from about 100 feet to 350 feet. Staff also said the plan reduces building heights on the Town-owned portions of the property, including removal of a previously allowed 75-foot hotel entitlement.

... and a more restricted residential housing plan
The general plan amendment was approved unanimously as presented. The PAD rezoning amendment, however, was changed during the Council meeting. It was passed 5-1. Mayor Joe Winfield amended the motion to restrict Area 3 to one- and two-story ownership townhomes. That removed the apartment option from the plan. The motion also limited linear commercial height in Area 2B to 30 feet, including architectural features.

...which means that the council left "money on the table" in order to accommodate residents
That change highlighted an issue also raised the previous night during Planning and Zoning Commission discussion. They discussed this. It was their conclusion that limiting the residential use to just town homes  could reduce the future value or marketability of the property. They also felt it was too restrictive of future council options.  Council Member Josh Nicholson echoed their thoughts regarding reducing market value. Nicolson, who owns and operates apartments, said apartments could potentially generate greater land-sale value for the Town than townhomes. He said an apartment project could produce about $5 million in taxpayer revenue, compared with “just a couple million” from townhomes.  Council Member Nicolson, however, did not agree. He was the lone no vote.

Mayor Winfield felt that trade-off was a good one...
Winfield, however, said staff had spoken with developers who expressed support for ownership townhomes. He did not address the value issue. He also said he believed that type of housing would be supported by a majority of residents. His motion made clear that he wanted a more limited residential product than the one staff had brought forward; that he placed more value on lower intensity development. 

...as most on council agreed
Though there was disagreement on this, council, nevertheless, voted unanimously to approve the motion. One member told us that "The only reason I did not push back (on Winfield's motion) what that it was a reasonable compromise. I was very happy with the fact that we were able to get almost 80% open space." 

Residents got what they wanted...lots of open space... restricted residential housing
Residents who spoke at the public hearing offered differing views. Some urged the Town to preserve the property as open space because of its scenic location and importance to the character of the area. Others supported the revised concept because it increases open space, reduces building heights, and removes the previously approved single-family lots. In the end, their views were clearly considered. Council moved the project forward, but with a more restrictive residential limit than originally proposed.
- - -
Want to learn more? Read previously LOVE reports.

Wednesday, February 25, 2026

Council Explores Changes That Might Attract Big-Box Retail

Council initiates discussion on attracting "Big-Box" Retail
For some time now, Vice Mayor Melanie Barrett and Councilmember Josh Nicolson have discussed the need for Oro Valley to attract at least a medium-sized, if not a large, big-box retailer. At their request, Town staff presented an update at last week’s Council meeting outlining current recruitment efforts. 

The discussion made clear that there are several challenges
Oro Valley could face in attracting these retailers, including assembling sufficiently large parcels, addressing potential infrastructure and grading costs, pursuing General Plan amendments or rezoning if required, and possibly negotiating incentives. None of these issues were described as insurmountable, and to a large extent they fall within the policy authority of the Town Council. However, each raises questions about timing, process, and ensuring that public involvement remains central to any decision.

Unknown if there are any Big-Box Retailers in the pipeline
Staff did not identify any specific medium or large big-box retailer as currently engaged or under review. Community and Economic Development Director Paul Melcher emphasized that the Town maintains confidentiality regarding potential projects and explained that staff’s goal is to keep approximately three “qualified leads” active at any given time. He stated that four qualified retail leads are currently in the pipeline. However, no specific large big-box retailer was named during the discussion, and no project in that category is presently before the Council for consideration.

Staff claims of a direct outreach strategy seem contrary to prior council discussion

Community and Economic Development Director Paul Melcher explained that the Town conducts “cold-call outreach,” meaning staff contacts targeted retailers directly and provides site information, recruitment materials, and pre-application assistance. He did not specify which retailers have been contacted. At a prior Council meeting, in response to a question from Councilmember Nicolson, Melcher said staff has not contacted Costco directly. No specific retailer was identified as currently engaged.

Staff foresees land size constraints and entitlement uncertainty
Staff outlined several structural challenges. Medium to large retailers typically require 18 to 22 acres or more, high traffic volumes, and locations at major intersections — conditions that are increasingly difficult to meet in Oro Valley, where most readily developable commercial land has already been built. Remaining parcels may involve costly grading, drainage or wash constraints, infrastructure extensions, multiple property owners, or the need for General Plan amendments and rezoning. Staff noted that timing is often critical in site selection, meaning uncertainty in the entitlement process can put Oro Valley at a competitive disadvantage when retailers compare locations.

Sales tax rebate incentive discussed... lessons from the Oro Valley Marketplace experience
The discussion also acknowledged that incentives can be part of large retail recruitment, including infrastructure reimbursements, permit fee reimbursements, expedited review, and potentially sales tax–based incentives through an Economic Development Agreement. Any agreement must comply with Arizona’s Gift Clause and demonstrate a clear public benefit. Oro Valley has prior experience with retail tax incentives, most notably with the Oro Valley Marketplace project nearly two decades ago, which included a sales tax rebate component returning a portion of sales tax revenues to the developer over a defined period. Despite that arrangement, the Marketplace struggled financially for years, raising broader questions about the effectiveness and risks of retail tax incentive agreements.

Pre-Entitlements Proposed — Public Input Emphasized
The most significant policy concept discussed was whether the Town should consider “pre-entitling” certain commercial parcels for medium or large retail uses. This could involve initiating General Plan amendments or rezoning in advance of a specific retailer applying, and potentially negotiating Economic Development Agreements earlier in the process. Staff suggested that this approach could provide greater certainty and reduce timing risk for developers. Vice Mayor Barrett cautioned, however, that the Town must not short-circuit public input, emphasizing that community participation remains critically important in Oro Valley. Mayor Winfield indicated that any proposal involving pre-entitlements would need to return to Council as a separate agenda item for full discussion.

The last time staff recommended any pre‑entitlement action was a few years ago at Innovation Park. Council approved a measure to allow developers to grade sites early to attract “shovel ready” projects. To our knowledge, that effort produced no results.

No Action Taken; Further Discussion Likely
No formal action was taken. For now, staff will continue recruitment efforts. Any specific retailer proposal, incentive package, or change to the entitlement process would require future Council review and public input.
- - -

Tuesday, January 20, 2026

Oro Valley Council Divided as Two New Taxes Are Rejected

Council rejects two proposed taxes
Last week, the Oro Valley Town Council rejected two proposed new taxes: A commercial rental tax and a telecommunications tax. The measures were voted down by four councilmembers. 

Council members cite lack of demonstrated need and need for more though vetting of spending and spending priorities
The reasoning varied. In general, Councilmembers Barrett, Murphy, Nicolson, and Robb said the Council and Town staff need to demonstrate more clearly that a financial shortfall will occur in 2030 and that new taxes are the only viable solution.  Councilmember Murphy summarized the concerns of those opposed, stating, “To my knowledge, there still hasn’t been an audit regarding operational efficiency since we first started talking about this. … I absolutely believe that our residents and our businesses deserve that before we talk about taxes.”

Business community raised concerns

Opposition was also expressed by the Greater Oro Valley Chamber of Commerce, which represents more than 500 businesses. Chamber President Kristin Sharp said, “It’s already more expensive to do business here, and enacting these taxes would only widen that gap.” In addition, comments from mayoral candidate Mark Napier, read into the record, reflected concerns that the Town may be facing a structural imbalance between revenues and expenditures and that the issue warrants closer examination before new taxes are adopted. 

And Vice Mayor Barrett "set the record straight"
Vice Mayor Barrett responded to criticism from former Council member Joe Hornat, who alleged that Council spending created the Town’s financial challenges. “I do not think that Oro Valley is at a crisis point in any way, shape, or form,” Barrett said, cautioning against characterizing the situation as urgent.  Barrett accurately reflected the facts. The spending Hornat cited was addressed by reducing costs elsewhere, particularly by what she described as excessive golf-related losses incurred during Hornat’s tenure. She noted that this Council paid down the police pension debt inherited from Hornat's Council.  Barrett reminded the group that the most recent tax increase was a half-cent sales tax increase enacted during Hornat’s time on the Council.

No clear path forward
The discussion highlighted a split within the Council on how to proceed. Mayor Winfield has said he believes Town staff are doing a strong job managing costs and operating efficiently,. It appears that he does not believe that an independent comprehensive review of spending and priorities is necessary. Winfield, along with Councilmember Greene, expressed confidence at the meeting that Town staff can work through the situation and framed support for the proposed taxes as a way to address long-term financial obligations proactively.

Strategic planning session may test those differences
Whether those differing views will be addressed in the Council’s tomorrow's council strategic planning session remains an open question. The Town has not published the agenda. We do not know how the agenda was developed or the extent to which it was shaped by Town management. As a result, it remains unclear whether the session will include a broad examination of spending levels and priorities and a critical review of the Town’s long-range financial forecasts. 
- - -

Tuesday, October 28, 2025

New Taxes not a "Silver Bullet"... Part Of A Package Of Actions For Sustained Oro Valley Fiscal Stability

Town has identified and council has considered three new taxes to cover possible future spending shortfall
In March, Oro Valley Finance Director David Gephart presented a five-year forecast of the Town’s General Fund showing that expenses are projected to exceed revenues beginning in fiscal year 2029–30. The General Fund—one of the Town’s many funds—supports day-to-day operations, capital spending, and transfers to other funds. In response to the projected financial shortfall, Town staff identified several ways to close the gap. These included implementing three new taxes already in place in nearby communities: a commercial rental tax, a use tax, and a telecommunications tax. Together, these taxes, along with long-overdue fee increases for parks and recreation programs, would close the roughly $3 million funding gap identified in the forecast. The Council approved the  Parks and Recreation fee increase in October. As reported last week, the Council is expected to vote on them at its next meeting.
 
New taxes are not a "silver bullet" but are part of a set of actions to insure financial sustainability
Though much has been said by town staff in favor of the proposed new taxes, these taxes are not a “silver bullet” for ensuring Oro Valley’s long-term financial sustainability. According to Mayor Joe Winfield, speaking at the October 15 study session on the new taxes, “We’re looking at this as one of many tools,” he said, emphasizing that the Town must continue to pursue multiple strategies to strengthen its financial position rather than relying on any single measure.  Winfield pointed to the Town’s strategic refinancing of its public safety pension debt—which has saved about $3.4 million—as an example of responsible financial management. He also cited other ongoing efforts to improve fiscal sustainability, including pursuing annexation of retail rich areas, working to reduce retail sales leakage, and supporting population growth through approved housing projects now under construction. Winfield said that all these actions together—not any single one—will help build a stronger financial foundation for the Town.

While town focuses on maintaining efficient operations
Winfield also stressed that the real solution also lies in maintaining an efficient municipal government and practicing disciplined budgeting. Finance Director David Gephart believes that the Town is running a “tight ship.” He emphasized that Oro Valley has been proactive in managing expenses and maintaining fiscal discipline. Gephart outlined several ongoing efforts to control spending, including limiting staff growth, consolidating positions where possible, and delaying or reprioritizing capital projects that are not immediately necessary. The Town is also using technology to improve efficiency, reducing reliance on outside consultants, and closely monitoring contracts and operating costs. He noted that departments have been asked to identify savings and that the Town continues to maintain healthy reserves without relying on short-term borrowing. Gephart said these measures have allowed Oro Valley to preserve high service levels even as costs increase and revenues grow more slowly, demonstrating that the Town is already “doing more with less” while continuing to strengthen its long-term financial position.
 
Impact of new taxes on businesses and tenants remains uncertain
Town staff said they do not believe the proposed new taxes would place a significant burden on residents or the business community. The only direct impact on residents would be a small increase in their cell phone bills. Regarding the commercial rental tax, Finance Director David Gephart said the effect on tenants would depend on lease terms and market conditions—some landlords might absorb part of the cost to stay competitive, while others would likely pass it through to tenants. Councilmember Nicolson initially disagreed, noting that most Oro Valley commercial centers are owned by large, out-of-state corporations that operate under strict financial models and are therefore unlikely to absorb new costs. Later in the meeting, however, Nicolson pointed out that Oro Valley’s commercial vacancy rate—about 14 percent—represents an oversupply condition that could limit a landlord’s ability to raise rents, meaning some may have to absorb at least part of the additional expense themselves.

Council decision will shape Oro Valley’s long-term financial path
Soon, the Town Council will decide whether to move forward with all or some of the proposed new taxes. The decision will determine how Oro Valley balances its budget in the years ahead—whether through new revenue sources, continued cost control, or a combination of both. Whatever the outcome, the discussion has made clear that maintaining the Town’s long-term fiscal stability will require steady attention, discipline, and a mix of strategies rather than reliance on any single solution.
- - -

Thursday, October 23, 2025

Oro Valley Council Continues Discussion On Adding Three New Taxes

Three new taxes continue to be under consideration
The Oro Valley Town Council met October 15 to continue its study session on three proposed taxes — a use tax, a telecommunications tax, and a commercial rental tax. These taxes are already collected by Tucson, Marana, and Sahuarita. Town staff said they would help maintain services as costs rise and state-shared revenues flatten. We have reported on the council's four previous discussions of this item.

Estimated annual revenue impact of up to $2 million
Finance Director David Gephart said the three taxes could generate between $930,000 and $1.9 million annually:
  • Use tax: $375,000 to $600,000
  • Telecommunications tax: $130,000 to $280,000
  • Commercial rental tax: $425,000 to $1,000,000
He said the goal is to diversify the Town’s revenues, reduce dependence on sales tax, and avoid introducing a property tax.

Staff would like to see funds dedicated for capital spending
If adopted, staff recommends that revenue from the new taxes be earmarked by Council for capital projects such as the newly acquired Police Department building, which currently lack a dedicated funding source. Final money dedication would require Council action (ordinance, fund setup, or budget transfer). Otherwise the funds can be used for any town operating or capital need. Council has not taken a position on this.

Businesses say new taxes would hurt competitiveness

Oro Valley Chamber of Commerce President Kristen Sharp told the Council that the commercial rental tax would make it harder for local businesses to remain competitive when operating costs in Oro Valley are already higher than in surrounding areas. She said businesses are “operating on tight margins” and warned that higher costs could discourage new tenants or drive existing ones away.

Commercial real estate broker Robert Tomlinson presented data showing Oro Valley’s retail vacancy rate at 12.8%, more than double the Tucson-area average of 5.9%. He said the new tax could further weaken the retail sector and increase vacant space.

Move would diversify Oro Valley's revenue stream
Joyce Garland, a 25-year Oro Valley resident and former Chief Financial Officer for Tucson, supported adopting all three taxes. She said state-shared revenues are declining because Oro Valley’s population is growing by less than one percent a year while new cities, such as San Tan Valley, are being incorporated. That means Oro Valley’s share of the statewide revenue “pie” continues to shrink. Garland said a broader mix of local revenues would give the Town flexibility and protect services from future shortfalls. The Budget and Finance Commission, which she chairs, voted September 16 to recommend approval of the proposals.

Implementation of taxes would not happen until July of 2026 if they are approved by council
Gephart plans to bring implementation proposals back for another study session before any vote. He explained that the Arizona Department of Revenue recently changed its reporting process for municipal tax code updates, and Oro Valley is the first community to use it. Because of that, there are questions about timing and notification requirements that must be resolved before moving forward. He said staff may recommend a phased implementation beginning in July 2026. 

Council weighs fairness and economic impacts
Councilmember Robb said she supports the use tax because it applies broadly and fairly but remains undecided about the other two. Vice Mayor Barrett questioned whether the rental tax would truly harm competitiveness, noting that neighboring towns already have similar taxes. Councilmember Nicolson said that because most Oro Valley commercial centers are owned by large, out-of-state corporations. These are landlords who are unlikely to pass the added cost on to their tenants — many of whom are small, locally owned businesses. He explained that these are landlords operate under corporate financial models that prioritize maintaining profit margins, leaving little flexibility to adjust lease terms or absorb new costs locally.

Next step: Up for public hearing with council vote on November 5
No formal action was taken at this session. At the beginning of the meeting, Finance Director David Gephart said staff intends to bring the three proposed taxes back to the Council for possible action at its next regular meeting on November 5.
- - -
- - -

Friday, October 3, 2025

Bits and Pieces

Council approves having Town Attorney report to them... begins search now
Wednesday, the The Oro Valley Town Council unanimously approved Ordinance No. (O)25-08, changing the Town Code so that the Town Attorney will now be appointed by and report directly to the Town Council rather than the Town Manager. The Council also directed the Human Resources Director and Town Manager to return at the next meeting with a proposed hiring process and job description. They instructed them to model their work after the process used to hire the Town Magistrate. This action formally begins the search for Oro Valley’s next Town Attorney. (See our article that discusses this change.) 

Council clarifies: Small backyard structures do not require building permits
At its October 1 meeting, the Oro Valley Town Council unanimously adopted Ordinance No. (O)25-06, making small corrections to the Town’s recently approved 2024 building and property maintenance codes. The ordinance deals with building permits under the International Residential Code (IRC). Normally, the code sets a threshold for when a permit is required to build small detached accessory structures, with the size referring to the floor area of the building (such as storage sheds, playhouses, or similar non-habitable structures). Without this correction, the rule would have dropped to 120 square feet, meaning even a 10x12 shed would require a permit. The ordinance keeps the Oro Valley threshold at 200 square feet, so residents don’t need a permit for small backyard sheds or similar structures under that size.

Register now for Pusch Ridge Golf Opening Tourney
Registration is now open for the Friends of Pusch Ridge Golf Opening Tourney on Friday, November 7. Don’t miss this community tradition—reserve your spot today! Click here to register. 

New businesses open in Oro Valley
Several new businesses have recently opened their doors in town, adding variety to the local economy. Heather’s Luminous Esthetics and Queenie Natural & Wellness are now operating at 7315 N. Oracle Rd., while Faye Artisan has opened at 2404 E. Tangerine Rd. In addition, Vantage West Credit Union has added a branch on La Canada Drive, and Premier Title Agency has a new location on Oracle Road. Noble Hops has come under new ownership, and Trader Joe’s has completed a commercial addition at its Oracle Road store. (Source)

Town staff works to remove invasive weeds to restore Vistoso’s desert ecosystem
According to Council Member Josh Nicolson, speaking at the past Wednesday's Town of Oro Valley Town Council meeting, Volunteers and Town staff recently focused on curbing the spread of Russian thistle at Vistoso Trails Nature Preserve—a critical effort for ecosystem health. Russian thistle is an aggressive, drought-tolerant invasive plant that can outcompete native species by quickly hogging water, nutrients, and space.  It produces hundreds of thousands of seeds, spreads easily as a tumbleweed, and can dominate disturbed soil areas if left unchecked.  By removing it before seed set, the preserve helps reduce the invasive seed bank and gives native plants a better chance to establish.  This removal supports the preserve’s restoration vision, helping to maintain biodiversity, improve habitat quality, and prevent soil degradation across Vistoso Trails.

Council "forced to approve" state dictated construction hour changes for earlier allowed start times
The Also Wednesday, the Oro Valley Town Council adopted Ordinance No. (O)25-07 to bring the Town Code into compliance with Arizona’s new state law on construction hours (SB 1182). The changes expand summer work hours, allowing general construction as early as 5 a.m. on weekdays and 7 a.m. on Saturdays, with concrete work permitted an hour earlier. Several council members voiced concerns about the impact of 4 a.m. and 5 a.m. start times on nearby residents and noted frustration that the state has stripped away local control. Despite this reluctance, the Council acknowledged it had no choice but to approve the amendments, since state law preempts stricter local standards
- - - 


Wednesday, October 1, 2025

Oro Valley Council to Consider Changing Town Attorney Reporting Structure

Let Oro Valley Excel (LOVE) logo Council to weigh changes in Town Attorney reporting and oversight
Tonight, the Oro Valley Town Council will consider a resolution that changes who hires the Town Attorney and to whom the position reports. The matter comes forward at the request of Vice Mayor Barrett and Councilmember Nicolson. It is a public hearing. The matter is particularly relevant since the Town's Director of Legal Services is retiring. (We have also hear that another member of the legal team is retiring though we have found no public notice of this.)

Current model places Town Attorney under Town Manager
Under today’s structure, Oro Valley’s Legal Services Director serves as Town Attorney and reports to the Town Manager, who appoints and evaluates the Director. This arrangement keeps the attorney within the management chain, ensuring alignment with staff operations. Supporters say this promotes efficiency. Critics argue that it limits the attorney’s independence, since the Town Manager oversees performance. They also note that the Town Manager is not an attorney and cannot add value to or properly evaluate the professional operations of the department.

Larger Arizona cities rely on council-appointed attorneys

In many larger and more mature Arizona cities, the City or Town Attorney is appointed directly by the Council and reports only to that body. Cities such as Tucson, Scottsdale, Tempe, Mesa, Peoria, Gilbert, and Flagstaff follow this structure. The advantages are clear: Council receives unfiltered, independent legal advice on issues where staff may have a stake, and Council members can consult directly with their attorney without staff involvement. This structure strengthens transparency, accountability, and the separation of powers.

Council appointment could reduce reliance on outside counsel
The Oro Valley Town Council currently retains the law firm of Mesch, Clark, Rothschild. The firm is contracted to be present at all Council meetings to provide legal advice directly to Councilmembers during deliberations. The firm is retained by the council and reports directly to them.  From time to time, the firm has also been engaged for special projects. Shifting the reporting structure so that the Town Attorney reports directly to Council may reduce, or even eliminate, the need for this outside legal support.

In communities like Tucson, Scottsdale, and Tempe, the Council-appointed attorney serves as the independent legal advisor to the governing body. Outside legal counsel is used only for highly specialized matters, not for routine Council meetings or day-to-day advice. This streamlines services, reduces duplication, reduces cost and ensures Council has a single, direct source for legal guidance.

Move would put complete public safety alignment under Council oversight
Currently, the Police Department and the Oro Valley Municipal Court already report directly to Council. Adding the Town Attorney to this reporting chain would complete the cycle and further emphasize public safety as central to the Town’s mission. All that is needed is a Council majority vote to make the change.
- - -
A look back
Oro Valley’s “two Tobins” and how Oro Valley came to use both inside and outside counsel
In 2012, Oro Valley employed two attorneys on staff — Tobin Rosen as Town Attorney and Tobin Sidles. Rosen was Town Attorney. He attended Council meetings and provided legal advice directly to Council. Sidles worked under Town Attorney Rosen. His duties included civil legal work and municipal prosecution. Their complementary positions reflected the Town’s recognition of the broad legal workload: General counsel for Council and staff alongside a prosecutorial function. When Rosen announced his retirement in late 2012, Mayor Hiremath and his a council appointed Sidles as Interim Town Attorney. In 2013, the town council amended the  Town Code (Ordinance O13-15, May 15, 2013) to formally create the position of contract Town Attorney. This new role reported directly to Council, with responsibilities limited to advising Council at meetings and on special projects Council brought in an outside contract attorney for Council meeting legal advice, never replacing Rosen's position in house. Sidles moved into the role of Legal Services Director.
- - -
UPDATE: The council unanimously approved Ordinance No. (O)25-08, changing the Town Code so that the Town Attorney will now be appointed by and report directly to the Town Council rather than the Town Manager. The Council also directed the Human Resources Director and Town Manager to return at the next meeting with a proposed hiring process and job description. They instructed them to model their work after the process used to hire the Town Magistrate. This action formally begins the search for Oro Valley’s next Town Attorney.

Wednesday, August 20, 2025

Council Delivers Solution To Police Space Crunch

Town to invest $23.6M in a police facility on Oracle Road
For years, LOVE has been reporting that Oro Valley Police Department facilities are substantially undersized. The department operates in 42,500 square feet of space across four locations, which has not been enough to support all police activities. In our 2021 report, we noted that Chief Riley felt the need for more space would become critical by 2026–27. Town Council anticipated this by including a “placeholder” $27 million amount in the capital expenditure plan for a future date.

Council approves purchase of building that will fill the need
Last week, the town council approved a $3.8 million purchase of a 50,000+ square foot building located north of Harbor Freight on Oracle Road. The police will use approximately 32,000 feet of that facility. Renovation costs are estimated at almost $20 million. The total cost for the purchase and renovation is $23.6 million.

Project will be funded over three years
The $3.8 million purchase price is built into the 2026 budget. We reported on this last-minute addition in June. There is no specifically identified funding source for the $20 million renovation. Those funds will have to come from town revenues or possible grants. The anticipated renovation period is about 2½ years, spreading costs across three fiscal years.

Funds left from purchase authorization could jump start renovation

There is a remaining amount of about $700,000 from a $4.5 million June appropriation. This is because the negotiated purchase price came in lower than the total appropriated amount. With council approval, these remaining funds can be used to start immediate renovation. According to Town Public Works Director Paul Keesler, early work will include roof replacement, electrical upgrades, and interior reconfiguration to prepare the space for police use.

Council felt this was the best of four options
Town staff presented four other options to the council for solving the police space problem. Two of these were more costly than the selected option. One alternative not fully discussed at the meeting was adding a second story to the existing headquarters at the town complex on La Cañada. That would cost approximately $20 million, including a 30% contingency, and would keep most operations in one facility. However, construction and occupancy time would be about twice as long, it would be highly disruptive to daily operations, and parking availability would be insufficient.

Added space give opportunity for expanded operations and training
The police department intends to use the building to meet several operational needs. It will provide room for a growing Criminal Investigations Unit, allow for better proximity between work groups, and create large meeting and training spaces that the department currently lacks. The facility will also give the department the capacity to host large-scale training events locally, reducing the need to travel and enabling more officers to participate.

Visibility and proximity to GRFD headquarters an added benefit
While the new building is away from the main town campus, police leaders noted they are accustomed to working throughout the community and will adapt. The location offers opportunities to make the new facility more visible and welcoming to the public than the current station, which some residents have difficulty finding. Proximity to Golder Ranch Fire headquarters may also foster closer collaboration.

Police department and Council enthusiastic

Police command staff expressed strong support for acquiring the building, calling it a long-awaited opportunity to address long-term space shortages. They emphasized that the size and flexibility of the facility will allow for phased renovations and expansions as needs arise and funding allows, ensuring that it can evolve with the department’s requirements.  Council approval of the purchase was unanimous.  Councilmember Nicolson summed up Council's excitement: “This is an investment in public safety and in our community’s future.”
- - -

Note:
The new facility is located at 12955 N. Oracle Road. It is north of the intersection of Rancho Vistoso Boulevard and Oracle Road.

Wednesday, May 14, 2025

It's Budget Time: Council Questions Whether Proposed Capital Spending Is Balanced and Justified

Council digs into details of capital spending
At the April 30 budget study session, Council members questioned several aspects of the Town Manager’s recommended capital budget for fiscal 2026. The discussion focused on major areas of spending: water, public safety, streets, parks, and town facilities. Mayor Winfield presided over the session but did not ask questions. Staff answered each question and said that the current proposal reflects priorities identified in the Council's strategic plan.

Water spending and NWRRDS funding
Several questions focused on the largest area of capital spending: the Water Utility, which accounts for 62% of the $45.6 million recommended CIP. Vice Mayor Melanie Barrett asked for clarification on how much of the Northwest Recharge, Recovery, and Delivery System (NWRRDS) project is new spending versus carryover from the current year. Staff responded that approximately $8 million is carryover and $16.7 million is new funding.

Barrett also requested that future reports distinguish between groundwater preservation fees, which are paid by all water users, and water impact fees, which are paid by developers. “It would be helpful to have those separated out, since they are different sources of funding,” she said.

Community center project costs and equity

Multiple councilmembers commented on the large share of parks funding being spent at the Community Center. Vice Mayor Barrett raised concerns about over-concentrating capital spending in one part of town, saying: “It kind of feels like we just keep putting more and more and more money onto this one area… I hope that [residents in that area] will also support funding other areas of our town.”

Councilmember Mary Murphy and Councilmember Mo Green supported the proposed $950,000 to resurface the Community Center parking lot, citing safety concerns and visible deterioration. Staff explained that the pavement is crumbling and poses trip hazards. Councilmember Joyce Robb added that the older part of the lot “definitely seems like there are trip hazards,” noting that she observed them during a recent site visit.

Traffic, streets, and intersections
Vice Mayor Barrett asked whether a traffic warrant study had been completed for the $750,000 traffic signal proposed at Tangerine Road and Musette Drive. Staff responded that traffic counts had been collected and a warrant analysis was underway. She also questioned the long-term deferral of the Moore Road and La Cholla Boulevard intersection improvements, a project she said residents continue to raise concerns about.

Councilmember Robb asked about the sidewalk program and whether $100,000 annually is enough. Staff responded that the program began two years ago and that the request for next year is intended to “catch up” on backlogged repairs before scaling down to $25,000 in future years.

Parks projects and equity concerns
There was strong support among councilmembers for moving a proposed $250,000 Naranja Park shade structure from the contingent project list into the funded budget. Councilmember Nicolson said he hears frequent complaints about the lack of shade, and Councilmember Jones-Ivey asked whether drainage issues might interfere with construction. Staff said drainage is being monitored but is no longer a barrier to building shade structures.

Barrett also questioned the proposed $350,000 multi-use path near Lambert Lane, asking whether it serves the highest-priority need in the town’s trail system. Councilmember Robb suggested earmarking the funds generally for multi-use paths, to be directed to the top priority identified in the updated trails plan.

Police facility planning and project timing
Vice Mayor Barrett urged caution on the $36 million police facility project currently listed in future years of the CIP. She supported the $400,000 in the FY 2026 budget for continued planning but said, “It seems a little optimistic to me to say that in next year’s budget we’ll have something ready for $18 million.” Staff responded that the project is still in the contingent list and that scope and funding are yet to be defined.

Operations yard and long-term use
Councilmembers discussed whether to remove a $50,000 project for decommissioning the Municipal Operations Center (MOC), given that the Town also proposes spending $450,000 on fencing and other upgrades at the same location. “If you’re going to go in one direction, you wouldn’t do one of the other,” said Barrett. Councilmembers agreed to remove the decommissioning project from the long-range plan, since there are no plans to relocate Transit or Water Utility operations.

Next steps
This was the first of five public meetings on the FY 2026 budget. A follow-up session on the operating budget is scheduled for tonight. Public hearings are set for June 4 (tentative adoption) and June 18 (final adoption). Councilmembers may continue to refine budget priorities as those dates approach.
- - -

Tuesday, April 22, 2025

Council Moves Forward With Plan to Restore Vistoso Pond--Here's How It Happened

Council approves 2.5-acre pond after Barrett’s emotional appeal
The Oro Valley Town Council voted 4-2 last week to approve construction of a 2.5-acre pond at the Vistoso Trails Nature Preserve. The motion, introduced by Vice Mayor Melanie Barrett, focused on restoring the pond this year using reclaimed water, with additional amenities to be added in later years as funding allows.  Barrett called the site’s current condition unacceptable and said restoring the pond would build momentum for the entire preserve. “Abandoning the pond was never an option,” she said.  (Read more about the pond.)

Residents showed strong support
More than 20 residents spoke at the meeting, nearly all in favor of the larger pond. Many called the area a “blighted eyesore” and recalled the pond’s former appeal. Several voiced frustration over what they viewed as years of delay and inequity in town spending. One resident urged the Council to “make this the showplace and the beautiful place that it can and should be.” Most supported the idea of restoring the pond first and adding other features later as funds become available.

Staff raised concerns...cost, 
in-house construction limits, and reclaimed water availability 
Town staff and consultants did not oppose the project outright, but raised concerns about long-term costs, water use, and legal limits on in-house construction. 
Water and maintenance cost
For example, Parks and Recreation Director Rosalyn Epting and consultant Rebecca Field noted that the desert garden alternative would avoid water and maintenance expenses. 
Legal ability of town to do the construction
One of the things that Mayor Barrett wanted was for the town to do more of the work itself.  She surmised that this would save cost. However, this may not be possible.  Public Works Director Paul Kiesler explained that state law restricts the extent to which municipalities can self-perform construction and said the town typically hires outside firms for that work.  Under Arizona Revised Statutes § 34-605, municipalities must contract out most public construction projects beyond $1 million. The law is designed to prevent local governments from competing with private industry. As a result, while Oro Valley can manage and oversee construction, it cannot perform the physical work itself beyond limited exceptions. In practical terms, this means that even if the town supervises the pond project in-house, it will still need to hire outside contractors to do the actual building.
Reclaimed water present and future availability
Water Director Peter Abraham told the Council that Oro Valley is already using its full allotment of reclaimed water, which it purchases from Tucson Water. He noted that Tucson is planning to build an Advanced Water Purification facility that would divert up to 20% of its reclaimed supply into potable water production, potentially starting in 2031. If that happens, Oro Valley would need to adjust how reclaimed water is allocated across all recreational facilities—including golf courses, Naranja Park, and the Vistoso pond—since the resource is shared town-wide. The Tucson Water project, however, is far from certain. Although $86 million in funding was approved—much of it secured at the last minute in January through a federal grant—its future remains unclear. A lot can happen between now and 2031.

Nonetheless, council approved pond and chose action over further delays
The approved motion reflects a practical compromise. The four councilmembers who voted in favor—Barrett, Jones-Ivey, Nicolson, and Robb—chose not to ignore the pleas of residents or miss the opportunity to build something with lasting value for the entire community. Instead, they opted to move forward with construction of the pond this year, focusing solely on that core element while deferring additional amenities for future consideration.
- - -

Tuesday, December 10, 2024

Could A "Look-See" At A Water Feature Further Delay Restoring The Vistoso Trails Nature Preserve?

A "water feature" will be considered
Last week, the Oro Valley Town Council voted 6-1 to explore the feasibility of creating a water feature at the Vistoso Trails Nature Preserve. The proposed feature would be built at the site of the former golf course pond, which has been out of operation for six years. 

This decision directs town staff to amend the current contract with consultant Kimley-Horn to obtain a design and cost estimate for the potential project. According to town manager Wilkins, this new directions should not change the cost of a consulting project that is currently underway.  The consulting contract is $150,000. To date, $85,000 has been spent.

"Look See"pauses restoration process
The proposal was spearheaded by Council Members Josh Nicolson and Melanie Barrett. Nicolson cited several reasons for considering this option, including strong community support, the potential aesthetic and recreational value of a water feature, and the opportunity to transform the disused pond into a vibrant community asset. Barrett added that having detailed cost estimates would enable the council to make an informed decision while balancing fiscal responsibility. 

The decision represents a "hold" on the council's November decision to move forward with a plan that included at Desert Garden in the area where the water feature would be.

Residents want a water feature explored

At the meeting, residents spoke in favor of the measure, emphasizing the historical and emotional significance of the pond as a community gathering place and highlighting its potential benefits for mental health, wildlife habitats, and accessibility. Rosa Daly, whose advocacy led to the measure being reconsidered, remarked, “When my children were younger, we had a beautiful golf course as our backdrop. It breaks my heart to see the area in its current state. Reintroducing a water feature would be a win for the community.” Another resident, Chris Westermeyer, said, “Whatever we do with that area, it’s got to be for the citizens. Let’s make it beautiful, something the community can enjoy, and not just another eyesore.”

Opposition from Mayor Winfield
Mayor Joe Winfield cast the lone dissenting vote. He opposed the measure due to concerns about water conservation, maintenance costs, and the potential conflict with the town’s ordinance against ornamental water use. Winfield pointed out that previous studies estimated that restoring the pond could require up to 76 acre-feet of water annually and an ongoing maintenance cost of approximately $70,000 per year. Additionally, an earlier estimate placed the initial cost of restoring the pond at $3 million. He argued that these expenses could strain the town’s resources and were not aligned with Oro Valley’s commitment to fiscal and environmental responsibility.

Winfield also reiterated the council’s earlier decision to focus on restoring the area to a natural Sonoran Desert landscape, which he believes reflects the community’s long-term vision for the preserve. He expressed concern that revisiting this decision could delay progress on the overall project.

Next fall restoration start now in question
The council’s decision to revisit the inclusion of a water feature has introduced a potential for further delay in the Vistoso Trails Nature Preserve restoration project, a delay already several years in the making. The target for getting started on the restoration was next fall. That's the planting season. If you miss that season, you have to wait another year. There is a question as to whether or not that can be achieved now because...

There may not be time to get a plan in place for the planting season
Two key factors could push back the start of the restoration. First, we estimate that Kimley-Horn will not report back to the council until February.  At that point, the council must decide whether to include the water feature in its plans or proceed with the original concept of a desert garden. This decision is critical—missing the fall planting season would push the project back by an entire year.

And the project can not start until the grant is approved...Grant approval is not certain and it takes time
Second, grant approval takes time. Town staff highlighted that obtaining state grants, such as the Land and Water Conservation Fund grant, is a lengthy and unpredictable process. Preparing and submitting an application typically takes two months, while approval can take eight months or more. For instance, a current grant for non-motorized trails submitted in March 2024 remains unapproved nine months later. Additionally, no work can begin until the grant is approved. If the approval process extends beyond the fall planting season, the restoration will face another year-long setback.

An uphill struggle...More tomorrow
At the conclusion of the discussion, after the vote was taken, Council Member Joyce Jones-Ivey cautioned the audience that this vote did not approve a water feature but only approved gathering information to determine whether such a feature is viable.  We think that's a wise caution because getting approval of water feature from this town council is going to an uphill struggle. Will tell you why tomorrow.
- - -

Tuesday, September 10, 2024

Shake Up the Council: Massive Undervoting Signaled Strong Support for Newcomers

Most voters cast only two, and not three votes
In the 2024 Oro Valley Council election, the vast majority of voters made a deliberate choice: Instead of voting for the allowed three candidates, 70% chose to vote for only two. The two candidates they overwhelmingly supported were Mary Murphy and Elizabeth Robb, who together received 4,800 more votes than incumbents Tim Bohen and Mo Greene. This gave them a significant 30% voting advantage in a four-person race. It’s likely that some voters paired Greene with Murphy or Bohen with Robb in their selections, but most decided not to cast their third vote.

Demonstrating a desire for new leadership
The clear message from voters in 2024 was: "We want fresh thinking on the council." Although incumbent Mo Greene was re-elected, it seems to be more due to the availability of an additional seat and a lack of a strong newcomer opponent rather than strong voter support. Greene received nearly 2,000 fewer votes than either of the two newcomers, suggesting that his presence on the council is more a result of circumstance than a strong voter mandate.

Golf Course stance cost Bohen the election

Greene narrowly defeated Bohen by 556 votes, with 542 of those votes coming from the three precincts around the town’s municipal golf courses. Bohen, known for his critical stance on the financial transparency of the town's golf operations, evidently lost support in these areas. However, his position didn’t gain him additional votes elsewhere in the community, indicating that most voters are indifferent to the golf course issue. This outcome highlights a key lesson from this election.

A shift in voter sentiment from the 2022 Election
The 2024 Council election results are a stark contrast to those of 2022, when voters clearly supported the continuation of the current council's direction by re-electing the three incumbents—Barrett, Nicolson, and Jones Ivey—with a 4,700-vote plurality, an 18% advantage in a six-person race. The number of ballots with less than three council votes in the 2024 election was notably higher, with 70% of voters opting not to use their third vote, compared to just 15% under-voting in 2022.

The new members will be seated on council in early November.
- - -
Editor Note: An “undervote” occurs in an election when a voter selects fewer candidates than the number allowed for a particular race. For example, if voters are permitted to choose up to three candidates but only select one or two, those unselected slots are considered undervotes. The undervote is calculated by subtracting the total number of votes cast for all open positions from the total number of votes that could have been submitted. In our analysis, we divided that number by the number of ballots cast to determine the percent of ballots that contained less than three votes.  

Tuesday, July 23, 2024

Greene Helps Make Town Staff 4% Pay Raise A Reality, Ignoring Financial Warnings...Failing To Participate In Discussion

Town Staff Gets Big Pay Increase 
This year’s budget includes a whopping 4% increase across the board for all employees. That’s the highest level ever given, in a year in which the council was warned that revenues are going to be tight in the future. 

Greene, Joyce-Ivey, Solomon and Winfield supported big increase
That increase was explicitly approved by a slim council majority at the June 19 council meeting, a meeting in which the council approved the $151.2 million fiscal 2025 Budget. Vice-Mayor Barrett had argued in favor of the historical 3% increase.  Council Members Bohen and Nicolson voiced their support for that.

Town “Spreads the Peanut Butter” when it comes to pay raises... No performance based awards...No incentive to get better

When it comes to staff pay raises, Oro Valley spreads the peanut butter! Everybody gets the same percent increase regardless of their performance. 

This contrasts with private sector practice where, as noted by Vice Mayor Barrett and Council Member Bohen, employees are paid based on their performance. As Council Member Nicolson noted at that meeting, who works in the public sector under the across-the-board pay philosophy: “I get the same raises, still same pay, not really a whole lot of incentive to improve.”

Barrett: Individual performance should be individually awarded
“I think it’s important to have some performance-based measures because I think that helps encourage our good employees, and we can help identify the employees that are most likely flight risks. That’s something that’s done regularly throughout all of the private sector and efficient places in other sectors as well,” said Vice Mayor Barrett.

Votava: No. That might make some people unhappy
Town Human Resource Director Andy Votava does not think that is a good idea: “So, in my mind, I don’t think we’re well-equipped to implement a pay-for-performance system because the danger or the hazard is that if we don’t do it well, some employees may take issue with that. Potentially, anybody can file a lawsuit, but it could lead to complaints.” 

Greene supported this massive increase in spending though he failed to even participate in the discussion
Mo Greene, who is running for reelection, claims to be fiscally responsible. However, his actions, including his decision to support this 4% across-the-board pay raise despite looming financial constraints, demonstrate the opposite. He was so disinterested in the conversation on the pay increase that he did not participate in it. Not one word!

Indeed, Greene's disregard for fiscal responsibility was evident when, at the Sun City forum, he was asked how he would demonstrate fiscal responsibility. He merely echoed Council Member Solomon's statement in a May council meeting: "We need to separate our wants from our needs." Greene then referenced something he did 20 years ago while working the New England Journal of Medicine, without citing any actions he has taken on the council in the past four years. That's because there were no examples to cite. 

Next Tuesday's election is a clear opportunity for voters to hold him accountable for his demonstrated lack of fiscal responsibility. 
- - -
(Source: June 19, 2024 Oro Valley Town Council Meeting, Item 5)

Tuesday, June 18, 2024

The Desperate Tactics of Candidate Harry "Mo" Greene

Faced with a record of doing nothing during his four years on council, Mo Greene chooses the low road
Candidate Mo Greene has seemingly concluded that he cannot compete with candidate Tim Bohen on a straightforward basis. Both are current council members. Both are vying for a seat on council. Bohen is running on the issues.  Greene, on the other hand, has resorted to going after Bohen in a most unusual way.

Greene "plays the victim"
Greene has resorted to portraying himself as a victim, alleging to one reliable source that Bohen has threatened to kill him. This claim is ridiculous. If Bohen had indeed made such a threat, Greene would have reported it to the police immediately. Filing police reports on Bohen is a common tactic used by his compadre and current Councilmember Steve Solomon. Greene has not presented any evidence to support his accusation. And he has filed no such report.  Greene was "so afraid" of Bohen that he asked for, but did not get, police protection at last week's Sun City candidate forum.  Trust us. Greene survived nicely. Just like Bohen's supposed threat, nothing happened. It's all smoke.

...cover up four years of doing nothing on council
The core issue for Greene is his lack of accomplishments on which to campaign. During four years on the Town Council, he has achieved virtually nothing, as evidenced by the panel at right, listing his accomplishments. 

Desperate to come up with something he did, he grabs onto the work of others...
Last week, at the Sun City Candidate Forum, Greene was so desperate to demonstrate that he actually did something in his four years on council that he claimed credit for an elevator that is being added to the community center. It was not his idea. The idea came from former Oro Valley resident Jim Horne, who embarrassed the council into doing something in 2022.  Interestingly, Candidate Bill Rodman made a big deal about it during his failed campaign in 2022.

It took until March 1, 2023, for the council to act to approve an elevator. The motions needed for this were made by Vice Mayor Barrett and seconded by Council Member Nicolson.  All seven Council Members, including Bohen and Greene, voted to approve. The vote was the extent of Greene's involvement. 

The only notable action Greene took in his four years on council was to second every motion made by Councilmember Solomon.

Tomorrow: "Candidate Greene Discusses His Goal's on Council and More..."
- - -