Showing posts with label New Taxes and Fee. Show all posts
Showing posts with label New Taxes and Fee. Show all posts

Tuesday, January 20, 2026

Oro Valley Council Divided as Two New Taxes Are Rejected

Council rejects two proposed taxes
Last week, the Oro Valley Town Council rejected two proposed new taxes: A commercial rental tax and a telecommunications tax. The measures were voted down by four councilmembers. 

Council members cite lack of demonstrated need and need for more though vetting of spending and spending priorities
The reasoning varied. In general, Councilmembers Barrett, Murphy, Nicolson, and Robb said the Council and Town staff need to demonstrate more clearly that a financial shortfall will occur in 2030 and that new taxes are the only viable solution.  Councilmember Murphy summarized the concerns of those opposed, stating, “To my knowledge, there still hasn’t been an audit regarding operational efficiency since we first started talking about this. … I absolutely believe that our residents and our businesses deserve that before we talk about taxes.”

Business community raised concerns

Opposition was also expressed by the Greater Oro Valley Chamber of Commerce, which represents more than 500 businesses. Chamber President Kristin Sharp said, “It’s already more expensive to do business here, and enacting these taxes would only widen that gap.” In addition, comments from mayoral candidate Mark Napier, read into the record, reflected concerns that the Town may be facing a structural imbalance between revenues and expenditures and that the issue warrants closer examination before new taxes are adopted. 

And Vice Mayor Barrett "set the record straight"
Vice Mayor Barrett responded to criticism from former Council member Joe Hornat, who alleged that Council spending created the Town’s financial challenges. “I do not think that Oro Valley is at a crisis point in any way, shape, or form,” Barrett said, cautioning against characterizing the situation as urgent.  Barrett accurately reflected the facts. The spending Hornat cited was addressed by reducing costs elsewhere, particularly by what she described as excessive golf-related losses incurred during Hornat’s tenure. She noted that this Council paid down the police pension debt inherited from Hornat's Council.  Barrett reminded the group that the most recent tax increase was a half-cent sales tax increase enacted during Hornat’s time on the Council.

No clear path forward
The discussion highlighted a split within the Council on how to proceed. Mayor Winfield has said he believes Town staff are doing a strong job managing costs and operating efficiently,. It appears that he does not believe that an independent comprehensive review of spending and priorities is necessary. Winfield, along with Councilmember Greene, expressed confidence at the meeting that Town staff can work through the situation and framed support for the proposed taxes as a way to address long-term financial obligations proactively.

Strategic planning session may test those differences
Whether those differing views will be addressed in the Council’s tomorrow's council strategic planning session remains an open question. The Town has not published the agenda. We do not know how the agenda was developed or the extent to which it was shaped by Town management. As a result, it remains unclear whether the session will include a broad examination of spending levels and priorities and a critical review of the Town’s long-range financial forecasts. 
- - -

Friday, January 16, 2026

Bits and Pieces

Council rejects two of three new taxes
Wednesday night, the Oro Valley Town Council took action on three proposed new taxes. Council approved a commercial use tax, but voted not to approve the proposed telecommunications tax or the proposed commercial rental tax. LOVE will provide a more detailed summary of the Council discussion and votes in next Tuesday’s article.

Arizona State School for Deaf and Blind to move to Copper Creek facility
It looks like the Copper Creek Elementary School Building, which Amphi is closing at the end of this school year, won’t be vacant for long.  The Arizona State Schools for the Deaf and the Blind (ASDB) plans to move its Tucson campus into the Copper Creek facility under a proposed multi-year lease with the Amphitheater School District. ASDB officials have said the move would allow the state agency to rightsize Tucson operations moving to the existing school campus rather than maintaining the larger, older facility on Speedway in Tucson. 

"The goal of this move is: (1) long-term sustainability of the agency and the Tucson campus, so that students continue to receive exceptional education opportunities; and (2) decrease operational/overhead costs, in order to have more resources for students and teachers."

According to ASDB, staff and students will move to the facility this summer.  The fall semester will begin at that location. The site will be repurposed for specialized education.  The move provides certainty to the  town and to the residents of Copper Creek that the facility will continue to a well maintained facility. Read more about their decision to move to Oro Valley here.

Town receives land gift... will likely be added to trails system
Also Wednesday, The Oro Valley Town Council approved a gift agreement to accept two parcels of undeveloped desert land adjacent to Honey Bee Canyon Park. Deputy Town Manager Chris Cornelison explained that the donation consists of roughly 33 acres of natural desert, offered at no cost, with property taxes current. The land is zoned as open space under the Rancho Vistoso PAD and includes existing informal trails. The land will be held by the Town for possible future inclusion in broader parks and trails planning efforts. The next step is for staff to complete standard due diligence, including title review and preparation of the deed, with no obligation for the Town to make improvements or incur expenses related to the property. mmCouncil members expressed support, noting that the donation complements Honey Bee Canyon Park. The Council unanimously approved the resolution, with a 6–0 vote.  

Police gain access to statewide investigative data system
Wednesday, the Town Council unanimously approved an agreement allowing the Oro Valley Police Department to participate in a state-supported law enforcement records management and analytics system. Police staff said the system will give OVPD access to data from other law enforcement agencies that do not share the same records platform, improving investigations and officer safety by providing more complete background and contact information. The system will be funded through a one-year state grant administered by the Arizona Department of Administration. In response to council questions, staff said the system meets all criminal justice data privacy standards and that the Town is not required to continue participation if grant funding ends

Council adopts state-mandated zoning code changes
Also Wednesday, the Town Council approved updates to the zoning codes required by recent State of Arizona law changes. We previously reported on these changes. Planning staff explained that the amendments formalize administrative approval for certain non-discretionary development and design review applications, clarify who may appeal administrative decisions and under what conditions, allow earlier submittal of grading and drainage plans, and correct minor code errors. The discussion also addressed a change requiring conditional use permits for building height increases in private school and parks and open space zoning districts, placing final approval authority with the Council. Council members noted that while many of the updates are state-mandated, staff worked to retain local oversight where possible. Changes had been previously approved by the Planning and Zoning Commission.

Phased stormwater rate increase approved... will support system maintenance
Later in the meeting, the Council approved a phased increase to the stormwater utility base rate, adopting Resolution R26-02. The increase raises the residential base rate by 67 cents per month, from $4.50 to $5.17, effective July 1, 2026. Two additional increases were also approved, another 67 cents effective July 1, 2027, bringing the rate to $5.84, and a final increase effective July 1, 2028, bringing the base rate to $6.50, a total $2 increase over three years. Commercial properties will see proportional increases based on impervious surface area. Staff said the stormwater base rate has not been adjusted since 2016, a point previously reported in LOVE, and that the phased approach was designed to limit impacts on residents while ensuring the utility can fund operations, meet regulatory requirements, and maintain required reserves. The storm utility fee is part of your monthly water bill.

Ballots for RTA Next all-mail election coming soon
An all-mail election is coming up on March 10 for Pima County voters to decide the future of regional transportation funding through the RTA Next plan. Proposition 418 asks voters to approve a new 20-year regional transportation plan covering roadway, transit, and safety projects across the region. Proposition 419 asks voters to continue the existing half-cent sales tax that funds the Regional Transportation Authority, with no increase in the tax rate. Ballots will be mailed automatically to registered voters beginning February 11 and must be received by 7:00 p.m. on March 10. There will be no in-person voting; participation is by mail only.
- - -

Wednesday, January 14, 2026

Does Oro Valley Really Need Three New Taxes?

Why some say approving three new taxes now may be premature
Yesterday we reported that town staff have asked the Oro Valley Town Council to consider approving three new taxes—a commercial rental tax, a telecommunications tax, and a use tax—that together are projected to generate between $930,000 and $1.88 million annually. 

Tonight, the council will consider approving these taxes.  While staff argue the taxes are needed to address long-term financial pressures, some believe approval may be premature based on what has and has not been analyzed to date.

Today, we present the alternative case for caution.

The projected funding gap is based on assumptions that may or may not come to fruition... alternative scenarios not considered
The current discussion was triggered by a long-range financial forecast presented last year that identified a potential structural funding gap beginning in fiscal year 2029–30. That forecast was based on a host of assumptions related to future spending growth, revenue trends, and service levels. Forecasts are widely used as planning tools, but they are not predictions. Some suggest that policy decisions with long-term consequences, such as new recurring taxes, should be informed by a range of alternative projection scenarios that explore different “what if” conditions.

Cost-control efforts are described but not fully documented...perhaps "reengineering" is needed
Town staff state that budget reductions have already occurred and will continue, and that reallocations within existing funds have been used to manage rising costs. However, the materials provided to Council do not document a zero-based budgeting review, a department-by-department operational analysis, or an independent efficiency or performance audit. Without this level of detail, some believe it is difficult to assess whether current services are being delivered as efficiently as possible or whether additional internal adjustments could be considered.

New revenue is proposed before structural changes are evaluated
The proposed taxes would create new, ongoing revenue streams. Once adopted, such taxes are rarely reduced or eliminated. Some argue that before committing to new permanent taxes, the Town could examine whether structural changes—such as staffing models, program scope, technology use, or service prioritization—might slow long-term cost growth or improve efficiency.

Business impacts are not fully explored
Two of the three proposed taxes—the commercial rental tax and the use tax—would primarily affect businesses, while the telecommunications tax would affect both residents and businesses. The staff materials do not include an economic impact analysis, a competitiveness review, or an evaluation of how the proposed taxes might influence business behavior over time. Some note that even relatively modest taxes can affect business location, expansion, and investment decisions, particularly when layered onto existing costs.

Alignment with other towns is context, not analysis
Staff note that neighboring communities already impose commercial rental, telecommunications, and use taxes, and that Oro Valley is an outlier in not doing so. While this comparison provides useful context, some believe alignment alone does not constitute a full justification. Communities differ in service expectations, cost structures, and fiscal strategies, and comparisons do not address whether Oro Valley has fully examined other available options.

Projected revenue generated is de minimus ... could be "covered" without any change in service levels
The amount of revenue projected from the proposed taxes is relatively small when viewed in the context of the Town’s overall budget, roughly $2 million within a $150 million budget. Some suggest this scale raises the question of whether improvements in operational efficiency or adjustments to non-essential spending could address the projected 2030 shortfall before new taxes are adopted.
- - -

Tuesday, January 13, 2026

Town Staff Advocate For Three New Taxes

Staff provides council with lengthy discussion of why new taxes are needed now
This Wednesday, the Oro Valley Town Council will consider whether to move forward with three new taxes: a commercial rental tax, a telecommunications tax, and a use tax. According to staff estimates, the three taxes together would generate between $930,000 and $1.88 million per year, with $1.88 million as the upper bound. The commercial rental tax would apply to leased commercial property and primarily affect businesses, as the Town already charges a 2% rental occupancy tax on residential rentals. The telecommunications tax would apply to communication services and would affect residents and businesses alike. The use tax would apply to Oro Valley business purchases made outside Arizona for which a sales tax should have been collected but was not. These are items a business buys for its own use.

Town staff believe new taxes are necessary at this time for seven reasons.

Projected revenue shortfall in fiscal 2030
The immediate trigger for this discussion was a long-range financial forecast presented last year by Finance Director David Gephart, which showed that, based on a host of assumptions, the Town could face a structural funding gap beginning in fiscal year 2029–30. The forecast indicated that existing revenue sources may not be sufficient to sustain current service levels over the long term as growth-related revenues slow and operating costs continue to rise. Staff identified the need to evaluate potential new, ongoing revenue sources well in advance of that timeframe, leading to the current discussion of possible tax options.

Rising operating and infrastructure costs
Town staff point to sharply rising costs as a primary justification for the new taxes. Inflation has increased the cost of providing core services, including police, parks, public works, and planning. Staff report that General Fund program costs have increased substantially since 2015, while pavement preservation and public safety costs have risen particularly quickly in recent years. According to staff, these cost pressures are ongoing and cannot be addressed through one-time solutions.

Slowing or constrained revenue growth
Staff also cite weakening revenue trends. Sales tax revenues, which fund a large share of Town operations, have shown little growth in recent years and have declined slightly. At the same time, Oro Valley is nearing residential build-out, which limits future growth-related revenues. Staff argue that this combination creates a structural imbalance between revenues and expenditures that must be addressed with new recurring revenue sources.

State actions limiting local revenues
Another justification raised by staff involves actions taken by the State Legislature. Changes to state income tax rates have reduced the amount of state-shared revenue flowing to municipalities, including Oro Valley. Staff emphasize that these decisions are outside the Town’s control and have permanently reduced an important General Fund revenue source.

Unfunded obligations and capital pressures
Staff also highlight new and existing obligations that lack dedicated funding. These include increased transfers to the Highway Fund to offset rising road maintenance costs and the recent purchase of a new police headquarters that currently has no funding identified for reconfiguration and build-out. Staff state that without additional revenue, these pressures will continue to strain the General Fund.

Alignment with neighboring communities’ tax structures
Finally, staff argue that Oro Valley is an outlier among nearby communities. Marana, Sahuarita, and Tucson already impose commercial rental taxes, telecommunications taxes, and use taxes. Oro Valley currently does not. Staff contend that adopting these taxes would align the Town’s tax structure with neighboring jurisdictions and capture revenues that other communities already rely on.

Staff believe they are doing all they can to keep spending under control
In their materials to Council, staff state that budget reductions have already occurred, according to staff, and will continue as part of the upcoming budget cycle to address what they describe as structural imbalances. Staff cite reallocations within existing funds, ongoing efforts to manage rising costs through the annual budget process, and steps taken to absorb inflation-driven increases in areas such as pavement preservation and public safety. While acknowledging that costs continue to rise, staff maintain that these measures are necessary but not sufficient on their own, leading them to recommend new revenue sources to sustain current service levels.

Tomorrow: An alternative case for further analysis and consideration
To date, no organization or individual has presented a clear, comprehensive case against the proposed taxes. An alternative perspective can nevertheless be developed from the existing record, and LOVE will present that perspective in tomorrow’s article.
- - -

Friday, November 7, 2025

Bits and Pieces

Running For Office? Your candidate packet awaits 
Oro Valley residents thinking about running for mayor or Town Council in 2026 can now pick up a Candidate Handbook from the Town Clerk’s Office at Town Hall, 11000 N. La Cañada Drive. Appointments can be made by emailing Mike Standish at mstandish@orovalleyaz.gov or calling 520-229-4700. Three council seats and the mayor’s seat are on the ballot. Candidates must be at least 18 years old, qualified to vote, and have lived in Oro Valley for at least one year before the election. Nomination papers can be filed March 9 – April 6, 2026, with between 525 and 1,050 signatures required. The Primary Election is August 4, 2026, and newly elected officials are expected to be sworn in shortly after the General Election on November 3, 2026. (Source: Town of Oro Valley Media Release)

Council to seek public input on proposed new taxes
By a 4–3 vote, the Oro Valley Town Council agreed Wednesday night to post notice of intent to adopt three taxes: A phased-in Commercial Rental Tax; a Telecommunications Tax; and a Use Tax. This step begins a state-required 60-day public notice and comment period, ending with a potential Council vote on January 14, 2026 to approve or reject any of the taxes. If enacted as proposed, Oro Valley’s 0% commercial rental tax would phase up to 2.5% over three years, the telecommunications tax would increase from 0% to 2.5%, and a new 2.5% use tax would be added to align with neighboring jurisdictions like Tucson and Marana. Councilmembers Barrett, Murphy, and Nicholson opposed moving forward, citing concerns over timing, business impacts, and the need for more cost-saving reviews of town operations. Staff will post a public notice of these proposed taxes on the town website on November 15. The council will make a decision on each of the three taxes at it's January 14 meeting. 

Where there is a will, there is a way
At Wednesday’s Council meeting, several residents expressed concern about the new no parking signs installed along Calle Buena Vista and parts of Calle Concordia. She said her household was not notified about the change and has seen no parking issues near their home in the past four and a half years. While she supports signage near OVCN to address overflow parking, she believes the signs further south are unnecessary, unsightly, and out of character with the neighborhood. Despite all the signage, which she described as an eyesore, we noted that church attendees were still parking on Calle Buena Vista this past Sunday [see panel right]. 

As written: New Use Tax would legally apply to individuals as well as businesses
If adopted, residents have been told by town staff that Oro Valley’s proposed use tax would apply mainly to businesses and not to residents. Businesses would be required to report out-of-state purchases where no local sales tax was paid. These are captured on regular tax filings submitted through the Arizona Department of Revenue, which may also conduct audits to ensure compliance. Town staff has repeatedly stated that the use tax would not be enforced on individual residents, and there are no plans to audit personal purchases. However, as technology advances, future governments may find it easier to track and enforce such taxes more broadly; though doing so would likely raise questions about privacy and require higher-level policy changes.

Film producer urges creation of Oro Valley film commission
Hollywood film producer Mark Headley spoke during Call to Audience segment of Wednesday's council meeting. He talked about the economic benefits of attracting movie production to the town. Drawing on his years of experience in the industry and Arizona’s past success as a filming location, he recommended the creation of a local film commission. Headley said such a commission could be inexpensive to set up and would complement efforts by the Arizona Film Office. He added that film productions typically leave about one-third of their budgets in the communities where they shoot.  Locally, both the Tucson and Marana film commissions. Film Tucson reported last year that filmmaking in the Tucson region generates between $9 million and $12 million annually in economic impact (hotels, restaurants, crews).

Council approves funds for police headquarters purchase and repairs
Wednesday, the Oro Valley Town Council unanimously approved reallocating $5.45 million from the Capital Fund contingency to cover the purchase and immediate repairs of the new police administration facility at 13101 N. Oracle Road. The purchase, completed for about $3.8 million, will be followed by an estimated $1.65 million in improvements, including HVAC replacement, roofing, stucco and parapet repair, and termite treatment. Vice Mayor Barrett noted she would have preferred some of the funding to be addressed during the next budget cycle but acknowledged the allocation was necessary. The motion passed 7–0, ensuring the building can be secured and preparations begun for future police operations.
- - -