Showing posts with label Crematorium. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Crematorium. Show all posts

Friday, March 6, 2009

What Are The Oro Valley Issues That We Are Concerned About?

In a recent comment, a blogger, commenting with the pseudonym "Concerned Citizen" wrote the following comment, addressed to a relatively new blogger, "OV Citizen."

"OV Citizen"
"Thank you for calling Art out. He is a big voice for what I believe is the minority of Oro Valley residents. Keep it up and hopefully more residents will catch on to what is happening here."

Well, it's nice to know that there are those that believe I am a "big voice," but I should remind everyone as to the following statement on our web site.

About Let Oro Valley Excel

There are many issues confronting the residents of Oro Valley, Arizona. Not every issue is of equal concern to every citizen. At least one issue, maybe more, impacts every one of us. Our hope: If we all concern ourselves with the problems encountered by our neighbors, we will have a bigger voice, and hopefully, make a bigger impact on the direction of our town.

Let us briefly note some of the issues (in no particular sequence) that we have and will continue to address. I will leave it up to our readers to determine if we are a negative or positive impact on our community.

ISSUES OF CONCERN

1) Naranja Park Bond Issue --- We took a stand AGAINST the bond in that it was much too costly, and much more than was required. Keep in mind the mayor wanted not $48.6 million, but $160 million for this park bond. The voters soundly defeated the bond.

2) Golder Ranch Fire District--- We were against the merger of Rural Metro Fire Dep't & GRFD that came about after a previous council made a decision to allow GRFD to annex Town Hall. As a result of the subsequent merger, thousands of Oro Valley residents saw their fire service bills escalate by 100% or in many cases, much more.

3) The Oro Valley Marketplace--- We were outspoken critics of a previous council's decision to give Vestar a $23.2 million subsidy without a clue as to what retailers would be coming. As we all now know, Vestar stuck us with a Walmart, hardly the "unique" shopping experience they convinced us was coming.

4) The "Crematorium"--- We sided with the residents in close proximity to this facility as they had major health issue concerns due to the potential mercury emissions.

5) The 60' Hotel at Innovation Park--- We spoke in opposition to the town council's actions allowing a 60' hotel where no hotel was permitted and no structure over 36' was allowed. It was, however, approved.

6) The Utility Tax--- This tax was passed in 2006, after two prior council votes had it defeated and AFTER a budget was approved. The tax, ostensibly approved to hire 18 1/2 new personnel which were requested, but not necessarily required.

7) Utility Tax 2009--- Speaking out, not only on the blog, but in addressing the council in a very "unfriendly" environment of police, family & friends, we spoke in opposition to renewing this tax. Our position was not based on the cost to the taxpayers, but the principle issue that the tax was initially approved for a 2 year period, and now it appears it may be a permanent fixture.

8) The Ford Property--- When a developer threatened to sue individual council members if he was precluded from building a 36' high office complex, almost literally in some neighbors backyard, we publicized this fact. Hopefully, not by anything we have done, but economic conditions will save the neighbor's property values and views, as the parcel has been put up for sale.

9) Library--- Although the "Friends of The Library" and other well meaning residents argued against allowing Pima County to take on the financial liability of our library, we endorsed allowing that to occur, as it would negate what is effectively, double taxation of the citizens.

10) Miller Ranch Property--- When we were advised that a developer was looking for a General Plan Amendment to build an apartment complex on part of this parcel, we helped publicize the issue and advised the neighbors on a course of action.

11) Arroyo Grande--- One of the issues we publicized was TEP's intention to build an electrical substation through the wildlife corridor of the Arroyo Grande parcel, in close proximity to many of the neighbors in Sun City and adjacent communities.

12) Kai Property--- When Marana Council Member Herb Kai proposed plans for a General Plan Amendment for the 271 acre parcel he owns on Palisades road, we took on the issue. Subsequently, the property owner "pulled" his General Plan Amendment.

13) Travel Expenses For The Mayor--- After Mayor Loomis took a trip to visit some European Bio Tech companies at the town's expense, we questioned if this was something that benefited, not the mayor, with a free trip, but the taxpayers. We pointed out, that a full report of this sojourn was never submitted by the mayor. Subsequently, the council voted to put some restrictions on traveling.

14) Oro Valley "Donations"--- We did any number of postings on the merits ---or more appropriately, the lack of merits of continuing to give "bundles" of cash to the likes of TREO, GOVAC, Tucson Convention Bureau, etc. Some of these "donations" have since been eliminated or at least cut back.

15) Bed Tax "Kickback"--- We pointed out that a previous council opted to put in a $900,000 water system, plus a bed tax rebate to entice the Ritz-Carlton to Stone Canyon. The resort pulled out of Oro Valley and moved to Dove Mountain, Marana. As a result of that deal, that council decided to give the Hilton El Conquistador Resort the same 2% "kickback." To date that has cost us in excess of $3 million. Fortunately, this giveaway ends next year.

16) Endorsing Candidates--- We took on a legal challenge from the town when the Town Clerk said we must form a Political Committee as a result of our endorsing two candidates that subsequently soundly defeated incumbents and are presently serving on the council. The town backed off when The Goldwater Institute took up our cause.

Certainly, in the two years, plus that our blog has been a part of the Oro Valley community, we have taken on contentious issues, but continue to always try and offer rational reasons as to why we take a position.

Paraphrasing Abraham Lincoln, we know that "not everyone will agree with everything we say all the time," and we are prepared for the criticism. All we ask, is please try doing so in an acceptable manner.

Thanks for your indulgence. Your comments, as always, are welcome.

Art


Wednesday, February 20, 2008

Oro Valley Neighbor Michelle Saxer Speaks Out

In a letter to The Explorer Feb 20, Michelle Saxer speaks out.

Councilman Parish said many times on Wednesday 2/6 during the town council meeting, “Take it to the constituents. Let them decide.”That, I concur, Mr. Parish, is a wonderful suggestion. Your words suggest that maybe you see that people / voters are your most potent resource.

How will the voters vote who have been impacted by this council’s decision to build a crematory a quarter of a mile from their subdivision? The February 2008 issue of Desert Leaf, in an article written by Loranne DarConte, points out that 16 percent of mercury emissions come from cremation. She documents what those subdivisions will be exposed to. Besides threatening their health you are lowering their property values. How do you think Vistoso Vistas and Vista Mirabella feel about the incumbents’ votes for the crematory? Do you think they feel protected by your council, your concern about them?

How do you think voters in Oro Valley will feel that by seducing them to vote for a “high-end store,” you effectively have deceived them by inviting Wal-mart, lowered their quality of life, view, property values and undermined their trust in local government?How is it possible that such an affluent community needs to financially persuade a retailer to come here? They should be knocking at Oro Valley’s door. Do you think this very educated, financially solvent community will feel you value them with this decision?How do you think this very educated, aware population feels when the town attempts to muzzle a citizen’s blog site by manipulating its description as a political organization, negating his right to freedom of speech?

Is this what a progressive, well-heeled, beautiful community wants … an image of a terrified reactionary political body that is closed to difference of opinion? Does the First Amendment work in every place but Oro Valley in the continental U.S.? This smacks of Nazi Germany. Haven’t we learned from history yet? Who will want to come to a community whose government even considers such a thing?

Naranja Park raises still more questions. At the council meeting, Bill Adler restated the results of the study about the park. The constituents are against it.Children need communal recreational facilities. But they don’t need to be built with the price tag of $164 million when there are fundamental services like water, roads and emergency equipment competing for the dollar. How do you think voters will feel if after the expensive survey where you obtained their opinion, you ignore the study and proceed to build the park?

Do you think they will feel appreciated, valued, or important and that you were fiscally responsible in using their tax dollars?The council often talks about the importance of enterprise. But you are forgetting your most valuable resource: the citizens of Oro Valley, whose money pays for its wares. This is what makes community … People with feelings, needs, wants, hopes, dreams, not just a collection of quality homes with beautiful views and owners with expandable wallets. Your most precious resource here is the people … they are the community. The quality of life here depends on the quality of people.

None of those events would entice anyone I know to move here. Just what are you doing to help, support, involve, pay attention to what the community is saying to you? Lose credibility with the community, and Oro Valley nosedives as a desirable place to live. You are seeding the demise of this town by your actions. Do you have to wait until election day to understand that message?

Michelle Saxer

Tuesday, February 12, 2008

Barry Gillaspie Gets Some Support

Dr. Carl Boswell sent me the following e-mail. I called Carl to advise him I would post his email, although he and I disagree on many of the issues he addresses as it concerns Council Member Barry Gillaspie. Rather than comment further, here is Carl Boswell's e-mail. He & I look forward to your comments.
Art
_____________________________________________________________________
Hi Art,
I hope you will accept the following statement for publication in the LOVE
Blog.

First, to let you know where I'm coming from, I'm a knee-jerk liberal, a
cactus hugger, a slow growth supporter, a charter member of the Oro Valley
Neighborhood Coalition, and I served on both General Plan efforts. My
introduction to fighting city hall was the failed effort to save Honey Bee
Canyon. Given that, I'd like to address the unwarranted criticism being
heaped on Barry Gillaspie.

Adding additional capacity to the new Hilton may seem like the proper
response to changing the zoning, but it misses the point. There are a lot
of righteous battles that deserve attention, but this one does not. Even at
60 ft tall, the hotel will still be substantially lower than the Hospital
across the street. The views of the mountains have already been obliterated
by the hospital and Splendido, not to mention the additional developments on
the ridge above El Conquistador. It is not clear to me which views
currently available will be destroyed by this structure? More
significantly, the amount of cold hard cash that moves through Ventana
Medical, the Northwest Medical Center and now Sanofi Aventis is staggering,
and these businesses all need access to high end accommodations and meeting
venues. The addition of the hotel is essentially a gold mine, providing an
income for the Town completely from outside the Town. At the same time it
presents an enticement for more high-tech industry to settle in Oro Valley.
If there was one thing the Town could have done to advance the stated goal
of attracting high-tech industry to Oro Valley, the new Hilton is it.

Concerning the incentive awarded to Sanofi to move into the larger
facility, I agree that it is a pittance when compared with their gross
income. But again, the point of the agreement is missed by such a narrow
negative view. The tax-break was essentially a show of support, which will
not go unnoticed when other clean, high-paying biotech firms consider Oro
Valley in which to set up shop. It would be foolish to not realize that a
LACK of support would also not go unnoticed.

This agreement should in no way be compared to what Vestar got for
bringing in Wal-Mart. That made me so mad I can still hardly talk about it.
If there was anything that made Oro Valley representatives look like
bumpkins, it was that deal. Remember that there are still some council
members that will be coming up for election in the next cycle who supported
this and their names are not Barry Gillaspie.

As for the crematorium, there have been a lot of histrionics about this
commercial operation, and it is baffling that it is being held up as
evidence that council members are inept. There is no legal method for
refusing to allow this business, which will be discreet and certifiably
non-polluting. A lot of folks are uncomfortable with the physical aspects
of human death, but they need to get over it and use some rationale.

If you want to scream about injustices, answer this question: Who
allowed the fire district to charge by the assessed value of a property,
rather than its size?" The answer is the State. Can't you just picture the
lobbying by fire districts to convince legislators that an illogical but
more profitable scheme was the best approach?

Finally, regarding much of the negativity toward Barry, it is worth
considering that diatribes sheltered by anonymity should immediately raise
suspicions of motive. Many of the particularly vitriolic statements seem to
come from just plain grouchy people. The adamant nature of the arguments
bring to mind the phrase "That's my story and I'm sticking to it", implying
an unwillingness to consider alternative ideas. Moreover, there is a clear
lack of understanding (or selective reading) of the General Plan. The
issues are complex, and legal constraints significant. If I could make one
suggestion it would be to take a relaxing deep breath, then actually talk to
Barry about the issues that bother you. You will be impressed with his
knowledge and grasp of the issues, and with his sympathy for those of us who
what Oro Valley to be some place special.

Carl A. Boswell

Wednesday, February 6, 2008

Coming Soon To Rancho Vistoso---"Up In Smoke!"

Thanks to Jeff Latas who took this photo and posted it as a comment on the "Please Register to Vote" Posting on Feb 4.
I thought it would get more attention as a new posting.

This is a Photo of The Adair Funeral Home on Magee road in Oro Valley taken by Jeff on Feb 5.
(Note--I originally said "Feb6." The correct date was Feb5)

As Jeff noted, this is what the neighbors around the new Crematorium on Rancho Vistoso Blvd will have to look forward to.

Even without any mercury concerns, who wants to be anywhere around this black smoke that emanates from a crematorium?



http://www.latasgroup.com/images/burn.jpg

Sunday, February 3, 2008

Wonderful! Helen Dankwerth Wins SAHBA Award. Read About More "Awards."

Isn't it great that The Southern Arizona Homebuilders Association (SAHBA) gave Dankwerth their "elected official" award for 2007?

How did Dankwerth merit this "prestigious award?" After not having Impact Fees for new homes raised since 1996, the Council finally agreed for the need to raise these fees. Rather than raise the fees as initially proposed, Dankwerth joined others and gave in to the Homebuilders "whining" and phased in the increase over a five year period. We're not really sure, but that might be one reason SAHBA "loves" Dankwerth.

That got us thinking----doesn't Dankwerth deserve even more recognition? No doubt! Let's think about a few other "awards" she so richly deserves.

1) LOOKING OUT FOR THE CITIZENS AWARD--- After the Council twice voted down the 4% Utility Tax, Dankwerth spearheaded the drive to push something through. We ended up with a 2% tax on our gas, water & electric bills, thanks to Dankwerth who said: "A half a loaf is better than none at all." Thanks a lot Helen "Taxwerth!"

2) GOLDER RANCH FIRE DISTRICT AWARD--- We're sure Fire Chief John Fink and his GRFD are indebted to Dankwerth who was responsible for the initiative to get GRFD as the SOLE provider for fire service in Oro Valley. The "hell" with the citizens whose bills have gone through the roof since then.

3) THE VESTAR INCENTIVE AWARD--- Back in Nov 2004, Dankwerth emphasized that the final decision on Economic Development Agreements rests with the Town Council according to existing policies. Her vote defeated a motion that would have allowed any Economic Development Agreements to be referable to the voters. And she claims she's an advocate for the people! "Give us a break!"

4) SANOFI-AVENTIS AWARD--- Talk about giving OUR tax money away. At a recent Council meeting Dankwerth had this to say concerning a $360,000 Construction Tax "kickback" to the world's 3rd largest pharmaceutical company with revenues of $39 BILLION: "I'm comfortable in giving them the MINUSCULE" amount of $360,000."

5) "UP IN SMOKE AWARD"--- Dankwerth came through once again, in "burning" the people. Unbeknownst to the citizens, a Crematorium was approved under the guise of a "Memorial Chapel." The citizens whose residences are nearby received zero consideration, which seems to happen much of the time.

6) EMBASSY SUITE AWARD--- The Rancho Vistoso area where Embassy Suites wants to build a hotel has some town codes that should be adhered to. The PAD specifically states "NO Hotel, and NO Structure over 36 feet." Don't you think Dankwerth voted FOR a hotel, and against the recommendation of the P & Z Commission, she helped approve a SIXTY FOOT HOTEL!

Do the voters need any more reasons to "send Dankwerth packing?"

Please----Help in improving Oro Valley for the PEOPLE of Oro Valley.

VOTE FOR ONLY BILL GARNER & SALETTE LATAS.

Art

Saturday, February 2, 2008

Now We Can Get Back To The Important Issues Confronting Oro Valley

It finally appears that all parties----The DeConcini law firm, the OV Town Attorney, Mr Monrad, who initiated it all with his "inquiry," and certainly me, acknowledge our legal right to endorse candidates in accordance with the Az Statutes, without requiring us to form a Political Committee.

That is certainly good news, especially since ballots for the Oro Valley Town Council should start arriving in your mail boxes within the next couple of weeks.

So, as we move forward, we ask all Oro Valley voters to try and familiarize themselves with the three incumbents and two challengers and their positions on the issues. In doing so, we believe you'll come to the same conclusion we have.

ONLY TWO CANDIDATES ARE WORTHY OF YOUR VOTE: BILL GARNER & SALETTE LATAS.

Why? Space does not permit the multitude of reasons. Suffice it to say if you live in Oro Valley and are impacted by one or more of the following, Bill & Salette are your only viable choices.

1) You now have a tax on the necessities of life; gas, water & electric bills.

2) You now are paying Golder Ranch Fire District exorbitant rates as result of the incumbents' actions.

3) You believe it is foolhardy to offer a multi-billion dollar pharmaceutical company $360,000 of our tax money to relocate to larger quarters after being in Oro Valley some 17 years and finding it necessary to expand.

4) Your views of the Catalina mountains are now infringed upon as a result of either a 4 story Splendido or an Ace hardware when you expected a one story office complex.

5) You'll soon have a 60 foot hotel in the Innovation Park area even though the PAD did not permit a hotel nor a structure higher than 36 feet.

6) Your new neighbor on Rancho Vistoso Blvd turns out to be a Crematorium, and when you complained because you had no awareness, the town in essence said, "too late and too bad."

7) You will soon have a 24/7 Wal-Mart Super Center as our "upscale" shopping experience partially because the three incumbents stood idly by when SOVOG sought assistance.

8) You may have a property tax even though the three incumbents want you to believe a Bond Issue in the amount of possibly $154 million is only a "secondary property tax." Once again, they're playing with semantics.

If you need more, let us know.

If you're convinced, remember VOTE FOR BILL GARNER and SALETTE LATAS.

Art

Tuesday, December 4, 2007

Crematorium Landscape Plan Back After Development Review Board Said "No"

The Development Review Board will once again consider the request for the landscape plan for the Vistoso Memorial Chapel at their Dec 11th meeting at 6:00 PM. It is the same request as the one we discussed in a posting this summer to replace walls with berms, as permitted in the OVZCR. However, this review also includes a letter of approval from the Rancho Vistoso HOA,

Keep in mind, this request was already turned down as noted by Oro Valley Planner Pamela Pelletier. Oh yeah. One more thing. Is it just another one one those coincidences that the Rancho Vistoso HOA that now approves this plan is controlled by none other than Vistoso Partners? OUCH!

Here's the text of the notice; "Beverly Harpold Trust, represented by Advantech Facility Design Inc., requests approval of a revision to the approved landscape plans for the Vistoso Memorial Chapel, located at the corner of Rancho Vistoso Blvd. and Vistoso Commerce Loop. If you have any questions about this matter, please contact Pamela J. Pelletier, OV Planner, at (520) 229-4813 or ppelletier@orovalleyaz.gov"

Sunday, August 19, 2007

"LOVE" Responds To A Resident's Complaint

We received an email, a second one, from this blogger with similar content. We thought we'd share it and our response with you. Tell us what you think:

Here’s the email we received:

“Your constant harping on the $23 million giveaway is alienating people. Did you read the letter in the Oro Valley Explorer??? It's over and was done by other people. Why not focus on current issues that have some meaning to the broad majority. Out of curiosity, I'm curious as to whether or not you think a 75 foot hotel in the Tangerine/Oracle area will block anyones views???”

Our Response---

“If you are referring to the letter from "Roberta in Saddlebrooke," yes I read it. Rather than responding, why don't you read the comment from "Vicorian Cowgirl," to the letter which was posted on the blog. Her response is as good as anything I might say.

As far as alienating people, I expect those are the same people who bought into the "story" that Vestar was bringing in a "unique, upscale" mall. Don't you realize that Vestar will pocket almost half of Oro Valley tax revenue that will be cannibalized from our existing retailers? I'm not even talking about the big retailers. What about the small independent shop owners like the bike store, the card shop, the small boutiques. These people, many of whom are Oro Valley residents may lose their businesses as a result of this Wal-Mart competition. And, don't tell me about free enterprise. If Vestar didn't get that giveaway, nobody could argue with their arrival here. But, that is not the case.

And, by the way, in case you missed it, The Goldwater Institute has filed a lawsuit, which, hopefully, if successful, will negate these giveaways. Are they also "harping?"
Enough on that. As to a 75' hotel at Innovation Park, there is only one issue. Not whether it will impede any views-----the developer acknowledged it would!--- but it violates the code. Do you understand that we have a code that limits the hotel to 36'? Why would the council violate a code at the whim of a developer?

Also, in case you don't know----the previous council violated the code by allowing a 75' hotel in front of Pusch Ridge, on the east side of Oracle road. The issue there was not about impeding people's views, but of impeding the beautiful views of the mountain.
You obviously have a different point of view on the direction Oro Valley should take.

As for your comment, "Why not focus on current issues that have some meaning to the broad majority,'' what issues are you alluding to? Could it be, the Utility Tax, The Golder Ranch Fire Dept annexation, the 4 story Splendido, the potential new row of 21 power lines on Tangerine, the $160 million Loomis wants to spend on his park, the water shortage issue, the crematorium, the town budget, etc.?

Are you reading our blog? I guess not. If you were, you wouldn't make the comment as to "focusing on current issues." That's all we've been doing since our inception! Why not tell me, what issues concern you and "the broad majority" we seem to be "alienating?"

Perhaps, we could address "those" issues."

Thursday, July 5, 2007

AZ Star Reports On Crematorium "Time-Line"

The Arizona Star reports in the July 5 online edition (as we originally did in our posting of June 25,) that the the neighbors who filed a lawsuit against Oro Valley are not liable to pay the crematorium owners (who opted in as intervenor), the $25,000 in court costs they sought.

Perhaps bloggers may be more interested in the "time-line" on this issue, as noted in the accompanied story. Click here to read the article.

Tuesday, July 3, 2007

New Crematorium Issue!

How many of you have been out walking in various neighborhoods and seen the "tiny, little" yellow signs that say; "notice," and are usually high enough for the ants & centipedes to read if they had a magnifying glass?

Well, we've been alerted that one finally appeared on the Rancho Vistoso Crematorium site, and the neighbors aren't happy.

Rather than saying anymore, here's the email we received from one of the neighbors.
Art
*****************************************************************************
As of today July 3, 2007, there is FINALLY a Town of Oro Valley development yellow sign 11" x 17" on the corner of the crematorium site. It seems that the developers Harpold/Wagner are APPEALING the decision of the Design Review Board on June 4, 2007, to the Town Council (Some of us attended that meeting.)

Harpold/Wagner want to have dirt berms instead of concrete block walls around the crematorium site. This will save them money if they don't have to buy concrete blocks and have walls built, AND they won't have to pay to haul away as much dirt. Of course, there is the problem that berms erode into adjoining streets creating a muddy mess, especially during monsoon season. Berms require plantings that take water, and we're in a drought. Berms may not screen the view of the crematorium as well, either. But Harpold/Wagner want their way again!

The sign says it was posted June 25th. We saw it for the first time today and we have been past the site almost daily.

The meeting for the appeal is Wednesday, July 18, 2007 at 7:00 p.m. in the TOV Council Room. Members of the public are invited to speak. If you have questions you may email ppelletier@orovalley.net This item is referred to as OV12-05-35B. WE HOPE YOU WILL BE ABLE TO ATTEND AND SPEAK UP!!!!!

Monday, June 25, 2007

Crematorium---Follow-Up

Most of our readers will recall that a group of our neighbors attempted to have their complaint about a crematorium scheduled to be built in their neighborhood heard by the Oro Valley Board of Adjustment.

When the town refused, the group known as "NIMBY" saw fit to go to court. The owners of the crematorium, the Harpold/Wagner Family joined the suit as Intervenors.

On May 10th, Judge Kelly decided against the residents, allowing the crematorium to proceed. That should have ended the litigation. However, the crematorium owners, who, as we said, entered the case as Intervenors, filed an application against the homeowners for over $25,000 in attorneys' fees.

That hearing was held on June 25th in Pima County Superior Court. Superior Court Judge Kelly ruled that NIMBY would NOT have to pay the Harpold/Wagner Family Attorneys' fees.

One small victory for the people!

Monday, June 11, 2007

Some Questions for Oro Valley's eService Citizen Portal

Now that the Town of Oro Valley has a means of being more responsive to the citizens of the community with their new "eServices Portal" we thought there may be a few questions one may want to ask.

Questions:

1) How much sales tax revenue has been generated from the Oracle Crossing Development, to date?

2) How much in bed tax rebates have been given to the El Conquistador Resort since it was determined that giving them a rebate was only fair, inasmuch as the town was giving one to the Ritz-Carlton? (As we know, the Ritz opted to build in Marana, not Oro Valley--- But the El Conquistador keeps raking in OUR revenue.)

3) How did the Town Council allow Golder Ranch to raise their rates, in some cases, in excess of 100%, in Oro Valley communities that were never even annexed into the Golder Ranch Fire District ?

4) How did Vestar get a $23.2 million giveaway, with Oro Valley having zero input as to retailers, no way of imposing a "big-box" ordinance on their development, and allowing them to avoid any increase in impact fees?

5) How did it come to pass that Splendido was allowed to build a four story structure with total disregard of the neighbor's views? "Ditto" for the upcoming ACE hardware store on 1st and Tangerine?

6) How did the Rancho Vistoso Crematorium get approved when the council agenda item read, "approval for a "funeral chapel?"

7) Why did the town council hire more police at a higher ratio than Tucson (which has a much higher crime rate,) and then, impose a Utility Tax on the citizens to subsidize the expenditure?

We're sure our readers have other questions. We can only hope, those who take advantage of asking them utilizing this new service, don't get a response that says; "Don't blame us, our hands were tied."

Wednesday, May 23, 2007

Oro Valley Leaders Failed To Protect The Community

The following is a "sad but true" commentary on the failure of Oro Valley leaders to protect and serve the people who elected them. It is a letter from Bill Berlat that appeared in the May 23 issue of The Explorer.

***********************************************************************************************

"Although I am presently in Pinetop, I do have a home in Oro Valley, a once delightful community. My heart goes out to those unfortunate enough to have no avenue of escape from the decadence spawned by a Mayor and Council who have succumbed to greed and growth. Splendido is a perfect example of what should not be allowed in desert setting — a horrible Chicago-like tenement. And if that was not enough, the council approved four stories for it! The devil with the folks who live across the street, their home values and their views. Then there’s the crematorium — a blight in any neighborhood. And now, a Wal-Mart.

What’s needed, and I fear it is too late, are ethics, aesthetic and morality classes for prospective mayors and council members. This would teach them that their first obligation is not taxation, growth or getting on their knees when a developer waves his evil wand. It is the protection of the community, ensuring that a community as beautiful and tranquil as Oro Valley was, stays that way and does not become another noisy, traffic-ridden, desert-despoiling nightmare. That is exactly what a Mayor and Council in a community like ours is supposed to protect us from — degradation. Their charge should not be more money for a bigger government and another herd of motorcycle police. Their first responsibility should have been to preserve and protect the aesthetics and beauty of a small community like ours. And they have utterly failed in that. Mayor Paul Loomis and the Council Members we have had should hang their heads in shame for what they have allowed and encouraged."

Thursday, May 10, 2007

Crematorium Verdict Is In

In a ruling dated May 10, 2007, Judge John F. Kelly, AZ Superior Court determined that the neighbors of the crematorium were too late with their appeal and the case has been dismissed.

We have received the following email from one of the neighbors:

"Wanted you to know the results of our case in Superior Court. Apparently the 3 or 4 residents who were informed in September of 2006, and attended the last meeting of the DRB, and protested the crematorium usage and were ignored, constitutes our having been informed...even though 390+ homeowners were NOT informed of the capricious decision."

Wednesday, May 2, 2007

Monday, April 23, 2007

CREMATORIUM--MANDAMUS HEARING HELD

A Mandamus Hearing concerning the complaint filed by the group "NIMBY" was held before Judge John F.Kelly on April 23. At the hearing, the town of Oro Valley defended its refusal of residents' administrative appeals of the town's decision that a crematorium is a permitted use at the corner of Rancho Vistoso Boulevard and Vistoso Commerce Loop The judge indicated he would render his opinion by 5PM on April 30.

Sunday, April 15, 2007

"Uncle Phil" - OV "Local Lawyer's Retirement Fund"

Our good friend Phil Richardson who knows "a little" about Oro Valley past legal involvements, has a few worthy comments concerning the latest foray involving the "crematorium issue."

*************************************************************************************

Sung to the Tune, “Back in the Saddle Again” (See Autry, Gene)*

“We’re back in the courtroom again,
We’re back fighting Miz Garrahan
Where the lonly builders feed
On more’n they’ll ever need -
Back in the courtroom again.
Whoopi-ty-aye-oh
Rocking, rolling, here we go,
Back in the courtroom again.”

April 23, The Taxpayers of Oro Valley will once again be making contributions to the Local Lawyers Retirement Fund, as a Pima County Superior Court Judge will start trying to decide whether Oro Valley residents who oppose a crematory in their neighborhood had their constitutional right to due process denied.
This essay does not propose to argue either side of that issue, although we cannot resist making an aside that none of the people in town hall have yet to volunteer to move next door to the smokestack.
We only wish to pause to lament the undeniable fact that the Oro Valley Town Council is involved, non-stop, in one litigious issue after another. The grand irony of this is that we taxpayers are footing the bill for all this litigation. We are are being soaked big bucks to fight ourselves!
Why do so many individuals, factions and divisions feel put upon – so much so, they are willing to risk their personal savings, not to mention their peace of mind, fighting Oro Valley Town Hall?
Someone, or some thing has to be to blamed for all of this continual controversy. Why is there such a great disconnect between the governors and the governed in this pretty town?
It cannot be greed; the lust for unending power, since everyone of our chosen leaders claim continually that all is being done, at no little sacrifice on their part – for our good!
It could be caused as the “Singing Cowboy” suggested, by the “lowly gypsum weed, out where the longhorn cattle feed,” or perhaps some yet undiscovered pernicious element washing down into the Canyon del Oro.

-Phil Richardson

*Gene Autry – The signature song of the mellow-voiced star of 65 “horse operas” Orvon Gene Autry 1907-1998. Founded Major League baseball team, “Los Angeles Angels” and owned a chain of radio and TV stations, including KOLD AM/TV, Tucson.

Thursday, April 12, 2007

AZ Star Reports on Crematorium Timeline

The story so far.
Here's a timeline of events surrounding the proposed crematorium.

• Jan. 10, 2006 — The Oro Valley Development Review Board gave the Harpold family the OK to develop Vistoso Memorial Chapel, a funeral home and crematorium, at 2285 E. Rancho Vistoso Blvd.
• Around May 16, 2006 — The town posted notice of the Development Review Board's first review of the funeral home and crematorium's final development plan. The notice was posted at Town Hall, 11000 N. La Cañada Drive, on the Town's Web site, www.townoforovalley.com, and at the site of the development.
• June 13, 2006 — It was announced at a Development Review Board meeting that the Harpolds asked that the review be postponed until some site plan issues could be addressed.
• Aug. 25, 2006 — The town posted notice of the board's rescheduled review of the final development plan at Town Hall, on the town's Web site and on the site of the proposed development. The town also mailed out 45 notices of the review to owners of property near the site.
• Sept. 19, 2006 — The board unanimously approved the development plan.
• Oct. 12, 2006 — The town posted notice of the Oro Valley Town Council's review of the final development plan at Town Hall, on the town's Web site and on the site of the proposed development. The town also mailed out notices to the same 45 property owners.
• Nov. 1, 2006 — The Town Council unanimously approved the development plan.
• Around Jan. 15 — This is the date Larry Ryan, one of the three Oro Valley residents now suing the town, says he first read about the town's approval of the funeral home and crematorium. He and his neighbors began calling and e-mailing the Town Council.
• Feb. 5 — Larry and Brenda Ryan met with Oro Valley town staffers about the issue.
• Feb. 22 — The Ryans, Gregory D. Santoro, who is also suing the town, and another resident, Tim Horne — who is not involved in the lawsuit — attempted to file an appeal of Oro Valley Planning and Zoning Director Sarah More's decision that a crematory is a permitted use on the site. That same day, Town Attorney Melinda Garrahan sent a letter to the residents' attorney, Katharina Richter, saying why their application was refused.
• March 2 — Garrahan sent Richter an analysis of the issues, including the reasons the town refused the application.• March 8 — The residents attempted to file an appeal of the planning and zoning administrator's decision to the Oro Valley Development Review Board.
• March 22 — Garrahan sent Richter another letter saying no administrative remedies were available to the residents.
• March 27 — Garrahan, the Board of Adjustment and More received a Superior Court summons.
• April 9 — The Superior Court issued a stay order on the town's approval of a crematorium as a permitted use on the site, so the town cannot issue any building permits for the project except for a grading permit.Superior Court issues stay on building of crematorium

AZ STAR Reports on Judge's Ruling on Crematorium

By Danielle Sottosanti
arizona daily star
Tucson, Arizona Published: 04.12.2007

The Town of Oro Valley for the next two weeks may not issue any building permits besides a grading permit for a controversial crematorium planned to be built in Rancho Vistoso, a Superior Court order issued earlier this week says.
The 14-day order, which Judge John F. Kelly issued on Monday, will remain in effect until after a Superior Court hearing scheduled for April 23.
The issues are complex enough and the plaintiff showed enough support to mandate keeping the status quo for 14 days, Kelly said.
But the order "has no effect because probably only grading would be done in that 14-day period," said C. Brad Woodford, the town's Tempe-based private attorney.
At the April 23 hearing, the town of Oro Valley will defend its refusal of residents' administrative appeals of the town's decision that a crematorium is a permitted use on the site, at the corner of Rancho Vistoso Boulevard and Vistoso Commerce Loop.
The three Rancho Vistoso residents who are taking the matter to court — Gregory D. Santoro and Larry and Brenda Ryan — are among other residents who have been fighting the development of Vistoso Memorial Chapel, a funeral chapel and crematorium, at 2285 E. Rancho Vistoso Blvd.
If Kelly decides in the residents' favor, the town will have to schedule an Oro Valley Board of Adjustment hearing for their appeal and could have to pay their attorney's fees and expenses.
Katharina Richter, the residents' Tucson-based attorney, is requesting that the court decide whether the town of Oro Valley denied them their constitutionally protected right to due process of law.
"It's my clients' position that they have a right to appeal to the Board of Adjustment that a crematory is a permitted use in the zone, and the town refused to accept their right to submit an application for an appeal," she said.
At the hearing, the town will try to prove it was justified in refusing the residents' application for appeal.
"The town's interest in this matter really lies in defending its own process," said Town Attorney Melinda Garrahan.
The town's Planning and Zoning Department in January 2006 gave the funeral home's owner — Harpold Trust LLC — the OK to proceed through the development process, and the Town Council approved the site's development plan on Nov. 1, 2006.
Though Harpold Trust LLC is not a defendant at the April 23 hearing, it has hired an attorney, Tom Parsons of Tucson.
During Monday's Superior Court hearing, Parsons argued against the delay of his client's plans to develop the funeral chapel and crematorium and said he hoped the court would take into account that the process for developing the multimillion-dollar project started two-and-a-half years ago.
Harpold Trust LLC is ready to grade the project site, he said. In his order, the judge said the town can issue a grading permit.
Since February, the residents have attempted twice to appeal the town's earlier decisions to approve the development.
They attempted to file an appeal with the town's Board of Adjustment on Feb. 22 and the town's Development Review Board on March 8. The town refused both applications for appeal.
In a letter dated Feb. 22, Garrahan wrote that their application to the Board of Adjustment was refused "because neither its factual nor legal premises are correct."
"Considering all the facts, there is no 'appeal' process available at this time, whether to the Board of Adjustment or any other branch of the town government," Garrahan wrote.
But the residents and their attorney say the town's refusals have denied them "due process of law," a constitutionally protected right.
● Contact reporter Danielle Sottosanti at 618-1922 or at dsottosanti@azstarnet.com.

Wednesday, April 11, 2007

CREMATORIUM Status

Our neighbors at "NIMBY" have advised that their attorney was in court on April 9, and obtained a Temporary Restraining Order to stop the permit on the crematorium until the Mandamus Hearing. That means that during the next two weeks, until the Hearing, the developer cannot start work on the Crematorium. He can start grading if he obtains a grading permit, for only the funeral chapel, if he chooses.

We will try and keep our readers abreast of this issue as it moves forward.