Course pays $100,000 for $360,000 worth of waterFor more than 25 years, the Oro Valley Water Utility has provided lowest water pricing to the Town-funded Pusch Ridge nine-hole Golf Course. In fiscal year 2025–26, that pricing amounted to a subsidy of more than $257,000, based on the difference between what the course paid and what it would have paid under the Town's standard four-tier commercial bulk water user rate.
Pusch Ridge Golf Course is receiving preferential pricing compared with other customers in the same commercial bulk water rate classification, without a documented reasonable basis for that difference and without formal Town Council approval.
The discussion of preferential water pricing for golf courses originated in 1999, when the Town was preparing to introduce tiered water rates. The proposed arrangement was included in the formal notice of intent to increase water rates (Resolution 99-62). However, the provision was not included in the subsequent resolution that formally approved the water rate increases (Resolution 99-79). We have found no evidence that Council ever formally adopted this special pricing arrangement.
...yet became the established billing practice
Despite the absence of that documented Council authorization, Pusch Ridge continued to be charged the lowest commodity rate. What began as a proposed pricing arrangement became a longstanding billing practice.
Water Director Abraham discovered the discrepancy in 2021... told the council...
That single-tier billing continued for two plus decades without a documented explanation. In February 2021, while Council was considering the future of the Pusch Ridge Golf Course, Town Manager Mary Jacobs reported that Water Utility Director Peter Abraham had discovered an unexplained discrepancy. Pusch Ridge had never transitioned to the tiered conservation pricing structure adopted by Council in 1999–2000 and revised in 2007–2008. Instead, it had continued paying a fixed Tier 1 rate for 20 years. The report stated:
"Director Peter Abraham discovered during his analysis of water use and projected revenues that for an unknown reason, the Pusch course water account never transitioned to the tiered conservation pricing structure adopted by the Town Council in 1999/2000 and later updated in 2007/08. For the past 20 years, the course has continually been charged a fixed Tier 1 rate rather than the established commodity rate structure. There is no documentation in the file regarding this matter, and no current staff were employed by the Water Utility during that time to further explain this discrepancy."
...but the council never fixed it.. simply continuing the billing.. while other uses pick up the slack through the rate they pay
Despite the 2021 finding, neither council nor staff has taken any action to fix this. Pusch Ridge continues to receive fixed Tier 1 pricing regardless of how much water it uses. The result is that the remaining water user pick up the slack by paying higher overall rates. The Oro Valley Water Utility operates as a financially self-supporting enterprise fund, separate from the Town's general governmental operations. It is responsible for collecting sufficient revenue to pay for water service, system maintenance, infrastructure improvements, and financial obligations. When a Town-owned golf course pays substantially less than the standard irrigation rate, the Utility receives less revenue while continuing to provide the same service. The financial benefit goes to the Town's golf operation, while the revenue difference must be absorbed within the Utility's finances.
In effect, the preferential arrangement shifts costs away from golf operations and onto other Water Utility customers through the rates they pay.
So many unanswered questions
The issue is whether the Town can give its own golf operation a preferential rate without a documented, legally supportable basis. Why has the Water Utility continued to provide preferential pricing to a Town-owned operation without this. Why didn't the council do anything after it learned this in 2021? Absent a council approval to do so, when will this policy be discontinued?
- - -
Sources for this article:
Resolution 99-62 (1999) — The proposed golf course conservation-rate provision.
Resolution 99-79 (1999) — The subsequent water rate action not including rate provision
February 2021 Town Council memorandum, page 30 — The discovery of the billing discrepancy
FY 2026–27 Water Rates Analysis — The current published rates, Appendix B.
- - -
Editorial distinction: The $257,412 calculation is a documented estimate of the difference between the two billing methods, not a verified increase in other customers' bills. The article makes the subsidy argument while distinguishing the billing difference from its precise effect on customer rates. It also reports that no Council authorization has been located, rather than claiming that an exhaustive legal review has conclusively ruled out its existence.






