Showing posts with label Rancho Vistoso PAD. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Rancho Vistoso PAD. Show all posts

Wednesday, October 7, 2026

Board Upholds “Sanatorium” Interpretation. Opens Door For Assisted Living And Memory Care On Vacant Parcel North of Safeway

Board decided what is permitted, not what will be built
The Oro Valley Board of Adjustment on Monday upheld the Town Planning and Zoning Administrator’s interpretation that the term “sanatorium,” a permitted use under the Rancho Vistoso Planned Area Development, can include assisted living and memory care. The decision does not approve a development on the vacant parcel immediately north of Safeway. It answers only the zoning question of whether those uses can fall within the PAD’s existing “sanatorium” designation.

The Board upheld staff’s interpretation after relatively little discussion. Members did not issue findings or explain why they agreed with staff’s reading of the PAD. 

A permitted use is not an approved project
This does not mean that a “sanatorium” is being built there. It means only that assisted living and memory care may be proposed because the Rancho Vistoso PAD permits those uses under the term “sanatorium.” Any actual development proposal would still have to go through the Town’s normal development review process. Staff would first review the proposal for compliance with applicable zoning and development requirements. The applicant would then be required to hold at least two neighborhood meetings, and the project would undergo review of issues including traffic, landscaping, walls and architecture. If the applicant seeks a rezoning or amendment to the PAD, Town Council approval would be required.

Click to enlarge
A difficult parcel with a long history

The approximately eight acre commercial parcel has been the subject of development proposals before. LOVE first wrote about plans for what we called “tiny homes” in 2021. That eventually became the Avilla Homes proposal for single story rental housing. Residents raised concerns about converting commercial land to residential use, compatibility with nearby homes, and especially access and traffic. The parcel is hemmed in by existing development and has limited ways to move traffic in and out. In January 2024, the Town Council unanimously rejected the Avilla proposal. LOVE later wrote that the Avilla experience showed how sustained resident involvement can shape the review of a difficult development site.

The traffic problem extends well beyond this parcel
Those access concerns are part of a much larger transportation issue surrounding Rancho Vistoso Boulevard, Woodburne Avenue and the northern Safeway entrance. Town staff has already identified the area as needing improvement. Public Works Director Paul Keesler told the Council earlier this year that the Woodburne and Safeway northern access area has experienced roughly five to six crashes a year. The Town had budgeted about $747,000 in roadway impact fee funding for changes that included lane reconfiguration, increased left turn storage and median reconstruction. Staff later reconsidered that plan as additional development proposals emerged in the area.

Sprouts proposal adds another piece to the puzzle
One of those proposals is Vistoso Marketplace, a planned commercial center across Rancho Vistoso Boulevard that is expected to include a Sprouts Farmers Market as its anchor. The project caused staff to look at the entire area rather than simply repair the Woodburne intersection. By August, staff was recommending that a future traffic signal be placed at the Safeway northern entrance, directly across from the proposed Vistoso Marketplace access. Keesler told the Council that a signal at that location is warranted even under existing traffic conditions. The parcel involved in Monday’s Board of Adjustment hearing sits immediately beside an intersection the Town is already trying to redesign while another significant commercial development is being planned across the street.

Monday answered only the first question
The Board of Adjustment settled a narrow issue. Under the existing Rancho Vistoso PAD, assisted living and memory care qualify as a permitted “sanatorium” use. It did not decide whether a particular facility should be built on this parcel or whether a future site plan will adequately address traffic, access and compatibility with surrounding properties. Those questions remain for another day. Given the history of this parcel, a proposed Sprouts development across Rancho Vistoso Boulevard and the Town’s ongoing work on the surrounding roadway system, that future review may prove far more consequential than Monday’s zoning interpretation. 
- - -

Tuesday, April 21, 2026

Planning and Zoning Commission Split Leaves Sun City Fountain Proposal Unresolved

No recommendation made after tie vote on water fountain
Last week, the Planning and Zoning Commission did not approve nor deny a text amendment to the Rancho Vistoso PAD that would have allowed an ornamental fountain to return to the Sun City Recreation Center. They did this through a split vote of 3-3 on a motion to deny the amendment, meaning no majority decision was reached.

Request made because fountain lost legal status to be restored without approval
The request is to allow restoration of the long-standing Lion Head Fountain. It was made by the Sun City Vistoso Community Association. The fountain was in operation until 2020. Unfortunately, it remained out of service for more than six months, causing it to lose its legal non-conforming status under Town code, which no longer permits ornamental fountains.

Proposal seeks smaller, lower-use fountain
The redesigned fountain will be smaller and more water-efficient than the previous one. It will use a  a closed-loop system of potable water, with the option to supplement with rainwater harvesting. The redesigned fountain would use about 1,300 gallons of water per month due to evaporation, or roughly 15,600 gallons annually. With rainwater harvesting, potable water use could drop to about 200 gallons per month. For comparison, a typical Oro Valley household uses about 7,500 gallons per month, meaning the fountain would use a fraction of a single home's annual water consumption.

Click To Enlarge
Staff says proposal conflicts with town water policies
Town staff recommended denial of the request, stating it conflicts with the Town's General Plan policies on water conservation. Staff referenced both the current Your Voice, Our Future General Plan and the draft Path Forward General Plan, which emphasize responsible water use, conservation, and drought-tolerant development. The zoning code has prohibited ornamental fountains since 2011 as part of that policy direction. Staff said allowing a new or reactivated fountain, even a smaller one, would be inconsistent with those policies and with the Town's long-standing approach to limiting non-essential water use.

Public comment was mostly supportive
Public comment reflected strong interest, with most speakers supporting the proposal. Supporters described the fountain as a valued community feature that provided a gathering place and contributed to the character of Sun City. They also pointed to the redesign and reduced water use. Those opposed focused on water conservation concerns, noting ongoing drought conditions and questioning whether any non-essential water use is appropriate.

Commission divided on whether exception is justified
Commission discussion reflected the same divide. Some members supported the amendment, noting the relatively small amount of water involved and the effort to reduce usage. Others emphasized the need to follow the General Plan and avoid setting a precedent for exceptions to the code. Several commissioners acknowledged the strength of public opinion on both sides.

Town Council will make final decision
With the 3-3 vote, the Commission did not make a formal recommendation. Instead, the matter will move forward to Town Council with notice of the split vote. Council will make the final decision on whether to approve the text amendment.
- - -

Thursday, May 7, 2020

Guest View: Mike Zinkin ~ Town thwarts idea to turn the Vistoso Golf Course into a natural open space, nature preserve, and walking trail

Yesterday, we posted about the town's response to questions residents posed regarding the proposed Vistoso Golf General Plan Amendment. Today, resident Mike Zinkin presents his view on that.
---
In a recent communication, the Town’s Parks and Recreation Director, Kristy Diaz-Trahan, replied to a question regarding why the Town was not considering the purchase of the Rancho Vistoso Golf Course to use as a public park. Ms. Diaz-Trahan responded by quoting the Rancho Vistoso Planned Area Development (PAD) document regarding park amenities. This document was written in 1987 and noted that:

“Rancho Vistoso is envisioned as a totally self-sufficient community, including residential used as all types, neighborhood and community shopping and retail, schools, parks, churches, natural open space, a trail system, a resort hotel, a Town Center, an adult community and an office park.”

Ms. Diaz-Trahan erroneously uses this 1987 vision statement for Ranch Vistoso as justification to dismiss a citizen-driven proposal for a nature preserve and community trail in the stunning location that was once one of the top 100 public golf courses in America. Further, the Town’s park survey asks nothing about recreation areas north of Tangerine and solely focuses on existing parks, making it appear as though the people who live in Rancho Vistoso (over 8,000) are not part of Oro Valley.

A comparable illustration
To illustrate why Ms. Diaz-Trahan’s approach is misguided, see if you can name the location envisioned in this PAD:

“The activity center is planned as a high end retail development to support the vision of the Town of Oro Valley in creating a technology-driven economy. The center will accommodate a range of distinct and complimentary land uses that are physically and functionally integrated. "XXX" will include pedestrian and site amenities such as courtyards, shaded seating areas, pedestrian mall(s), landscaping, and an integrated pedestrian circulation system. Functionally, the center will accommodate a range of differing but complimentary land uses and be designed with amenities and architectural elements to reflect the quality development Oro Valley attracts. "

Now replace the "XXX" with Steam Pump Village, which contains NO courtyards, NO shaded seating areas, NO integrated pedestrian circulation system, and NO pedestrian mall. What was supposed to be a high end development instead contains a QT gas station and a 3-story storage facility. The actual development is NOTHING like it was envisioned in the PAD description. Likewise, in the case of Rancho Vistoso, the “park” amenities they actually have access to are far less useful than was once envisioned.

Dismissing public input
In all fairness to Ms. Diaz-Trahan, she works for Town Manager, Mary Jacobs. My observations are that Ms. Jacobs has consistently shown a disregard for public input that is not in line with her thinking. As an example of how Ms. Jacobs operates from a predetermined agenda, when the Town Council was struggling to reconcile the financial deficits associated with the Town-owned golf courses, she illogically informed the Council that 36 holes of golf are cheaper to operate than 18 holes. It now appears that she will not even consider applying for grant funds that could help solve the ongoing issue with the Vistoso golf property. To be clear, in light of the ongoing pandemic and its effect on the town budget, I do not believe that Oro Valley could afford to purchase this property during this budget cycle, but the citizens who live in Rancho Vistoso deserve a fighting chance to save a community that represents 25% of Oro Valley, in population as well as in revenue.

Wednesday, January 16, 2019

Guest View: Tim Bohen ~ Is The WLB Group padding their claims? Part 2.

Part 1 was published on Monday.

The process is broken
Our Oro Valley PAD amendment process is broken but it’s hard to see on the surface. For years, we have had a developer-driven process on developer timetables and a lack of healthy cross-examination of developer claims which should expose obvious errors in documents. The Town Council eliminated the Development Review Board some years ago in order to make the supposedly unfriendly Oro Valley easier for developers to navigate.

There is at least one council member liaison present at all P&Z meetings so nothing major should slip by. In addition, Staff researches the issue beforehand for their presentation, so they should catch errors or falsehoods at this point, right? So between P&Z, the town staff, and the Town Council, due diligence has been done, right?

Not always. See editor’s note at the end of the article.

But when developers request new entitlements at Rancho Vistoso or seek to enforce entitlements they won previously, who is actually verifying that these entitlements are properly recorded and followed for all to see? In my view, no one has been doing this for over 10 years. Don’t hold your breath waiting for the developers who have had their way for so long to bring this up. Our Town needs to insist upon a complete and verifiable application which clearly delineates the WAS and IS text of the PAD amendment before the public meeting is even scheduled.

Why single out WLB?
They are an engineering and planning firm, not a developer nor a public relations firm. First of all, the badly outdated Rancho Vistoso PAD has their name on it and has for a long time. Check “Prepared by…” on page one and “Revised by WLB July 10, 1996” in Tables H and J. [Click HERE to review the Rancho Vistoso PAD]

Despite the PAD issues mentioned above, we have on many occasions seen WLB advocating for their Rancho Vistoso developer applicants based on their “long experience” in Rancho Vistoso. But after their recent 2017 successes in these requests for General Plan and PAD amendments, have they bothered to follow through to confirm that the amendments they seek are properly recorded and available?

Also, we see WLB quite literally all over Town advocating for the interests of their developer partners, including the Arizona Bureau of Land Management in the current Tangerine Annexation process. But WLB, as mentioned, is an engineering and planning firm, not a legal or PR firm. Just who is minding the WLB store when it comes to ensuring they do their core work of maintaining current engineering and planning documentation for our Town?

Homework Assignment
Vintage documents should not be considered current in dealings between WLB and the Town of Oro Valley. WLB, if you do update the PAD for the Town website as you should, be sure to provide the Town one mylar and five colored exhibits of the entire PAD as required per Section 6A on sheet 41. Don’t forget the five bound copies and one unbound copy for future distribution per Section 6B.

---
Editor’s Note: The Saguaro Viejos development (another WLB project) is a perfect example of false information being presented as fact. During their presentation in April 2018, Paul Oland of WLB stated that their rezoning request for 6,500 sf lots was compatible with the existing land use east of the property which he claimed was 7,000 to 10,000 sf lots. The actual lot sizes for that neighborhood are 15,000 to 33,000 square feet. This was pointed out to P&Z and the Town Council by Oro Valley resident and frequent LOVE contributor, Diane Peters, who, like Tim Bohen, actually did some due diligence by reviewing town documents.