With the Town Council election on the horizon, LOVE will be presenting a series of articles entitled, “The Solomon Chronicles,” highlighting the abysmal record of Councilmember Steve Solomon who is running for re-election. This weekly series will highlight his 4-year record of incivility and his interdependent relationship with local developers. This series was written by a LOVE contributor and contains a synopsis of previous LOVE articles plus new information.
- - -
Today’s article presents excerpts from Councilmember Solomon’s voting record from November 2016 to April 2018 and focuses on his repeated catering to developers.
Solomon thumbed his nose at the citizens on his first night in office
November 16, 2016. Solomon was sworn into office. That very same night, he voted to approve a Major General Plan Amendment to amend the Land Use Map at Rancho Vistoso Blvd. and Vistoso Highlands Drive (17 acres) FROM Neighborhood Commercial/Office TO Medium Density Residential.
Why was this important? Solomon’s vote was noteworthy because it came just 8 days after the new 2016 General Plan had been approved by Oro Valley voters! Think about that. A plan that was 3 years in the making (September 2013 – September 2016), a plan written and approved by the people of Oro Valley to reflect OUR community values, was altered by Steve Solomon (and the rest of the former Hiremath council) during their very first meeting. On his very first night in office, Solomon’s first order of business was to thumb his nose at the citizens. This would be a harbinger of what was to come.
Apparently, all those Oro Valley voices coming together to present a clear vision of what we wanted for our town was of no value or importance to Steve Solomon.
Approved the grading of rolling hills
November 16, 2016. Yes, we’re still on the same night and he wasn’t done yet. Remember the beautiful rolling hills that were once present on the east side of First Avenue? Town Code does not allow grading of hills by more than 6 feet. Solomon voted to allow a portion of those hills to be graded down 12-15 feet to accommodate the residential development known as Sanctuary at Silverhawke.
Approved a storage facility at the historic Steam Pump Ranch
March 15, 2017. Solomon voted to allow a 107,544 square foot, 3-story storage facility containing approx. 750 storage units at the historic Steam Pump Village despite residents speaking against it during the Public Hearing. Residents pointed out that it was not consistent with the vision, guiding principles, goals and policies of the General Plan. One of those residents pointed out that even the Town Staff found that it met ONLY ONE of the 10 goals in the General Plan.
Additionally, this area was slated to be part of the Main Streets district which was to include areas for shopping and dining along the CDO wash…another reason that a 3-story storage facility was not appropriate for this area.
Tangerine North Annexation, Shannon 80, and Big Wash General Plan Amendments
December 6, 2017. Despite a huge resident turnout at this council meeting and strong vocal opposition from residents, Solomon voted to approve ALL of the following:
• Tangerine North Annexation. Solomon voted to approve a General Plan Amendment to extend the Oro Valley planning area boundary to include 302 acres currently zoned for 3.3 acre residential on the north side of Tangerine (between Coyote Crossing and Thornydale) and to give it a new designation of Master Planned Community. In other words, say goodbye to 3.3 acre minimum lot sizes.
• Shannon 80. Solomon voted to approve a General Plan Amendment to change the land use on 76 acres on the east side of Shannon Road FROM Rural low density residential TO Low density residential-1. He then voted to approve the rezoning from R1-144 to R1-36. However, due to ESLO criteria, the minimum lot size actually allowed is just 8,750 square feet! This is totally incompatible with existing homes in that area which are custom homes on lot sizes of 144,000 sf and larger (3.3 acres and up).
• Big Wash. Solomon voted to approve a General Plan Amendment to change land use and zoning designations for 108 acres of undeveloped land in a FLOODPLAIN located along Honeybee Wash and Big Wash to allow 408 homes on lot sizes of 7,200 sf lots and 5,400 sf lots on mass-graded sites.
Saguaros Viejos
April 4, 2018. Despite this parcel (west side of La Cholla between Glover and Naranja) already having been rezoned from R1-144 (144,000 sf) down to R1-20 (20,000 sf) just two years earlier, Solomon voted to approve yet another rezoning down to even smaller lots of R1-7 (7,000 sf).
This pristine desert parcel (85 acres), originally zoned for 3.3 acre rural residential lots with no mass grading, will now be built as 7,000 sf lots with mass grading and cookie-cutter 2-story homes. This is not compatible with the surrounding homes, including custom homes on 3.3 acre lots and semi-custom homes with an average lot size of 18,500 sf. Numerous residents spoke in opposition to this rezoning.
Solomon’s legacy – 588 acres of pristine desert irreparably transformed
This is just a small sample from Solomon’s first 18 months in office! It reveals that his loyalty is not to the people, but rather to wealthy land speculators and developers. For anyone who still doesn’t know this, Steve Solomon is also a developer. He is the owner of Canada Vistas, a real estate development/homebuilding business.
NOTE: Councilmember Bill Rodman who is also running for re-election also voted to approve all of the above general plan amendments and rezonings. Do you want to re-elect these two incumbents and give them another 4-year long license to continue rezoning what little land is left of our once beautiful Oro Valley desert landscape?
- - -
The Solomon Chronicles: Part 3. “Who funded Solomon’s 2016 Town Council campaign?” will be published next Wednesday.
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query solomon voting record. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query solomon voting record. Sort by date Show all posts
Wednesday, June 10, 2020
Wednesday, June 3, 2020
The Solomon Chronicles. Part 1. Favoritism.
With the Town Council election on the horizon, LOVE will be presenting a series of articles entitled, “The Solomon Chronicles,” highlighting the abysmal record of Councilmember Steve Solomon who is running for re-election. This weekly series will highlight his 4-year record of incivility towards Oro Valley residents and his interdependent relationship with local developers. This series was written by a LOVE contributor and contains a synopsis of previous LOVE articles plus new information.
- - -
April 5, 2017 Town Council meeting
A $17 million bond for sports fields at Naranja Park was on the agenda, however, there was no Public Hearing scheduled for this item. As you continue reading, keep in mind that Solomon was in favor of this bond.
With no Public Hearing scheduled, two residents who wanted to speak on this issue, chose to do so during the Call to Audience. Most likely, neither were aware that you are not allowed to speak during the Call to Audience regarding an item that is on the agenda.
The first person to speak (Oro Valley resident, Karen Stratman), was opposed to the $17 million bond and the secondary property tax to pay for it. She stated that if ball fields were wanted by our residents, then they should have been a priority rather than the Town purchasing 3 golf courses.
Solomon calls a Point of Order
Ms. Stratman was quickly interrupted by Councilmember Solomon who called a Point of Order, stating that she was not allowed to speak on an agenda item during the Call to Audience. Solomon addressed the Town Attorney stating that, “She specifically mentioned the bond issue that’s on the agenda.”
Although he was correct that discussing an agenda item during the Call to Audience is not allowed, it’s what happened next that revealed his true intention in stopping her speech…and it wasn’t because he’s a stickler for enforcing Parliamentary Rules.
Solomon’s True Intentions
The next person to speak (Oro Valley resident, Ben Baker) was in favor of the $17 million bond. He opened his speech by instructing the council on the best way to convince people to vote to approve the bond, including giving specific examples of how to entice residents into voting YES.
Solomon was silent. He never interrupted this speaker. He never called a Point of Order and Mr. Baker was allowed to present his entire speech unimpeded, despite speaking on the same agenda item that Solomon had just prevented Ms. Stratman from speaking on.
Why was Solomon not consistent in asking the Town Attorney to enforce the rules? One can only conclude that it was because Mr. Baker was in favor of the $17 million Naranja Park Bond (as was Councilmember Solomon) and Solomon wanted to make sure that that speaker’s voice was heard!
This is Councilmember Solomon in action. To him, Parliamentary Rules should only apply to those who disagree with him. If you agree with him, he’s just fine with suspending the rules for you. Councilmember Solomon has never understood the simple fact that he is supposed to be a councilmember for all and not just for those who agree with him.
Appointed his crony to Planning & Zoning
Solomon also voted to appoint Don Cox to the Planning & Zoning Commission despite the council receiving letters of concern from multiple residents about Cox’s repeated inappropriate and unprofessional behavior while serving past terms on P&Z. Cox had already been reprimanded twice by the Town Attorney for his inappropriate behavior and for violating the rules for Board and Commission members. (NOTE: Cox was a vocal supporter of Steve Solomon during the 2016 election and formed a PAC that endorsed Pina-Rodman-Solomon for election. Quid pro quo?)
- - -
The Solomon Chronicles: Part 2. “Voting Record” will be published next Wednesday.
- - -
April 5, 2017 Town Council meeting
A $17 million bond for sports fields at Naranja Park was on the agenda, however, there was no Public Hearing scheduled for this item. As you continue reading, keep in mind that Solomon was in favor of this bond.
With no Public Hearing scheduled, two residents who wanted to speak on this issue, chose to do so during the Call to Audience. Most likely, neither were aware that you are not allowed to speak during the Call to Audience regarding an item that is on the agenda.
The first person to speak (Oro Valley resident, Karen Stratman), was opposed to the $17 million bond and the secondary property tax to pay for it. She stated that if ball fields were wanted by our residents, then they should have been a priority rather than the Town purchasing 3 golf courses.
Solomon calls a Point of Order
Ms. Stratman was quickly interrupted by Councilmember Solomon who called a Point of Order, stating that she was not allowed to speak on an agenda item during the Call to Audience. Solomon addressed the Town Attorney stating that, “She specifically mentioned the bond issue that’s on the agenda.”
Although he was correct that discussing an agenda item during the Call to Audience is not allowed, it’s what happened next that revealed his true intention in stopping her speech…and it wasn’t because he’s a stickler for enforcing Parliamentary Rules.
Solomon’s True Intentions
The next person to speak (Oro Valley resident, Ben Baker) was in favor of the $17 million bond. He opened his speech by instructing the council on the best way to convince people to vote to approve the bond, including giving specific examples of how to entice residents into voting YES.
Solomon was silent. He never interrupted this speaker. He never called a Point of Order and Mr. Baker was allowed to present his entire speech unimpeded, despite speaking on the same agenda item that Solomon had just prevented Ms. Stratman from speaking on.
Why was Solomon not consistent in asking the Town Attorney to enforce the rules? One can only conclude that it was because Mr. Baker was in favor of the $17 million Naranja Park Bond (as was Councilmember Solomon) and Solomon wanted to make sure that that speaker’s voice was heard!
This is Councilmember Solomon in action. To him, Parliamentary Rules should only apply to those who disagree with him. If you agree with him, he’s just fine with suspending the rules for you. Councilmember Solomon has never understood the simple fact that he is supposed to be a councilmember for all and not just for those who agree with him.
Appointed his crony to Planning & Zoning
Solomon also voted to appoint Don Cox to the Planning & Zoning Commission despite the council receiving letters of concern from multiple residents about Cox’s repeated inappropriate and unprofessional behavior while serving past terms on P&Z. Cox had already been reprimanded twice by the Town Attorney for his inappropriate behavior and for violating the rules for Board and Commission members. (NOTE: Cox was a vocal supporter of Steve Solomon during the 2016 election and formed a PAC that endorsed Pina-Rodman-Solomon for election. Quid pro quo?)
- - -
The Solomon Chronicles: Part 2. “Voting Record” will be published next Wednesday.
Wednesday, July 15, 2020
The Solomon Chronicles. Part 6. Promises and Lies
This is the final installment in our series of articles entitled, “The Solomon Chronicles,” highlighting the abysmal record of Councilmember Steve Solomon who is running for re-election. This series was written by a LOVE contributor and contains a synopsis of previous LOVE articles plus new information.
- - -
This article will discuss some of the lies that Steve Solomon is currently telling along with some of the lies he told when running for election in 2016.
Solomon’s golf course lie
We present this one to show you that Solomon has a history of lying. Solomon told this whopper when running for Town Council in 2016. He distributed this lie in a campaign flyer that was delivered to the homes along the town-owned golf courses in Canada Hills. At that time, he (along with Bill Rodman and Rhonda Pina) was running against incumbents Brendan Burns, Bill Garner, and Mike Zinkin. The flyer stated:
Solomon’s $3 million deficit lie
Solomon actually used the adjective “whopping” in his next lie. A Freudian slip, perhaps? Because it’s another whopper of a lie. And he not only told this whopper when running for council in 2016, but he is repeating it again in the current 2020 election. He stated it during Jim Horn’s Town Hall podcast held on June 25th.
Here’s what he said during that Town Hall:
The Hiremath Council did not inherit a $3 million deficit in 2010 as Solomon claimed. Here’s the real story.
• First of all, it is against State law to have a deficient budget.
• The tentative, proposed budget showed a $3.1 million difference between requested spending and forecasted revenues. That’s not a deficit. A deficit only occurs when actual spending exceeds actual revenues. That never happened. This is the $3 million to which Councilmember Solomon refers. This was the Hiremath council’s budget. They did not inherit it from any previous council.
• The Council was told by the Town Manager (Jerene Watson at that time) that they needed to increase revenues or the staff was going to suffer layoffs and/or 4 day work-weeks.
• The Hiremath Council, including Steve Solomon, decided to raise those revenues by doubling your Utility Tax from 2% to 4%. Solomon doesn’t tell you that part.
Here’s another 2020 campaign lie
During the Sun City Candidate Forum held on June 30th, Steve Solomon said this during his closing statement.
If time permits, LOVE will dissect those lies for you in an upcoming article.
The ESLO lie
In Solomon’s continuing campaign of self-promotion, during that same forum, Solomon took sole credit for creating the Environmentally Sensitive Lands Ordinance. He said,
But to hear Solomon tell it, he alone devised the plan and implemented the policy!
Campaign promises don’t matter
During the June 30, 2020 Sun City debate, when asked if there were any situations in which he would increase taxes, Solomon replied, “Read my lips. No new taxes.” But keep in mind what he said during the January 23, 2019 town council meeting:
If you’ve missed any of The Solomon Chronicles, the links are provided below for your convenience.
Part 1. Favoritism
Part 2. Voting Record 2016-2018
Part 3. Who funded Solomon's 2016 Town Council campaign
Part 4. Conflict of interest
Part 5. A pattern of incivility and disrespect
Part 5. A pattern of incivility and disrespect (Cont'd.)
- - -
This article will discuss some of the lies that Steve Solomon is currently telling along with some of the lies he told when running for election in 2016.
Solomon’s golf course lie
We present this one to show you that Solomon has a history of lying. Solomon told this whopper when running for Town Council in 2016. He distributed this lie in a campaign flyer that was delivered to the homes along the town-owned golf courses in Canada Hills. At that time, he (along with Bill Rodman and Rhonda Pina) was running against incumbents Brendan Burns, Bill Garner, and Mike Zinkin. The flyer stated:
“Save your home value! The incumbents running for re-election have pledged to close and sell your golf course destroying your home value!” The flyer was “Paid for by Solomon for OV Council.”That was an outright lie. Burns, Garner, and Zinkin had never pledged any such thing and when an Oro Valley resident asked Solomon to prove that they did, he couldn’t. He made it up. It was a complete fabrication designed to trick uninformed voters into voting for him…and they did.
Solomon’s $3 million deficit lie
Solomon actually used the adjective “whopping” in his next lie. A Freudian slip, perhaps? Because it’s another whopper of a lie. And he not only told this whopper when running for council in 2016, but he is repeating it again in the current 2020 election. He stated it during Jim Horn’s Town Hall podcast held on June 25th.
Here’s what he said during that Town Hall:
“During my time on council, I helped guide the town to financial success. From 2008-2010, the council generated a whopping $3 million dollar deficit. When I first took office in 2010, myself and the other new council members balanced the budget, eventually generating $2 million in annual surpluses.”He also said it during the January 9, 2019 council meeting:
“…when I first came on council in 2010, we discovered that the budget that was approved by the prior council…had a $3 million deficit which they never bothered to point out or emphasize and we had to deal with it."There was never a deficit
The Hiremath Council did not inherit a $3 million deficit in 2010 as Solomon claimed. Here’s the real story.
• First of all, it is against State law to have a deficient budget.
• The tentative, proposed budget showed a $3.1 million difference between requested spending and forecasted revenues. That’s not a deficit. A deficit only occurs when actual spending exceeds actual revenues. That never happened. This is the $3 million to which Councilmember Solomon refers. This was the Hiremath council’s budget. They did not inherit it from any previous council.
• The Council was told by the Town Manager (Jerene Watson at that time) that they needed to increase revenues or the staff was going to suffer layoffs and/or 4 day work-weeks.
• The Hiremath Council, including Steve Solomon, decided to raise those revenues by doubling your Utility Tax from 2% to 4%. Solomon doesn’t tell you that part.
Here’s another 2020 campaign lie
During the Sun City Candidate Forum held on June 30th, Steve Solomon said this during his closing statement.
“Dr. Greene, Bill Rodman’s, and my campaigns are all positive. We have not gone on the attack against our opponents. That’s something you may want to take into consideration in your evaluation.”After implying that you shouldn’t vote for people who engage in attack ads, just 10 days later, Solomon and Rodman posted an attack ad on their Facebook pages where they attack “The Other Guys.” We assume that this same postcard will soon be arriving in your mailbox. But the biggest problem is, that once again, the accusations made against Bill Garner and Tim Bohen are all lies.
If time permits, LOVE will dissect those lies for you in an upcoming article.
The ESLO lie
In Solomon’s continuing campaign of self-promotion, during that same forum, Solomon took sole credit for creating the Environmentally Sensitive Lands Ordinance. He said,
“I’ve also put in place our environmentally sensitive land ordinance.”He put it in place? Well, that will come as quite a surprise to all the other people who worked on that committee. Back in 2010, Solomon was just one member of the 7-member Public Advisory Committee assigned to work on ESLO. There was also a 10-member Technical Advisory Committee including people from Arizona Game & Fish, Arizona Geological Survey, and the Coalition for Sonoran Desert Protection to name a few.
But to hear Solomon tell it, he alone devised the plan and implemented the policy!
Campaign promises don’t matter
During the June 30, 2020 Sun City debate, when asked if there were any situations in which he would increase taxes, Solomon replied, “Read my lips. No new taxes.” But keep in mind what he said during the January 23, 2019 town council meeting:
"There is a major difference between campaigning and governing. It is really irrelevant what your campaign promises were.”The inference is that Solomon believes that one can say whatever they wish in order to get elected, but once elected, there is no need to follow through.
If you’ve missed any of The Solomon Chronicles, the links are provided below for your convenience.
Part 1. Favoritism
Part 2. Voting Record 2016-2018
Part 3. Who funded Solomon's 2016 Town Council campaign
Part 4. Conflict of interest
Part 5. A pattern of incivility and disrespect
Part 5. A pattern of incivility and disrespect (Cont'd.)
Wednesday, August 16, 2017
Editorial ~ The Voting Record of the Oro Valley Town Council “Majority-7” (Part 2.)
This is the second of a 3-part series presenting the voting record for the new Oro Valley Town Council. Part 1 was published last week, covering their voting record from November-January. If you missed it, you can read it HEREThis week we present the record from February-April. Four meetings were held and all votes were unanimous.
……………
February 15, 2017
Over 100 youth sport parents and Oro Valley user group representatives were in attendance requesting that Council take action to construct additional sports fields at Naranja Park.
Five representatives of the group spoke in favor of this issue. Council directed staff to return at a future council meeting with a plan to finance additional sports fields in response to this community request.
Authorizing an increase in water rates.
All motions passed 7-0.
March 15, 2017
Amending the Steam Pump Village PAD to permit an indoor self-storage facility.
Only one person spoke in support. Five Oro Valley residents and two business owners spoke in opposition. Oro Valley resident, Diane Bristow, pointed out that it did not meet the majority of General Plan requirements. You can read the arguments she presented HERE.
Despite this, Solomon motioned and Rodman seconded to approve it “based on a finding that the request conforms with the Your Voice, Our Future General Plan.”
Motion carried 7-0.
All motions passed unanimously including one 6-0 vote when Councilmember Hornat left the room. (There were no discussions on four agenda items this evening).
April 5, 2017
Adopting the OV Main Streets Concept Plan.
Discussion, direction, and possible action from Town Council regarding the funding and construction of additional sport fields and related improvements for Naranja Park.
All motions passed 7-0 (There was discussion on the above two items).
April 19, 2017
Funding and construction of additional sports fields and related improvements for Naranja Park. PUBLIC COMMENT.
Thirteen residents spoke in favor. (They were all involved in sports either as coaches or from having children who play Little League, etc.) Two residents spoke in opposition.
Mayor Hiremath motioned and Pina seconded to place this item on the May 3rd agenda and directed staff to come back with a question for council consideration to place this item on the November 7, 2017 ballot.
Motion carried 7-0 (with discussion). All motions this evening passed 7-0.
Part 3 will be published on Wednesday, August 23rd.
Monday, March 4, 2019
How Council Member Steve Solomon Lied During the January 9th Council Meeting
Item 3 on the agenda of the January 9th council meeting was “Establishing a Budget and Finance Commission and establishing the tasking and operations of said commission.”
The original Finance and Bond Commission was dissolved in 2010 during the Hiremath reign. Mayor Winfield wanted to bring it back to allow for more community involvement. He explained, “I have a strong belief in our boards and commissions and the important function they have in our community.”
Council Member Solomon paints himself into a corner
Council Member Steve Solomon tried to paint himself in a positive light, but ended up painting himself into a corner during the July 9th meeting. During the discussions, he claimed that he had nothing to do with abolishing the original Finance and Bond Commission in 2010.
Solomon claimed at the meeting: "…in the past, there was kind of a failure of this prior committee because when I first came on council in 2010, we discovered that the budget that was approved by the prior council, through whatever this bond or finance committee was, had a $3M deficit which they never bothered to point out or emphasize and we had to deal with it. After that committee was dissolved, and I wasn’t involved in the dissolution, what happened was that for the last 7 years, the town has run a surplus in the budget so I just want to make it clear that we do not have a budget problem."
Does he think that LOVE doesn’t have fact-checkers?
There are multiple problems with Solomon’s claims
Devils, rakes, and shovels…oh my!
But wait, there’s more! During his arguments, Solomon also made the following comments:
"Now more citizen input is always nice but the devil’s in the details. So my question is…what is this group of people going to do? Are they going to go through the budget and say, ‘We’re spending too much money on parks and not enough money on planning and zoning.’ Or are they going to say, ‘Wait a minute, Parks and Rec…there’s a line item, we need 10 shovels…we want 5 rakes. Is the committee going to say, ‘No, I think rakes are better than shovels. We should buy 10 rakes and 5 shovels.'"(Well, if anyone knows about shoveling stuff, it’s Steve Solomon.)
He continued: "This is not unreasonable because this is what happens when you put a group together. So we need to be clear on what do we expect from them. Do we expect them to tell us that Parks and Rec has the wrong number of rakes and shovels? Do we expect them to tell us that the Police are getting too much money and Parks and Rec is getting too little money? Do we expect them to tell us that…we should cut out golf?...Are they going to slow the process up?...What role are these citizens going to have and are they going to have the background to contribute positively to it, which would be wonderful. We can’t just grab a group of five people and throw them into this and say, ‘Here’s the budget. Give us recommendations.’"
If Solomon had read the Council packet including the attachments, he would have known exactly what the responsibilities of the Finance Commission would be. The functions of the Commission were spelled out clearly. One needs to read the Resolution you are voting on before you vote. It appears that Solomon was too lazy to do his job and instead relied on the verbal summary from staff.
For the record, the Town Council isn’t going to just “grab a group of five people and throw them into this” and it was insulting to Mayor Winfield for Councilmember Solomon to even suggest this absurd possibility.
Supporting town documents showing that Councilmember Solomon voted to dissolve the former Finance and Bond Commission
The original Finance and Bond Commission was dissolved in 2010 during the Hiremath reign. Mayor Winfield wanted to bring it back to allow for more community involvement. He explained, “I have a strong belief in our boards and commissions and the important function they have in our community.”
Council Member Solomon paints himself into a corner
Council Member Steve Solomon tried to paint himself in a positive light, but ended up painting himself into a corner during the July 9th meeting. During the discussions, he claimed that he had nothing to do with abolishing the original Finance and Bond Commission in 2010.
Solomon claimed at the meeting: "…in the past, there was kind of a failure of this prior committee because when I first came on council in 2010, we discovered that the budget that was approved by the prior council, through whatever this bond or finance committee was, had a $3M deficit which they never bothered to point out or emphasize and we had to deal with it. After that committee was dissolved, and I wasn’t involved in the dissolution, what happened was that for the last 7 years, the town has run a surplus in the budget so I just want to make it clear that we do not have a budget problem."
Does he think that LOVE doesn’t have fact-checkers?
There are multiple problems with Solomon’s claims
- Solomon claims that a previous deficit was the fault of the prior Finance and Bond Commission. That’s nonsense. Staff has the final call on what is presented to the council. How many times did we hear from the Hiremath council that they didn’t need to get into the weeds because “we have staff and staff are the experts.” We found it curious that Finance Director, Stacey Lemos, said nothing when Solomon blamed the supposed “deficit” on the former commission members.
- There was never a deficit. The Hiremath Council did not inherit a $3 million deficit as Solomon claimed. First of all, it is against State law to have a deficient budget. The Council was told by the Town Manager (Jerene Watson at that time) that they needed to increase revenues or the staff was going to suffer layoffs and/or 4 day weeks. The Hiremath Council responded by doubling the Utility Tax from 2% to 4%.
The 2011-2012 tentative, proposed budget showed a $3.1 million difference between requested spending and forecasted revenues. That’s not a deficit. A deficit only occurs when actual spending exceeds actual revenues. That never happened. This is the $3 million to which Councilmember Solomon refers. This was the Majority-4's budget. They did not inherit it from any previous council.
- Solomon maintains that he wasn't involved in the Board’s dissolution, yet he was one of seven council members who voted unanimously to dissolve that commission.
Here’s the timeline:
June 2, 2010
Mayor Hiremath and his Majority-4 council took the oath of office.
June 16, 2010
Steve Solomon was appointed to fill a vacancy left when Salette Latas resigned two months earlier. Solomon’s term was effective until June 6, 2012. (The Finance and Bond Commission was still active when Solomon took office.)
December 1, 2010
The vote to dissolve the former Finance and Bond Commission took place during this council meeting. Solomon was on council and was present that night.
Item 7A on the agenda was a “Discussion and possible action regarding the Finance and Bond Commission.” The vote was 7-0 to dissolve the commission. There was no discussion prior to the vote. Solomon did not argue against dissolving this commission and he voted to dissolve it.
Or in Solomon’s words, “I wasn’t involved in the dissolution.”These are more examples of why you should not trust anything that Councilmember Steve Solomon asserts. He appears to just make it up as he goes along, saying whatever paints him (or the prior Majority-4) in a positive light.
Devils, rakes, and shovels…oh my!
But wait, there’s more! During his arguments, Solomon also made the following comments:
"Now more citizen input is always nice but the devil’s in the details. So my question is…what is this group of people going to do? Are they going to go through the budget and say, ‘We’re spending too much money on parks and not enough money on planning and zoning.’ Or are they going to say, ‘Wait a minute, Parks and Rec…there’s a line item, we need 10 shovels…we want 5 rakes. Is the committee going to say, ‘No, I think rakes are better than shovels. We should buy 10 rakes and 5 shovels.'"(Well, if anyone knows about shoveling stuff, it’s Steve Solomon.)
He continued: "This is not unreasonable because this is what happens when you put a group together. So we need to be clear on what do we expect from them. Do we expect them to tell us that Parks and Rec has the wrong number of rakes and shovels? Do we expect them to tell us that the Police are getting too much money and Parks and Rec is getting too little money? Do we expect them to tell us that…we should cut out golf?...Are they going to slow the process up?...What role are these citizens going to have and are they going to have the background to contribute positively to it, which would be wonderful. We can’t just grab a group of five people and throw them into this and say, ‘Here’s the budget. Give us recommendations.’"
If Solomon had read the Council packet including the attachments, he would have known exactly what the responsibilities of the Finance Commission would be. The functions of the Commission were spelled out clearly. One needs to read the Resolution you are voting on before you vote. It appears that Solomon was too lazy to do his job and instead relied on the verbal summary from staff.
For the record, the Town Council isn’t going to just “grab a group of five people and throw them into this” and it was insulting to Mayor Winfield for Councilmember Solomon to even suggest this absurd possibility.
Supporting town documents showing that Councilmember Solomon voted to dissolve the former Finance and Bond Commission
![]() |
| Roll Call for 12/1/10 meeting showing that Solomon was present |
![]() |
| Motion Carried 7-0 |
Monday, March 5, 2012
The Steve "The Trashman" Solomon "Bamboozle"
---
The Steve "The Trashman" Solomon "Bamboozle" is not a new dance. No. It is the same old "money and lies" dance political hacks have used for decades to get elected.
---
Based on Pre-Primary finance reports, Steve "The Trashman" Solomon has spent almost twice as much as the combined spending of Brendan Burns, Bill Garner, Mark Napier and Mike Zinkin. His $10,100 personal loan to his campaign is three times greater than combined the campaign loans of these four.
Solomon is trying to buy the election.
Does this tactic sound familiar? It should. We have seen this tactic before.
In 2010, Satish Hiremath spent more than $50,000, $37,000 more than his opponent, to gain a 31-vote margin in the Oro Valley Mayoral election.
Solomon is using the "Satish Hiremath Buy-The-Election" formula: Invest outrageous personal sums in the election and seek the endorsement of special interests, of which we have previously posted. Why not? This formula worked before.
There is a difference, though, in the situations of Hiremath and Solomon.
In 2010, no one knew Satish Hiremath. We can understand why he wanted to spend so much money to dazzle the voters. He had no record on which to stand. He was a stealth candidate whom some underestimated. He was the new face in town, ready the sweep clean the ten-year reign of Paul Loomis.
In 2012, Steve "The Trashman" Solomon's situation is different from that of Satish Hiremath's. Solomon's problem is not that he is not known, as in Hiremath's case in 2010. Solomon's problem is that he is known. People know who he is. They know for what he stands.
Solomon has to spend outrageous sums to "bamboozle" the voters into thinking that he is not who he is.
---
"Bamboozle he does" with:
Yes. Solomon wants to buy the election. Solomon wants you to forget who he is. Solomon wants to scare you into voting for him. These are three good reasons not to vote for him.
The Steve "The Trashman" Solomon "Bamboozle" is not a new dance. No. It is the same old "money and lies" dance political hacks have used for decades to get elected.
---
Based on Pre-Primary finance reports, Steve "The Trashman" Solomon has spent almost twice as much as the combined spending of Brendan Burns, Bill Garner, Mark Napier and Mike Zinkin. His $10,100 personal loan to his campaign is three times greater than combined the campaign loans of these four.
Solomon is trying to buy the election.
Does this tactic sound familiar? It should. We have seen this tactic before.
In 2010, Satish Hiremath spent more than $50,000, $37,000 more than his opponent, to gain a 31-vote margin in the Oro Valley Mayoral election.
Solomon is using the "Satish Hiremath Buy-The-Election" formula: Invest outrageous personal sums in the election and seek the endorsement of special interests, of which we have previously posted. Why not? This formula worked before.
There is a difference, though, in the situations of Hiremath and Solomon.
In 2010, no one knew Satish Hiremath. We can understand why he wanted to spend so much money to dazzle the voters. He had no record on which to stand. He was a stealth candidate whom some underestimated. He was the new face in town, ready the sweep clean the ten-year reign of Paul Loomis.
In 2012, Steve "The Trashman" Solomon's situation is different from that of Satish Hiremath's. Solomon's problem is not that he is not known, as in Hiremath's case in 2010. Solomon's problem is that he is known. People know who he is. They know for what he stands.
Solomon has to spend outrageous sums to "bamboozle" the voters into thinking that he is not who he is.
---
"Bamboozle he does" with:
- Huge Explorer Ads ($2,000 per his Pre-Primary Report)
- Wicked Ugly Glossy Postcards and Giant Wicked Ugly Yellow Signs ($4,000 per his Pre-Primary Report
Yes. Solomon wants to buy the election. Solomon wants you to forget who he is. Solomon wants to scare you into voting for him. These are three good reasons not to vote for him.
Wednesday, August 9, 2017
Editorial ~ The Voting Record of the Oro Valley Town Council “Majority-7” (Part 1.)
This is the first of a 3-part series where we will present the voting record for the new Oro Valley Town Council beginning with their first council meeting on November 16, 2016 and ending June 21, 2017 (the last meeting of the fiscal year which ended on June 30th). There were many more votes than what is presented below, but in the interest of space, we have expounded only on the most important items.A total of 12 meetings were held. With the exception of one vote, all votes were approved unanimously; the majority of them with little to no discussion. (So much for their claims of being “independent thinkers.” They really should call themselves “The Rubberstamp Council.”)
November 16, 2016
The three new council members (Rhonda Pina, Bill Rodman, Steve Solomon) were sworn in.
Regular Agenda Items
Amending the GP land use map at Rancho Vistoso Blvd. and Vistoso Highlands Drive from neighborhood commercial/office to medium density residential for 17.8 acre property. Major General Plan amendment.
Of note is that during the 9/2/16 meeting, this agenda item was moved to tonight’s meeting at Mayor Hiremath’s suggestion. Applicant Paul Oland of the WLB Group agreed. That way, the new council would be seated when this vote was taken and there would be no discussion on the item. With former Councilmembers Burns, Garner, and Zinkin no longer there to speak for the citizens, this Major General Plan amendment would be easily approved.
Also of note, the new General Plan was just approved by the voters on 11/8/16. Just 8 days later, they are looking to amend it.
A portion of former Mayor Paul Loomis’ speech that evening:
“What I do want to highlight is that you’re amending the General Plan even before the vote has been certified. Past policy was to not allow amendments in the year of revisions or for a year after voter approval.”Despite this well-reasoned plea by non other than our former mayor, Rodman motioned to approve. Waters seconded.
Motion carried 7-0 with MINIMAL discussion.
Allowing the use of ESL flexible design option for a modified review process for above property.
Rodman motion to approve. Snider seconded. Motion carried 7-0.
Conceptual site plan for Alterra at Vistoso Trails subdivision. Half-mile east of Rancho Vistoso Blvd. and Moore Road.
Waters motion to approve. Solomon seconded.
Motion carried 7-0. NO DISCUSSION.
Proposed grading exception for the Sanctuary at Silverhawke subdivision near NE corner of First and Naranja. (East side of First at Naranja traffic light).
The rolling hills are 19-20 feet high from the intersection. Town Code does not allow grading in excess of 6 feet. Applicant requested to grade 12-15 feet in order to build a straight access road into the development.
Solomon motioned to approve. Hornat seconded.
Motion carried 7-0. NO DISCUSSION.
All motions carried 7-0.
December 7, 2016
Don Cox’s appointment to Planning & Zoning Commission (Consent Agenda)
NO DISCUSSION despite the council receiving letters of concern from multiple residents about his repeated inappropriate and unprofessional behavior while serving past terms on P&Z.
Approving conceptual architecture and landscape plan for 8000 sf commercial building at El Corredor, NE corner of Linda Vista and Oracle.
Both items approved 7-0 with NO DISCUSSION.
Regular Agenda
Tonight’s agenda contained 7 items. Six of them passed 7-0.
(Hornat was opposed to El Con HOA using golf course property for a shed.)
January 4, 2017
Meeting was over in 6 minutes! Two motions made. Both carried 7-0.
January 18, 2017
Agreement between TOV and RTA for a pedestrian and traffic signal on LaCanada at the entrance to the Community Center. (Consent Agenda, Item D.)
Finally, we have some discussion!
Councilmember Pina asked about the $500,000 price and if there were cost overruns, what would be the impact to the town? Paul Keesler (Director of Community Development and Public Works) responded that there are 3 things that can cause a project to go over.
1. During the bidding process, once the Intergovernmental Agreement (IGA) is authorized by the town council, if the lowest bid comes in over $500,000 the town is not required to make up that difference. The RTA would have to increase the budget with approval from their management board or the project could be canceled. Chances are with an RTA project, particularly a safety project like this, they’re not going to cancel it, so on the off chance that the bids come in high, the RTA covers it.
2. Once the contract is signed and the contractor has begun work, if some unforeseen condition arises which could push it over the budget, the IGA makes accommodations for that. If it’s within 10%, the RTA staff can approve it. If it’s over 10%, it would go to the RTA board to get approved for that overage.
3. The only time the town is on the hook for this is if during the project, we add an element not anticipated by the town such as a sidewalk or extra street lights.
Vice-Mayor Waters asked what kind of light will it be. Paul Keesler responded:
Originally it was going to be a HAWK signal just for pedestrians. But we also have a sight visibility issue with people coming out of the Community Center having a hard time seeing the traffic coming north. Rearranging the landscaping didn’t help so the Town went back to the RTA and got this budget approved for not only a pedestrian crossing but also a traffic signal.
Motion to approve by Pina. Seconded by Snider.
Motion carried 6-0. Mayor Hiremath was absent.
Discussion and possible direction to staff regarding future Community Center elements.
Town Council directed staff to hire a consultant to review options available for the CC restaurant facility and the configuration of the golf course, and to prepare a Request for Proposal (RFP), solicit bids, and return to Council with the information received from those requests.
Approving the final plat for the Sanctuary at Silverhawke, residential subdivision located at the NE corner of Naranja and First.
Motion carried 6-0. NO DISCUSSION.
All motions carried 6-0.
Part 2 will be published next Wednesday, August 16th.
Thursday, March 15, 2012
What Did It Mean?
---
The election of three candidates to Council in the primary must certainly be a record. The last time more than one candidate was elected to Council in the primary was in 2008, when Bill Garner was last elected.
The three candidates earned 61% of the total votes cast. This is an unbelievable result.
Why did it happen?
Was is partisanship? No.
We were fearful that party lines would blur the election results. We wrote about this previously. Our fears were not realized. The affiliation of our voters:
The election results were not entirely "partisan" in that the candidates who were elected had to achieve support form all three voting blocks.
Was it lavish spending on glossy postcards and color ads in the Explorer? No. Had it been than then Steve Solomon would have been elected.
Was it the visible, high level pressure and support of current council members: Mary Snider, Joe Hornat and Lou Waters? No, we don't think so. Their "stealth candidate", Fred Nacaroti, barely mustered 8% of the total votes cast; a mere 2,147 votes. He came in last.
Was it Mayor Hiremath saying, at the last council meeting, that Steve Solomon saved Coyote Run when the record shows that it was Bill Garner who identified bed tax revenue as the source of funds to save Coyote Run while Solomon, along with the rest of the Gang of 5, initially voted to kill it.
Or maybe it was the email that Lou Waters sent out urging voters to vote for the losing three candidates. No. That didn't work either.
Was it the endorsements of the Oro Valley Police Associations and SAHBA? No. The winning candidates sought no endorsements and received only the endorsements of the people.
So what was it? What was it that drove such a unanimous verdict by the people?
Perhaps it was Snider, Hornat and Waters giggling and making fun of the winning candidates while sitting in the back of the room at Sun City candidate forum.
Perhaps it was the fact that this council appointed someone as a Council Member who was so opposite to the person who the people had elected, essentially robbing the people of their vote and their representation. Doing this resulted in absolute control and guaranteed many 5-2 votes.
Perhaps it was the recent vote to reduce transparency by changing the minutes of meetings to summary minutes only; a move led by Mayor Hiremath and Steve Solomon.
Perhaps it was the doubling of the Utility Tax in 2010, done by the new Council just days after they took office. Did they think that we would forget? It may just be a few pennies to Steve Solomon, as he pointed out at the NPCC Candidate Forum this month. To people on fixed income, however, its real dollars.
Perhaps it was the struggle of the residents of Neighborhood 7 in Rancho Vistoso to prevent an amendment to their PAD to allow apartments.
Perhaps it was the prospect of apartments on the Ford Property in Rancho Vistoso that, once again, the residents had to "rise up" to prevent.
Perhaps it was the fact that the current council make-up would not even consider a management study of 46% of Oro Valley's operating budget. In fact, cancelling this study of the Police Department was among the first things they did when they took control in 2010. It was obvious patronage. It was wrong.
Perhaps it was the hard work on the part of the three winning council candidates. Certainly, that played a major role.
Regardless of why, this Tuesday the voters of Oro Valley stated in clear terms that they want Council Members who put the interests of the people first. They want Council Members who will involve them in decisions, not simply tell them to "trust" them. They want a diversity of views on the council.
They simply want to Let Oro Valley Excel.
---
The election of three candidates to Council in the primary must certainly be a record. The last time more than one candidate was elected to Council in the primary was in 2008, when Bill Garner was last elected.
The three candidates earned 61% of the total votes cast. This is an unbelievable result.
Why did it happen?
Was is partisanship? No.
We were fearful that party lines would blur the election results. We wrote about this previously. Our fears were not realized. The affiliation of our voters:
- Republican 48%
- Democrat 27%
- Independent 25%
The election results were not entirely "partisan" in that the candidates who were elected had to achieve support form all three voting blocks.
Was it lavish spending on glossy postcards and color ads in the Explorer? No. Had it been than then Steve Solomon would have been elected.
Was it the visible, high level pressure and support of current council members: Mary Snider, Joe Hornat and Lou Waters? No, we don't think so. Their "stealth candidate", Fred Nacaroti, barely mustered 8% of the total votes cast; a mere 2,147 votes. He came in last.
Was it Mayor Hiremath saying, at the last council meeting, that Steve Solomon saved Coyote Run when the record shows that it was Bill Garner who identified bed tax revenue as the source of funds to save Coyote Run while Solomon, along with the rest of the Gang of 5, initially voted to kill it.
Or maybe it was the email that Lou Waters sent out urging voters to vote for the losing three candidates. No. That didn't work either.
Was it the endorsements of the Oro Valley Police Associations and SAHBA? No. The winning candidates sought no endorsements and received only the endorsements of the people.
So what was it? What was it that drove such a unanimous verdict by the people?
Perhaps it was Snider, Hornat and Waters giggling and making fun of the winning candidates while sitting in the back of the room at Sun City candidate forum.
Perhaps it was the fact that this council appointed someone as a Council Member who was so opposite to the person who the people had elected, essentially robbing the people of their vote and their representation. Doing this resulted in absolute control and guaranteed many 5-2 votes.
Perhaps it was the recent vote to reduce transparency by changing the minutes of meetings to summary minutes only; a move led by Mayor Hiremath and Steve Solomon.
Perhaps it was the doubling of the Utility Tax in 2010, done by the new Council just days after they took office. Did they think that we would forget? It may just be a few pennies to Steve Solomon, as he pointed out at the NPCC Candidate Forum this month. To people on fixed income, however, its real dollars.
Perhaps it was the struggle of the residents of Neighborhood 7 in Rancho Vistoso to prevent an amendment to their PAD to allow apartments.
Perhaps it was the prospect of apartments on the Ford Property in Rancho Vistoso that, once again, the residents had to "rise up" to prevent.
Perhaps it was the fact that the current council make-up would not even consider a management study of 46% of Oro Valley's operating budget. In fact, cancelling this study of the Police Department was among the first things they did when they took control in 2010. It was obvious patronage. It was wrong.
Perhaps it was the hard work on the part of the three winning council candidates. Certainly, that played a major role.
Regardless of why, this Tuesday the voters of Oro Valley stated in clear terms that they want Council Members who put the interests of the people first. They want Council Members who will involve them in decisions, not simply tell them to "trust" them. They want a diversity of views on the council.
They simply want to Let Oro Valley Excel.
---
Wednesday, June 1, 2011
Mary Snider Calls Recall Of Her & Joe Hornat "Irresponsible"
So, Mary Snider believes the PAC that initiated a recall of her and fellow Council Member Hornat is "irresponsible."
Her reason, as reported in The Explorer, is "because of the cost and the damage to the Oro Valley image a recall will cause."
Well--- Ms. Snider should have given a little more thought (did she give any thought, whatsoever?)what her voting record in her one year in office has done to the people of Oro Valley?
We have documented her abysmal record in a number of postings, but it's worth repeating once again. (By the way, her record is wonderful if you happen to be any one of a number of Special Interest Groups. It's only abysmal if you are one of the unfortunate citizens that has been so negatively impacted by this lady.)
Briefly, she:
1) Voted to appoint Steve Solomon, a developer to the vacant council seat, bypassing 18 other candidates that didn't meet HER prerequisite (they were only volunteer citizens)
2) Voted to approve a temporary budget that included a doubling of our Utility Tax WITHOUT any concern for the impact of those that can barely make "ends meet."
3) With total disregard to our elderly and disabled, she voted for the demise of the Coyote Run Bus Service, leaving hundreds of our fellow citizens scampering to find other transportation to doctors, shopping, therapy, etc.
4) Agreed with our Town Manager (who just resigned) that it's a great idea to give OV employees the day before Christmas & New Years off WITH pay. And let's not forget, that also includes their birthday. Great for the workers. Not so great for the people (taxpayers) who must pay for the thousands of dollars in lost work productivity.
5) I won't even go into detail, on the way she treats the cops. She thinks they are Gods that deserve raises, free cars and who knows how many other perks that WE pay for.
Now, Mary Snider says, we're being "irresponsible." Look in the mirror lady
Her reason, as reported in The Explorer, is "because of the cost and the damage to the Oro Valley image a recall will cause."
Well--- Ms. Snider should have given a little more thought (did she give any thought, whatsoever?)what her voting record in her one year in office has done to the people of Oro Valley?
We have documented her abysmal record in a number of postings, but it's worth repeating once again. (By the way, her record is wonderful if you happen to be any one of a number of Special Interest Groups. It's only abysmal if you are one of the unfortunate citizens that has been so negatively impacted by this lady.)
Briefly, she:
1) Voted to appoint Steve Solomon, a developer to the vacant council seat, bypassing 18 other candidates that didn't meet HER prerequisite (they were only volunteer citizens)
2) Voted to approve a temporary budget that included a doubling of our Utility Tax WITHOUT any concern for the impact of those that can barely make "ends meet."
3) With total disregard to our elderly and disabled, she voted for the demise of the Coyote Run Bus Service, leaving hundreds of our fellow citizens scampering to find other transportation to doctors, shopping, therapy, etc.
4) Agreed with our Town Manager (who just resigned) that it's a great idea to give OV employees the day before Christmas & New Years off WITH pay. And let's not forget, that also includes their birthday. Great for the workers. Not so great for the people (taxpayers) who must pay for the thousands of dollars in lost work productivity.
5) I won't even go into detail, on the way she treats the cops. She thinks they are Gods that deserve raises, free cars and who knows how many other perks that WE pay for.
Now, Mary Snider says, we're being "irresponsible." Look in the mirror lady
Monday, July 25, 2016
Guest View-Diane Peters: Who's Really To Blame For Oro Valley's High Density Developments?
Many Oro Valley residents have stated their displeasure with all the high density developments that have been approved since Mayor Hiremath and Councilmembers Hornat, Snider, and Waters took office in 2010. The three new apartment complexes on Oracle Road have been most frequently cited.In response, someone, has attempted to take the onus off the Majority-4 by claiming, in a published letter entitled "Laughable Presentation,that all three apartment complexes on Oracle Road were approved by a unanimous vote. The writer specifically named Councilmembers Burns, Garner, and Zinkin as partaking in those unanimous votes.
The writer was wrong.
- All votes were not unanimous.
- Zinkin and Burns were not on council when these approvals occured.
- Garner voted against two of the three complexes.
Encantada at Steam Pump ~ 270 apartments:
This rezoning was approved in April 2011. Mike Zinkin and Brendan Burns were not on council. They took office on June 6, 2012, so how could they have voted to approve a rezoning that took place in 2011? The Conceptual and Architecture Plans for this project were approved in May 2012, but it would still be another month before Burns and Zinkin would take office.
El Corredor at Oracle and Linda Vista ~220 apartments:
This one required a Major General Plan Amendment to convert 13 acres to high density residential. That vote took place in December 2011. Zinkin and Burns were not on council and Bill Garner voted against it. When the high density rezoning for this project was approved in May 2012, Zinkin and Burns were still one month shy of having any voting powers on the town council.
Villas at San Dorado ~ 274 apartments:
This rezoning was approved in April 2012. That’s right… Zinkin and Burns were still not on council and Bill Garner was absent that night. Yet the writer claimed that all three of them voted to approve it! When the Conceptual Site Plan was approved in November 2012, Zinkin and Garner were opposed.
Then council member, now current council candidate, Steve Solomon voted to approve all of these:
- Encantada: Solomon approved the rezoning, the Conceptual Site Plan, and the Architecture Plan.
- El Corredor: Solomon approved the Major General Plan Amendment and the rezoning that followed.
- Villas at San Dorado: Solomon approved the rezoning. He lost his bid for re-election the following month.
Diane Peters
Oro Valley Resident
Tuesday, July 21, 2020
Guest View: Diane Peters ~ Rodman-Solomon-Greene campaign postcard is a pack of lies
Town Council candidates Rodman, Solomon, and Greene recently sent out a campaign postcard where they falsely attack “The Other Guys” (Tim Bohen and Bill Garner). They also posted a picture of the postcard on their Facebook pages.
They should have called it “The Other Lies” because everything they said about Bill Garner and Tim Bohen is a lie.
Below are some examples.
• Don’t support law enforcement, first responders, or education
Bill Garner spent 20 years in emergency services including as a firefighter, an emergency medical technician, an assistant squad chief, and an Emergency Management Director. Garner also has a Master’s degree in Public Safety. Does that sound like the resume’ of someone who doesn’t support law enforcement or first responders?
Additionally, when Garner was on council in 2009, it was he and former councilmember Salette Latas who collaborated on a proposal to save 6 police officer positions that were going to be cut from the 2009-2010 police budget. You can read about it HERE.
From Bill Garner’s Facebook page:
• Encourage policies that will likely lead to a property tax
The property tax lie is a scare tactic that they pull every election. Garner was on council from 2008-2016 and never once discussed a desire for a property tax. He has publicly stated that he is opposed to one. The fact is that the Town Council could not institute a property tax even if they wanted to. It has to be placed on the ballot for the citizens to decide. If elected, Bill Garner and Tim Bohen would not even have the power to institute a property tax.
However, Steve Solomon did vote to increase your utility tax from 2% to 4%.
• Have no history of support for neighborhood preservation
When Garner was on council (2008-2016) he (along with Councilmembers Zinkin and Burns) worked with me and my citizens’ group for 9 months during 2014-2015 to “preserve our neighborhood.” Those three council members guided my citizens’ group throughout the process of fighting a Major General Plan Amendment that, if approved, would have completely changed the character of our neighborhood by turning 200 acres of pristine desert into a “Master Planned Community."
Multiple meetings and negotiations took place between my citizens’ group and the applicant. Whenever there was an impasse, Councilmembers Garner, Zinkin, or Burns would negotiate with the applicant on our behalf.
Through 9 months of negotiations, we succeeded in removing apartments, a senior care facility, and almost 300 homes from the plan. We also obtained larger buffer zones between the new development and the existing neighborhoods. The night of the council vote, I publicly thanked Burns-Garner-Zinkin for all of their help. It’s in the PUBLIC RECORD.
Were they too lazy to fact-check or are their lies deliberate?
Either Rodman-Solomon-Greene’s fact checking skills are lacking or they are deliberately lying in order to get votes from uninformed people. Which one is it? Either way, it doesn't speak well of them. Are these the kind of people that you want on your Town Council?
Mo Greene hides the truth
I posted the above information on Mo Greene’s Facebook page. Rather than admit to his error and apologize for it, he deleted my comment and blocked me from further posting. I assumed he would do that in order to hide the truth, which is why I took a screenshot immediately after posting it. You can view it below.
If you want honesty and transparency in Oro Valley government, I suggest that you join me in voting for Bill Garner and Tim Bohen.
---
Diane Peters has lived in Oro Valley since 2003, moving here to escape the humidity of the East Coast. She’s been involved in OV politics and development issues since 2006. In 2014, she organized a citizens group that successfully negotiated a controversial 200-acre development project. In her past life, she worked in medical research at various University Hospitals in New England. Her interests include reading, writing, nature photography, travel, art galleries, museums, and politics.
They should have called it “The Other Lies” because everything they said about Bill Garner and Tim Bohen is a lie.
Below are some examples.
• Don’t support law enforcement, first responders, or education
Bill Garner spent 20 years in emergency services including as a firefighter, an emergency medical technician, an assistant squad chief, and an Emergency Management Director. Garner also has a Master’s degree in Public Safety. Does that sound like the resume’ of someone who doesn’t support law enforcement or first responders?
Additionally, when Garner was on council in 2009, it was he and former councilmember Salette Latas who collaborated on a proposal to save 6 police officer positions that were going to be cut from the 2009-2010 police budget. You can read about it HERE.
From Bill Garner’s Facebook page:
I support our police department, as well as the public safety and emergency responders that assist our community in time of need when the call goes out. I have the knowledge and education to know what it takes to serve in this line of work and the value brought by these men and women.Regarding education, this is a school board issue, not a town council issue. Secondly, Garner has two school-aged children. It’s nonsensical to claim that he doesn’t support education.
• Encourage policies that will likely lead to a property tax
The property tax lie is a scare tactic that they pull every election. Garner was on council from 2008-2016 and never once discussed a desire for a property tax. He has publicly stated that he is opposed to one. The fact is that the Town Council could not institute a property tax even if they wanted to. It has to be placed on the ballot for the citizens to decide. If elected, Bill Garner and Tim Bohen would not even have the power to institute a property tax.
However, Steve Solomon did vote to increase your utility tax from 2% to 4%.
• Have no history of support for neighborhood preservation
When Garner was on council (2008-2016) he (along with Councilmembers Zinkin and Burns) worked with me and my citizens’ group for 9 months during 2014-2015 to “preserve our neighborhood.” Those three council members guided my citizens’ group throughout the process of fighting a Major General Plan Amendment that, if approved, would have completely changed the character of our neighborhood by turning 200 acres of pristine desert into a “Master Planned Community."
Multiple meetings and negotiations took place between my citizens’ group and the applicant. Whenever there was an impasse, Councilmembers Garner, Zinkin, or Burns would negotiate with the applicant on our behalf.
Through 9 months of negotiations, we succeeded in removing apartments, a senior care facility, and almost 300 homes from the plan. We also obtained larger buffer zones between the new development and the existing neighborhoods. The night of the council vote, I publicly thanked Burns-Garner-Zinkin for all of their help. It’s in the PUBLIC RECORD.
Were they too lazy to fact-check or are their lies deliberate?
Either Rodman-Solomon-Greene’s fact checking skills are lacking or they are deliberately lying in order to get votes from uninformed people. Which one is it? Either way, it doesn't speak well of them. Are these the kind of people that you want on your Town Council?
Mo Greene hides the truth
I posted the above information on Mo Greene’s Facebook page. Rather than admit to his error and apologize for it, he deleted my comment and blocked me from further posting. I assumed he would do that in order to hide the truth, which is why I took a screenshot immediately after posting it. You can view it below.
If you want honesty and transparency in Oro Valley government, I suggest that you join me in voting for Bill Garner and Tim Bohen.
---
Diane Peters has lived in Oro Valley since 2003, moving here to escape the humidity of the East Coast. She’s been involved in OV politics and development issues since 2006. In 2014, she organized a citizens group that successfully negotiated a controversial 200-acre development project. In her past life, she worked in medical research at various University Hospitals in New England. Her interests include reading, writing, nature photography, travel, art galleries, museums, and politics.
Monday, August 22, 2016
Guest View ~ Diane Peters: What you need to know about Bill Rodman

Bill Rodman is a former Oro Valley Planning & Zoning Commissioner (2012-2015) who is hoping to unseat one of the incumbents (Brendan Burns, Bill Garner, Mike Zinkin) on the Oro Valley Town Council. What does Bill Rodman bring to the table?
Rodman’s views on the golf course
When Rodman was asked by two local newspapers how he would handle the financial problems of the Community Center golf courses, he responded:
- “Provide the oversight necessary to make sure that we’re analyzing it properly.”
- “If at some point the expenses continue to outstrip the revenues…the golf courses can be closed, partially closed, leased or sold to a third party, and/or made open space.”
Secondly, Councilmembers Burns, Garner, and Zinkin have already proposed closing or partially closing the golf courses, they’ve proposed leasing one course back to the Hilton (which is allowed per the existing contract), they’ve proposed looking for private entities to lease the other 18-hole course, and they’ve proposed turning one or more courses into a linear natural greenway/park. These are the exact same solutions that Rodman is now proposing.
Isn’t it interesting that the Majority-4 are endorsing Rodman when his “ideas” are to simply replicate what Burns-Garner-Zinkin have already been doing or suggesting all along?
Rodman also stated at the August 10th Candidate Forum that the council shouldn’t make any decisions on the golf courses because, “I believe there is a 5-year plan.” Is Rodman aware that Troon’s own forecast continues to show expected losses of $1.4 million dollars in year-five? Can we even trust that figure when the first year was expected to lose $1.5 million and it actually lost $2.4 million? That forecast was off by almost $1 million dollars!
Rodman’s voting record on Planning & Zoning
On Rodman’s Facebook page, he states: “I spent 4 years on Oro Valley’s Planning & Zoning Commission, serving as Chair, advising the town on how to manage growth and make good decisions.”
Below is a sample of the items that Bill Rodman approved while on P&Z. Is this your idea of managed growth and good decision making?
2015
- Increased building heights at Linda Vista and Oracle (El Corredor) within the Oracle Rd. Scenic Corridor District (obstructing mountain views)
- General Plan Amendment, ESL Amendment, and Rezoning for a 5-story retirement community (Nakoma Sky) on 79.5 acres at 1st Ave. and Naranja
- Increased illuminated window signs for businesses
- CUP for a Fry’s gas station at 1st Ave. and Oracle Rd.
- Rezoning of the 39-acre Olsen property from R1-144 to Planned Area Development
- LaCholla Major rezoning, convert 45 acres from R1-144 to R1-7 at LaCholla and Naranja
- Amended zoning code to allow property owners to grade right up to the adjacent property
- Rezoning 149 acres at Tangerine and First Ave. from R1-144 to MDR and commercial
- CUP for U-Haul business at Ace Hardware on First and Tangerine
- Rezoned NE corner of Tangerine and LaCholla from R1-144 to Commercial and NCO
- Major General Plan Amendment of Olsen property from LDR and open space to MDR
- Major General Plan Amendment of Miller Ranch from LDR to MDR
- Rezoned 13 acres at NE corner of Linda Vista and Oracle (El Corredor) to HDR (The Canyons Apts.)
- Major General Plan Amendment for NE corner Tangerine and LaCholla from LDR to NCO
Summary
A vote for Rodman (as well as Pina and Solomon) will result in an abundance of 7-0 votes on council with no discussion or debate, no adherence to the voter-approved General Plan, more rezonings to appease greedy developers, and millions of dollars in continued golf losses.
Diane Peters
Oro Valley Resident
---
This article was submitted directly to us by Diane. She also submitted it to the Arizona Daily Independent where it was published last week. We publish it here to insure complete coverage of this election.
---
Tuesday, July 9, 2024
Your Vote Matters! Discover the Top Candidates for the July 30 Council Election
Your mail in ballot should be in hand
By now, you should have received a mail-in ballot for the July 30 council election, if you requested one. If you have not received a ballot, you should contact the Pima County Recorder to determine where your ballot is. It’s not too late to request a mail-in ballot if you’re not going to be around on June 30 for the election.
Growth...land use...water...financial sustainability at issue
You can vote for up to three council members. However, you should only vote for the council members that you want on the council.
Voting for additional candidates can increase the threshold for the members you want to be elected. This means you can vote for one, two, or three candidates.
...except for council member Mo Greene. In his case, we merely pointed to his record of doing nothing on the council during the past four years, except seconding anything Council Member Steve Solomon proposed.
So, it’s clear to us who the three best candidates are:
- Tim Bohen
- Mary Murphy
- Elizabeth Robb
Bringing Bohen back on council is a "no-brainer”. He works tirelessly for the people and even gets in trouble for it; but he doesn't stop working hard to make sure that things come to light. Adding Murphy and Robb brings fresh thinking to a council that often gets stuck in spending most of its time just complementing town staff for simply breathing. Murphy has some interesting ideas regarding releasing the town council from the bondage of making minuscule golf related decisions. Robb adds fresh thinking on how to bring fiscal sustainability to town finances. Together, these three will will bring a new level council involvement. And let's face it: residents don't need not need four more years of a Solomon's "Yes man. ”
It's important to look beyond this election to the 2026 council election. That election will result in four seats on the council, including the mayor's seat, being open. We don't know who will run for those seats or if the incumbents will seek a third term. However, we do know that it will be a significant election and that outside developer money likely will pour into pro developer candidates.
The 2026 general plan is under development. Those on council for the next two years will have a significant influence over the final product. Land use will be a big issue. Other current issues include whether the Church of the Nazarene will get a sports facility; or if the town will ever extend reclaimed water to three recreational facilities, thus ending the use of drinking water for irrigation. By 2026, fiscal sustainability will be a critical issue. Unless the town moves to annex major open areas, which we do not recommend, it will have to learn how to live within its means—something it has never had to do before.
Elections matter. The future of Oro Valley is in your hands. This is one time you can really make a difference. So please take this opportunity to do so.
- - -
Monday, June 24, 2013
The Debate: Where Should The The Oro Valley Police Department Report? (Part 1)
---
Last week, we reported that the Oro Valley Town Council voted 4-3 at the town council meeting to have The Oro Valley Police Department continue to report to town council as opposed to reporting to Town Manager Greg Caton. The vote occurred after an hour discussion. The discussion revealed the different positions of the Council members. At times, it was an unnecessarily contentious discussion, we think, since the focus of the discussion should have been completely unemotional.
The Question:
Should the police department report to the town council or should it report to the Town Manager?
Background:
Last month, we wrote a two-part piece called: "Removing The Police Department From Oro Valley Politics." Part 1 detailed the history of why the department reports to town council. Part 2 discussed why some council members believed that a discussion of the reporting relationship was appropriate.
It was at the May 1 council meeting that Council Member Burns asked that this item be discussed at a future council meeting. At that time, Burns presented four reasons why he felt that it was worth a future discussion:
The Facts
The Town Of Oro Valley has an outstanding record of public safety for all years, regardless of whether or not the department reported to the town council or to the town manager. The town, for a variety of reasons of which we have previously written, such as an older population and limited road access, has low instances of violent crimes. Oro Valley is a safe community. It is, however, not immune from crime.
In 2009, when the department reported to town manager David Andrews, its budget received detailed scrutiny. The department and its unions went after Andrews and two members of council in a public effort to retain six police positions. Andrews and Council Members Garner and Carter became the targets, with a union ad chastising them on air. Admittedly, it was a mess; but it was not a mess because the department reported to the town manager. It was a mess because the department didn't get its way. Positions were threatened. The union stood up for its members. That's life in the "big city."
Yes. It was contentious, but this budget issue was resolved to everyone's satisfaction. As Town Manager Andrews reported at that time: "Its a win-win situation."
In June 2010, the council, voted (5-2, Gillaspie and Garner dissenting) to eliminate in an independent study of the police department. The purpose of the study was to identify improvements that could be made in the operations of the department, hopefully providing equal or improved public safety at reduced cost.
Those voting to cancel it (Mayor Hiremath and Council Members Hornat, Snider, Solomon and Waters) did so on the basis that the town doesn't need to spend the money. The department is running just fine, according to them, The town was facing a budget challenge at that time, a challenge they met by increasing the utility tax and by canceling this study and an independent study of the parks and recreation department.
It has been 3 years since the Council last visited the subject of the department's reporting relationship. There are two individuals on Council who did not anticipate in the 2010 decision. There is one who sat on that council who now believes that the situation has changed and that, therefore, a change in the reporting relationship may be in order. Certainly, a discussion was warranted.
The Debate
As we said, the debate took place last week. We reported the result. Tomorrow, we will discuss the position of those who voted to retain the existing relationship. Wednesday, we will discuss the position of those who voted to make the change.
You be the judge.
Then, Thursday, we will post our debate analysis.
---
Last week, we reported that the Oro Valley Town Council voted 4-3 at the town council meeting to have The Oro Valley Police Department continue to report to town council as opposed to reporting to Town Manager Greg Caton. The vote occurred after an hour discussion. The discussion revealed the different positions of the Council members. At times, it was an unnecessarily contentious discussion, we think, since the focus of the discussion should have been completely unemotional.The Question:
Should the police department report to the town council or should it report to the Town Manager?
Background:
Last month, we wrote a two-part piece called: "Removing The Police Department From Oro Valley Politics." Part 1 detailed the history of why the department reports to town council. Part 2 discussed why some council members believed that a discussion of the reporting relationship was appropriate.
It was at the May 1 council meeting that Council Member Burns asked that this item be discussed at a future council meeting. At that time, Burns presented four reasons why he felt that it was worth a future discussion:
- The Council does not adequately provide the professional oversight required as required by code;
- This change in the reporting relationship would remove the police department from being the political "football" that it has become;
- The town is being run by professionals, as Mayor Hiremath has so often noted. These professionals should oversee the police department; and
- Oversight by the town manager would increase the synergy, for example, resource sharing, among town departments and town resources.
The Facts
The Town Of Oro Valley has an outstanding record of public safety for all years, regardless of whether or not the department reported to the town council or to the town manager. The town, for a variety of reasons of which we have previously written, such as an older population and limited road access, has low instances of violent crimes. Oro Valley is a safe community. It is, however, not immune from crime.
In 2009, when the department reported to town manager David Andrews, its budget received detailed scrutiny. The department and its unions went after Andrews and two members of council in a public effort to retain six police positions. Andrews and Council Members Garner and Carter became the targets, with a union ad chastising them on air. Admittedly, it was a mess; but it was not a mess because the department reported to the town manager. It was a mess because the department didn't get its way. Positions were threatened. The union stood up for its members. That's life in the "big city."
Yes. It was contentious, but this budget issue was resolved to everyone's satisfaction. As Town Manager Andrews reported at that time: "Its a win-win situation."
In June 2010, the council, voted (5-2, Gillaspie and Garner dissenting) to eliminate in an independent study of the police department. The purpose of the study was to identify improvements that could be made in the operations of the department, hopefully providing equal or improved public safety at reduced cost.
Those voting to cancel it (Mayor Hiremath and Council Members Hornat, Snider, Solomon and Waters) did so on the basis that the town doesn't need to spend the money. The department is running just fine, according to them, The town was facing a budget challenge at that time, a challenge they met by increasing the utility tax and by canceling this study and an independent study of the parks and recreation department.
It has been 3 years since the Council last visited the subject of the department's reporting relationship. There are two individuals on Council who did not anticipate in the 2010 decision. There is one who sat on that council who now believes that the situation has changed and that, therefore, a change in the reporting relationship may be in order. Certainly, a discussion was warranted.
The Debate
As we said, the debate took place last week. We reported the result. Tomorrow, we will discuss the position of those who voted to retain the existing relationship. Wednesday, we will discuss the position of those who voted to make the change.
You be the judge.
Then, Thursday, we will post our debate analysis.
---
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)







