Showing posts sorted by relevance for query solomon favoritism. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query solomon favoritism. Sort by date Show all posts

Wednesday, July 15, 2020

The Solomon Chronicles. Part 6. Promises and Lies

This is the final installment in our series of articles entitled, “The Solomon Chronicles,” highlighting the abysmal record of Councilmember Steve Solomon who is running for re-election. This series was written by a LOVE contributor and contains a synopsis of previous LOVE articles plus new information.
- - -
This article will discuss some of the lies that Steve Solomon is currently telling along with some of the lies he told when running for election in 2016.

Solomon’s golf course lie
We present this one to show you that Solomon has a history of lying. Solomon told this whopper when running for Town Council in 2016. He distributed this lie in a campaign flyer that was delivered to the homes along the town-owned golf courses in Canada Hills. At that time, he (along with Bill Rodman and Rhonda Pina) was running against incumbents Brendan Burns, Bill Garner, and Mike Zinkin. The flyer stated:
“Save your home value! The incumbents running for re-election have pledged to close and sell your golf course destroying your home value!” The flyer was “Paid for by Solomon for OV Council.”
That was an outright lie. Burns, Garner, and Zinkin had never pledged any such thing and when an Oro Valley resident asked Solomon to prove that they did, he couldn’t. He made it up. It was a complete fabrication designed to trick uninformed voters into voting for him…and they did.

Solomon’s $3 million deficit lie
Solomon actually used the adjective “whopping” in his next lie. A Freudian slip, perhaps? Because it’s another whopper of a lie. And he not only told this whopper when running for council in 2016, but he is repeating it again in the current 2020 election. He stated it during Jim Horn’s Town Hall podcast held on June 25th.

Here’s what he said during that Town Hall:
“During my time on council, I helped guide the town to financial success. From 2008-2010, the council generated a whopping $3 million dollar deficit. When I first took office in 2010, myself and the other new council members balanced the budget, eventually generating $2 million in annual surpluses.”
He also said it during the January 9, 2019 council meeting:
“…when I first came on council in 2010, we discovered that the budget that was approved by the prior council…had a $3 million deficit which they never bothered to point out or emphasize and we had to deal with it."
There was never a deficit
The Hiremath Council did not inherit a $3 million deficit in 2010 as Solomon claimed. Here’s the real story.

• First of all, it is against State law to have a deficient budget.

• The tentative, proposed budget showed a $3.1 million difference between requested spending and forecasted revenues. That’s not a deficit. A deficit only occurs when actual spending exceeds actual revenues. That never happened. This is the $3 million to which Councilmember Solomon refers. This was the Hiremath council’s budget. They did not inherit it from any previous council.

• The Council was told by the Town Manager (Jerene Watson at that time) that they needed to increase revenues or the staff was going to suffer layoffs and/or 4 day work-weeks.

• The Hiremath Council, including Steve Solomon, decided to raise those revenues by doubling your Utility Tax from 2% to 4%. Solomon doesn’t tell you that part.

Here’s another 2020 campaign lie
During the Sun City Candidate Forum held on June 30th, Steve Solomon said this during his closing statement.
“Dr. Greene, Bill Rodman’s, and my campaigns are all positive. We have not gone on the attack against our opponents. That’s something you may want to take into consideration in your evaluation.”
After implying that you shouldn’t vote for people who engage in attack ads, just 10 days later, Solomon and Rodman posted an attack ad on their Facebook pages where they attack “The Other Guys.” We assume that this same postcard will soon be arriving in your mailbox. But the biggest problem is, that once again, the accusations made against Bill Garner and Tim Bohen are all lies.

If time permits, LOVE will dissect those lies for you in an upcoming article.

The ESLO lie
In Solomon’s continuing campaign of self-promotion, during that same forum, Solomon took sole credit for creating the Environmentally Sensitive Lands Ordinance. He said,
“I’ve also put in place our environmentally sensitive land ordinance.”
He put it in place? Well, that will come as quite a surprise to all the other people who worked on that committee. Back in 2010, Solomon was just one member of the 7-member Public Advisory Committee assigned to work on ESLO. There was also a 10-member Technical Advisory Committee including people from Arizona Game & Fish, Arizona Geological Survey, and the Coalition for Sonoran Desert Protection to name a few.

But to hear Solomon tell it, he alone devised the plan and implemented the policy!

Campaign promises don’t matter
During the June 30, 2020 Sun City debate, when asked if there were any situations in which he would increase taxes, Solomon replied, “Read my lips. No new taxes.” But keep in mind what he said during the January 23, 2019 town council meeting:
"There is a major difference between campaigning and governing. It is really irrelevant what your campaign promises were.”
The inference is that Solomon believes that one can say whatever they wish in order to get elected, but once elected, there is no need to follow through.

If you’ve missed any of The Solomon Chronicles, the links are provided below for your convenience.

Part 1. Favoritism
Part 2. Voting Record 2016-2018
Part 3. Who funded Solomon's 2016 Town Council campaign
Part 4. Conflict of interest
Part 5. A pattern of incivility and disrespect
Part 5. A pattern of incivility and disrespect (Cont'd.)

Wednesday, June 3, 2020

The Solomon Chronicles. Part 1. Favoritism.

With the Town Council election on the horizon, LOVE will be presenting a series of articles entitled, “The Solomon Chronicles,” highlighting the abysmal record of Councilmember Steve Solomon who is running for re-election. This weekly series will highlight his 4-year record of incivility towards Oro Valley residents and his interdependent relationship with local developers. This series was written by a LOVE contributor and contains a synopsis of previous LOVE articles plus new information.
- - -

April 5, 2017 Town Council meeting
A $17 million bond for sports fields at Naranja Park was on the agenda, however, there was no Public Hearing scheduled for this item. As you continue reading, keep in mind that Solomon was in favor of this bond.

With no Public Hearing scheduled, two residents who wanted to speak on this issue, chose to do so during the Call to Audience. Most likely, neither were aware that you are not allowed to speak during the Call to Audience regarding an item that is on the agenda.

The first person to speak (Oro Valley resident, Karen Stratman), was opposed to the $17 million bond and the secondary property tax to pay for it. She stated that if ball fields were wanted by our residents, then they should have been a priority rather than the Town purchasing 3 golf courses.

Solomon calls a Point of Order
Ms. Stratman was quickly interrupted by Councilmember Solomon who called a Point of Order, stating that she was not allowed to speak on an agenda item during the Call to Audience. Solomon addressed the Town Attorney stating that, “She specifically mentioned the bond issue that’s on the agenda.”

Although he was correct that discussing an agenda item during the Call to Audience is not allowed, it’s what happened next that revealed his true intention in stopping her speech…and it wasn’t because he’s a stickler for enforcing Parliamentary Rules.

Solomon’s True Intentions
The next person to speak (Oro Valley resident, Ben Baker) was in favor of the $17 million bond. He opened his speech by instructing the council on the best way to convince people to vote to approve the bond, including giving specific examples of how to entice residents into voting YES.

Solomon was silent. He never interrupted this speaker. He never called a Point of Order and Mr. Baker was allowed to present his entire speech unimpeded, despite speaking on the same agenda item that Solomon had just prevented Ms. Stratman from speaking on.

Why was Solomon not consistent in asking the Town Attorney to enforce the rules? One can only conclude that it was because Mr. Baker was in favor of the $17 million Naranja Park Bond (as was Councilmember Solomon) and Solomon wanted to make sure that that speaker’s voice was heard!

This is Councilmember Solomon in action. To him, Parliamentary Rules should only apply to those who disagree with him. If you agree with him, he’s just fine with suspending the rules for you. Councilmember Solomon has never understood the simple fact that he is supposed to be a councilmember for all and not just for those who agree with him.

Appointed his crony to Planning & Zoning
Solomon also voted to appoint Don Cox to the Planning & Zoning Commission despite the council receiving letters of concern from multiple residents about Cox’s repeated inappropriate and unprofessional behavior while serving past terms on P&Z. Cox had already been reprimanded twice by the Town Attorney for his inappropriate behavior and for violating the rules for Board and Commission members. (NOTE: Cox was a vocal supporter of Steve Solomon during the 2016 election and formed a PAC that endorsed Pina-Rodman-Solomon for election. Quid pro quo?)
- - -

The Solomon Chronicles: Part 2. “Voting Record” will be published next Wednesday.

Monday, May 22, 2017

Guest View: Diane Peters ~ The abject favoritism of the OV Town Council. Part 1.

Over the past few years, I’ve noticed a pattern of favoritism on the OV Town Council whereby there seems to be one set of rules for residents (and even council members) who are supportive of the mayor’s plans for the town and another set of rules for the residents and council members who are critical of his ideas.

In a recent two-part article, “The Great Bond Caper,” I addressed the difference in how the Town Council waffled on applying Call to Audience rules during the April 5th Town Council meeting; strictly applying the rules to one resident (a critic) while waiving the rules for another resident (a supporter). In that case, the rule in question was: ”any member of the public is allowed to address the Mayor and Town Council on any issue not listed on today’s agenda.”

Today’s article will address the rule that states…”Per Town Council Parliamentary Rules and Procedures, you must address the Council as a whole.”

When partiality supersedes objectivity
The mayor and council waived the above rule during an October 2016 council meeting when Steve Solomon (a friend of theirs who has since become a council member) specifically called out then-Councilmember Mike Zinkin, accusing him of spending more on travel than what his travel budget allowed. Solomon specifically called out “Mr. Zinkin” four times during his speech. No Point of Order was called at any time. (As usual, Solomon was incorrect in his assertions and this will be discussed in Part 2).

This raises the question: Are these rules a mandate or is enforcement at the whim of the mayor? I am in the process of obtaining clarification from the Town on this question. If it turns out that enforcing the rules is at the mayor’s discretion, then the next logical question would be: Why does the mayor enforce Town Council Parliamentary Rules for his critics while waiving them for his supporters?

Solomon’s Hypocrisy
Solomon’s speech that night raises another question as well. Why was Solomon so concerned about Councilmember Zinkin’s travel expenses (all approved by then-Town Manager, Greg Caton) yet he never criticized the Town Manager for approving them?

Even more telling is that after Solomon became a council member in November 2016, he said nothing when, just two months later, Mayor Hiremath and Interim Town Manager, Danny Sharp, spent over $3000 for a one-day trip to the U.S. Conference of Mayors Winter Meeting in Washington, DC just so the mayor could receive a “2017 Public Leadership in the Arts Award.”

They arrived in Washington, DC on January 18th at 7:00 PM and they left DC on January 19th at 1:00 PM. They were in DC for less than 24 hours. What benefit did Oro Valley taxpayers derive from this $3000 trip?

Mayor Hiremath’s trip expenses were as follows:

Airfare        1048.46
Hotel           528.85 (for one night)*
Meals          87.50

TOTAL     $1664.81

*NOTE: Mayor Hiremath cancelled his original hotel room (Hilton Alexandria Old Town) when he found another room (Hilton Homewood Suites) closer to the event location. The cancelled room was NON-REFUNDABLE at $209.39. The new hotel room was $319.46, bringing the Grand Total for a one-night hotel stay to $528.85.

Getting closer to the venue would make sense if the mayor was staying there for a week and needed to go to that venue every day, but he only had to go there one day and for this he stiffed the taxpayers an additional $209. The mayor should reimburse the town. After all, that’s what they would have expected Mike Zinkin to do. (This will be explained further in Part 2)

Interim Town Manager, Danny Sharp’s trip expenses were as follows:

Airfare        1048.47
Hotel           313.07 (for one night)
Meals          87.50
Taxi             45.18

TOTAL      $1494.22

Grand total to the taxpayers for Mayor Hiremath to receive an award in Washington, DC was $3,159.03.

Is it lonely at the top?
What was the necessity of having the Interim Town Manager accompany Mayor Hiremath on this trip? It served the town of Oro Valley no purpose to drag the Town Manager along on a purely ceremonial junket. If the mayor hadn’t invited Danny Sharp to accompany him and he hadn’t cancelled his original hotel room, the Grand Total would have been just $1345.35. It’s funny how Steve Solomon never complained about or questioned any of these unnecessary expenses.

Part 2 of this article will be published on Wednesday.

Monday, January 9, 2017

Editorial ~ Tears, Lies, and Videotape

Mayor Hiremath’s send-offs to departing council members was very enlightening

During the November 16, 2016 council meeting, outgoing councilmembers Bill Garner and Brendan Burns were given plaques of appreciation from the town. Mayor Hiremath’s acknowledgement of their years of service was brief, abysmal, and in stark contrast to the lengthy acknowledgements he gave to outgoing councilmembers Barry Gillaspie and Steve Solomon when they left office in 2012, which included some tearful blubbering over Solomon’s departure.

The mayor expressed no regret over the loss of Councilmembers Burns and Garner despite them both being elected by the people. The service of these true independent thinkers and champions of the citizens was barely recognized.

2016: Hiremath refuses to acknowledge accomplishments of anyone who disagrees with him

  • Councilmember Bill Garner was first elected by the people in 2008 and re-elected in 2012, serving our town for a total of 8 years (2008-2016). His 8 years of service, which included fighting to preserve the town’s transportation service for the elderly and disabled (Coyote Run) and working with citizens to prevent development of apartments on LaCholla, was given a contemptibly inadequate 10-second acknowledgement from Mayor Hiremath who merely read the inscription on the plaque. [10 second speech]
  • Councilmember Brendan Burns was elected by the people in 2012. His 4 years of service, which included efforts to bring more town services to needy and disadvantage children, was given a mere 12-second acknowledgement by Mayor Hiremath, who again simply read the inscription on the plaque. [12 second speech]
2012: The mayor’s unbridled favoritism is evident
  • Councilmember Barry Gillaspie was elected by the people in 2004 and re-elected in 2008, serving our town for a total of 8 years (2004-2012).
Hiremath acknowledged Gillaspie’s 8 years of service with a 150 word, one-minute speech, a portion of which included these sentiments: “Barry’s involvement being on the council, his involvement with Planning and Zoning, his sheer will to preserve the look of Oro Valley for the last 8 years really is unmatched. Oro Valley is Oro Valley because of the efforts of Barry Gillaspie…Oro Valley owes you a great deal of debt.” [1 minute and 10 second speech]
  • Councilmember Steve Solomon was appointed to council in 2010 and lost his bid for election in 2012. He served only two years and was never elected (let alone re-elected) by the people.
Hiremath acknowledged Solomon’s 2 years of service with a 274 word, 3-minute speech! Just a few seconds after applauding Barry Gillaspie for his unmatched sheer will to preserve our desert views, Hiremath falsely claimed that it was Solomon’s “single efforts” that resulted in the environmentally sensitive land ordinance! He also gave him sole credit for the town’s current transportation system for the elderly and the disabled, ignoring the involvement of the citizens group, “Friends of Coyote Run” who had already laid all the groundwork.
Hiremath’s tribute to Solomon included, “I envy you because in 2 short years, you have taken what Councilmember Gillaspie has done, and prior councils, and solidified by code, by ordinance, the environmentally sensitive land ordinance…and…I envy you because you along with Vice Mayor Waters really were tasked to serve and provide for the residents that can’t provide for themselves…So again, through your single efforts in the last two years, you have retained the character of what Oro Valley is going to be in the future as well as provided a transportation system for needy residents…and really made Oro Valley very, very unique.” [2 minute and 44 second speech]
The person who served the least amount of time and who was appointed rather than elected, is the person who received the longest and most heartfelt acknowledgement and thank you from Mayor Hiremath (including some tearful blubbering which you can witness for yourself on the video included with this posting).

A little perspective

It was disingenuous for the mayor to credit Steve Solomon with providing a transportation system for needy residents. Solomon voted to eliminate Coyote Run in 2011, the town’s original transportation service for the elderly and disabled. It was only after a huge outcry by those very citizens (over 100 of them packed the council chambers to express their outrage) that the mayor was forced to form a sub-committee to identify alternatives. The “solution” was to turn it over to the Regional Transportation System (RTA) of which Mayor Hiremath just happened to be Vice-Chairman of the board of directors.

Additionally, the citizens group, “Friends of Coyote Run” worked diligently with the RTA for more than 6 months to retain the services of Coyote Run. Steve Solomon’s “single efforts” is nothing more than a smokescreen and a pipe dream!
---
NOTE: Councilmember Mike Zinkin was out of the country on November 16th. The Town mailed his plaque to his home.

Wednesday, May 24, 2017

Guest View: Diane Peters ~ The abject favoritism of the OV Town Council. Part 2.

Following up on Part 1 of this article, below are some of the false accusations that current Councilmember Steve Solomon made against then-Councilmember Mike Zinkin during a Town Council “Call to Audience” in October 2016.

Solomon’s claim:
Solomon asserted that Zinkin’s annual Travel and Training budget was $3000 and that he had gone over that budget by spending $9000 the previous year. He also claimed that Zinkin spent over $27,000 on travel during his four years on council, with this being more than twice his four-year combined budget of $12,000.

Fact:
Although each Council Member had a $3000 annual Travel and Training allotment, Mike Zinkin was a Leadership Fellow with the National League of Cities and Towns (NLC). There was a line-item for NLC travel in the amount of $11,500. Zinkin never came anywhere near exceeding that annual budget.

Solomon’s claim:
Solomon stated that Zinkin never requested nor obtained approval from the Town Council to exceed his travel budget and claimed that he was therefore in violation of Town policy. He called this “an unauthorized use of taxpayer funds” and asserted that Zinkin should have to repay this money back to the Town and the taxpayers.

Fact:
Since Zinkin hadn’t exceeded his travel budget, he was not required to obtain Town Council approval for additional travel. All travel expenses that he submitted were within the scope of his Travel and Training budget and were approved by the Town Manager.

This was just another one of Steve Solomon’s feeble attempts at maligning the character of anyone who doesn’t fall in lock step with his point of view.

Hypocrisy much?
Steve Solomon expected Zinkin to reimburse the town for travel and training expenses that he falsely deemed to be unauthorized and then said nothing when Mayor Hiremath’s one-day ceremonial junket to Washington, DC cost the taxpayers $3,159.00 (detailed in Part 1 of this article).

Councilmember Joe Hornat also chimed in to complain about Zinkin’s travel expenses, stating in an e-mail to Zinkin last year…

“I always thought that your out-of-state trips were little more than a boondoggle for your benefit” and that attending a conference with the NLC was “personally beneficial” to Zinkin, offered “no benefit to the Town,” was a “blatant misuse of public funds” and that Zinkin should “pay for any expenses associated with this.”

…and who then said nothing about Mayor Hiremath’s out-of-state boondoggle which was for his own benefit and involved the misuse of public funds (detailed in Part 1 of this article).

Which of the below trips constitutes a “benefit to the Town?”

Day-tripper
Mayor Hiremath and Interim Town Manager travel to Washington, DC for less than 24-hours at a cost of over $3000 so the mayor can receive a “2017 Public Leadership in the Arts Award.”

How did this trip (or the Interim Town Manager accompanying the mayor on this trip) benefit the town or the taxpayer?

Building better communities
In 2016, Councilmember Mike Zinkin participated in two trips with the National League of Cities. The details and expenses are outlined below:

National League of Cities 2016 Congressional City Conference
Washington, DC -- March 5-9, 2016

Registration                              $465.00
Airfare                                      $421.20
Lodging                                    $1848.06
Meals and Incidentals              $431.50
Personal vehicle expenses        $86.44
TOTAL EXPENSES                $3252.20

National League of Cities 2016 University Leadership Summit
Madison, WI -- Sept. 28 – Oct. 1, 2016

Registration                              $495.00
Airfare                                      $419.20
Lodging                                    $614.18
Meals and Incidentals              $196.50
TOTAL EXPENSES                $1725.58

How did these two trips benefit the Town or the taxpayer? The answer is below.

From the NLC Leadership Summit Conference Brochure

Purpose:
Solving today’s complex societal and community problems, from infrastructure to public safety, requires a collaborative, multi-sector effort. [Multiple government entities] must all work together to generate and implement creative and effective solutions. Doing so requires a special type of leader, one who understands the motivations and unique contributions of the various actors and can align common agendas, incentives, and outcomes.

Participants in the 2016 Leadership Summit will learn how to become that type of leader…Attendees will gain valuable perspective on the different sectors and will work in collaboration to address some of today’s complex problems.

Our Leadership Summit is designed for city officials…who want to solve real problems and build better communities.

Objectives:
Understand the differing roles and agendas of the private sector…the non-profit community, city and state government.

Examine successful municipal multi-sector initiatives.

Apply lessons learned to a current or future initiative.

Engage with and learn from peers and leaders from different sectors.

Outcomes:
Better working relationships with multi-sector partners.

More efficiency and economic savings on multi-sector projects and initiatives.

Better ability to establish criteria and identify approaches for successful collaborations up front (proactive rather than reactive).

Promote innovation and provide proven strategies and valuable resources that address the challenges that cities face.

Expand the capacity of city officials to serve as ethical, effective, and engaged leaders.

Don’t mess with the kingdom (a.k.a. The Empire Strikes Back)
Whereas Mike Zinkin’s trips involved community problem-solving (broadening the mind), the mayor’s cross-country trip (of which no one complained) involved receiving an award and hanging out with his buddy. Yet, the former receives complaints and the latter does not.

Why the favoritism? Because during the four years that Mike Zinkin was on council (2012-2016) he was a workhorse who spent considerable time attempting to trim the town budget by cutting waste. For his efforts, he was repeatedly maligned by the Majority-4 council members and certain town staff employees, all of whom didn’t like anyone delving too closely into town operations and expenses and trying to change the status quo.

Diane Peters has lived in Oro Valley since 2003, moving here to escape the humidity of the East Coast. She’s been involved in OV politics and development issues since 2006. In 2014, she organized a citizens group, Citizen Advocates of the Oro Valley General Plan, who over a 9-month period, successfully negotiated a controversial 200-acre development project slated for the LaCholla-Naranja-Lambert-Shannon area. In her past life, she worked in medical research at various University Hospitals in New England. Her interests include reading, writing, nature photography, travel, art galleries, museums, and politics.

Wednesday, April 12, 2017

Guest View: Diane Peters: ~ The Great “Bond” Caper (Part 1)

Town Council disregards the rules and gives preferential treatment to their friend and supporter during the April 5th Call to Audience.

Last week’s Watchdog Report (Look out! Council to discuss Property Tax at April 5th Town Council Meeting) informed readers that a General Obligation Bond of $17 million for additional sports fields at Naranja Park was on the April 5th town council agenda. This bond would be paid back with a secondary property tax totaling $28 million over 20 years.

Point of Order? This whole court is out-of-order.
With no Public Hearing on this issue, two Oro Valley residents decided to speak on the issue during the first Call to Audience. However, rules for the the Call to Audience state that, “any member of the public is allowed to address the Mayor and Town Council on any issue not listed on today’s agenda.” Perhaps neither citizen was aware of this rule, but it’s what happened next that was quite revealing.

The first resident, (who was OPPOSED to the bond and secondary property tax) was interrupted by Councilmember Steve Solomon, who called a Point of Order to question why she was being allowed to speak on an agenda item. After some discussion, the town attorney ruled that this resident could not discuss this matter at the Call to Audience. This resulted in the resident altering the content of her speech.

The second resident (advocating FOR the bond and associated secondary property tax and who just happens to be a friend of Councilmember Rhonda Pina) was allowed to speak without interruption. Solomon was silent. The town attorney was silent. The Mayor and all other council members remained silent.

Stratman vs. Baker: The Transcript
First Speaker: Karen Stratman:
“I would like to address the town budget. In my opinion, I feel that our town budget is a little bit out of control. Adding more money to the town budget at this time from other revenue sources, I don’t believe will solve the problems we’re having. I think a plug needs to be put into the golf course and restaurant that is draining our funds. Please get the golf out of the budget. I think there’s other people who may be interested in running the golf course so there are solutions out there. We are not golf people obviously as we do not run it very well.

If there is a poll that indicates that more ball fields are wanted, not golf, that should have been a priority and not the golf course, which we all know was not a top priority in any poll ever taken in OV that I know of. I’m sorry that the town has no money for ball fields at this time. Every dollar seems to be going to the golf courses. This is just an idea, but maybe some of the golf course could be used for batting cages, practice pitch, maybe catch. We have plenty of the space for it already there.

I strongly feel that adding a bond or other revenue sources is not a solution at this time. How do I know that any new bonds or taxes will be…” [she was interrupted by Solomon.]

Solomon: Excuse me, Mr. Mayor. Point of order. I want to ask the town attorney, is she allowed, I thought that at the Call to Audience you weren’t allowed to speak on any item on the agenda. (Solomon is correct.)

Attorney Gary Verburg: For the Call to the Public, they can pretty much talk about anything but they’re limited in time and you can’t respond or take any action on it. You can direct staff to study the matter if that’s what you choose to do. (The attorney was wrong in stating that speakers can “talk about anything” but later realizes his mistake.)

Stratman: “I’m just against adding any revenues or bond money to our budget at this time when we can barely keep track of what’s going to the golf courses. How do we know that any of that revenue won’t go to the golf courses? I’ve heard a rumor that there could be a secondary property tax or some bonds…” [she was interrupted by the town attorney]

Attorney: Excuse me. Now I understand the question better. Yes, the bond issue is going to be on an agenda item that’s coming up.

Solomon: She specifically mentioned the bond issue that’s on the agenda.

Attorney: That’s not supposed to be addressed during the Call to Audience…It’s Item #2 related to the ball park. It’s part and parcel of that discussion.

Stratman: “Well, let me just say this. Correct me if it’s not in the ball park, but I believe perhaps 99 out of 100 residents do not golf here in OV. That would leave about 450 that maybe do. So less than 1% of OV is invested in this golf course. I just say please don’t burden the citizens yet again with more revenues coming out of our pockets. Instead, balance the budget please.”

Second Speaker: Ben Baker:
“I was the OV representative to the 1997 bond issue along with Ms. Pina’s husband, Raul. (He pointed towards Councilmember Rhonda Pina as he said this).

If you’re looking at a bond issue, how are you going to go about getting it passed? I was told, you’ll never get Sun City to go along with these bonds. They’ve already educated their kids, they don’t want playgrounds...

So what did we do?...We told them what it would do for them…what’s it going to do for their home value? It’s going to kick it up. For every 25 cents you spend over the next 10 years on a bond might bring you back $4.00 at the end of that period in your home’s value. I can’t be specific with numbers, it’s purely conceptual, but we sold that bond…we were on every TV station, every talk show, everybody that would have us, we talked that bond up…We got it passed and as a result of that we have Riverfront Park….

So tell them what it’s going to do for them in the future, not that somebody else’s kids want to play softball, but it’s the whole big part of the community that’s going to raise their property values.”

Shameless Favoritism
Notice that Baker began talking about bond issues right out of the gate and no one stopped him. They didn’t even stop him when he began giving them instructions on how to get the Naranja Park bond passed! Why was there no consistency in enforcing the rules? Was it because he spoke IN FAVOR of it and he’s also a friend of Councilmember Rhonda Pina?

I’m not the only person who noticed the preferential treatment afforded to Mr. Baker. Radio talk show host, Chris DeSimone of Wake Up Tucson, took advantage of the second Call to Audience of the evening to admonish the council and town attorney for their blatant favoritism.
---
We will publish Part 2. (including the transcript of DeSimone’s speech) tomorrow

Monday, January 28, 2019

Town Council: New and Old Go "Toe To Toe"

11 new faces on 5 Oro Valley commissions
The Oro Valley Town Council appointed 11 new members to five of its boards and commissions at last week's town council meeting. This represents a sea change by bringing fresh insight and energy from Oro Valley's citizen involved community to town affairs.

Favoritism no more
This contrasts sharply with the Hiremath years. During those years, the town eliminated the Art Review Board, The Conceptual Design Review Board, and the Bond and Finance Commission. These totaled "...19 citizens that were removed from being involved in our community," according to Mayor Winfield, in his remarks during last week's council meeting.  In addition, that council eliminated term limits on boards and commissions, assuring virtual life-long appointments for those who were favored by them.

December council decision reinstated commission term limits
Mayor Winfield observed that the decision to return to board and commission term limits at the December 5 council meeting was a return to a policy that had been successful prior to the Hiremath council changing it.

"The intent of restoring term limits was to open the door to citizen involvement." In just one month, the policy change has increased citizen interest in serving on boards and commissions: 42 applications for 13 positions.  This is a marked increase over recent past years when people were discourage from applying to a board or commission because they knew that close allegiance to the Majority-4 was a requirement and because many of those serving were reappointed.

One year too many
At the meeting, Vice Mayor Barrett, in the spirit of increasing community involvement in town affairs, recommended a new member for Planning and Zoning Commission, rather than reappointing Commissioner Hitt to a sixth year of service. She felt that this is far too long given an objective of increasing community involvement in town affairs.

Rodman: We met the goal of increasing involvement 
Council Member Rodman, the liaison to the commission, responded. He and town planner Bayer Vella had selected Hitt for reappointment on the basis that he is experienced.  Rodman felt that the three new appointees to the commission reflected the demographics of the community and added diversity to the commission. "We recommended two women to be on the commission, who are also family demographic." He also felt that Hitt's reappointed reflected the "...younger family demographic."

Rodman asserted that, Hitt, a former Pima County Planner, brings experience to the board that is lacking in the three new appointed members. In addition, he pointed out that the two remaining members, both of whom are experienced, will be "turned out at the end of the year."

Rodman: Term limits should not work against experience 
Rather than focusing on this specific appointment, Rodman then revisited the December 5 decision on term limits.

"To me, I'm disappointed" that people can not serve beyond their current term, even though they are qualified. "That does not make sense for the future of the town. Our job was to select the most qualified candidates. Our job was not to worry about politics and political promises."

Rodman and Pina supported reappointment
Council Member Solomon, speaking in what appeared to be a prepared remark, proffered his support of reappointing Hitt. Tomorrow we will report Solomon's comments since they became noteworthy because of their accusatory nature.

"It's really hard for me to understand how we can bring on three new people and not allow one experienced person stay on board to help them get up to speed," Council Member Pina noted. Pena was not correct in this statement because there are two members continuing on the Planning and Zoning Commission. Thus, they can help the new members.

Winfield: 18 new faces "I have great confidence in."
Mayor Winfield observed that tonight's appointment of 11 new commission members, the future appointment of five people to the budget and finance commission, plus the future appointment of two vacant seats on the Historical Preservation Commission will bring total number of new citizen involvement to 18 people! "These are people that I have great confidence in."

The council approved the proposed board and commission members on a 4-3 vote. Pina, Rodman and Solomon stated that they approved of all the appointments. However, they voted no to express displeasure that Hitt was not reappointed.

You can watch the council discussion via this link.