Showing posts sorted by relevance for query Romspen. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query Romspen. Sort by date Show all posts

Monday, December 7, 2020

Vistoso Residents Want Solomon and The Group Preserve Vistoso Barred From Town's Vistoso Land Negotiations

Residents want Solomon to recuse himself...
Residents of Rancho Vistoso have asked the Oro Valley Town Council to remove Council Member Steve Solomon from any discussions regarding the town's potential purchase of the former Vistoso Golf land from owner Romspen LLC. As LOVE reported in November, the council has authorized the town manager and town council to negotiate with Romspen to purchase the property. 

...because Solomon has been involved in previous discussions with Romspen, the landowner, that would have resulted in development of some of the property
Rancho Vistoso residents are seeking Solomon's recusal from discussions because Solomon, starting in March, inserted himself into activities with the group Preserve Vistoso , activities that could have resulted in residential development of some of the property. These residents, like many in Rancho Vistoso, want no development of the property. Rather, they want the property to become a natural preserve.

Council Member Solomon's activities with Romspen and the group Preserve Vistoso continued at least until the council meeting of November 18. At that meeting, Solomon put forth a motion that would have the town join with a small "working group" he had formed with Romspen's representative to, as he put it, "quickly resolve" the purchase. The working group was to also include Preserve Vistoso and the Vistoso Community Association ("VCA") to, supposedly, represent the residents. 

Residents vehemently rejected Solomon's proposal at the November council meeting. Now, they are fearful that any Solomon involvement could result in a "deal" that would see some of the property developed; in particular, a six acre plot on the far east side of the golf course. This would disadvantage residents living in that area.

Residents: The group Preserve Vistoso and the Vistoso Community Association should not be involved
These residents assert that only the town can represent the interests of all residents. The group Preserve Vistoso represents only some members of the community. In addition, only a small part of the land is under the auspices of the Vistoso Community Association  ("VCA"),  the governing master homeowners association. 187 of the 208 acres of the former golf course are under town control. Thus, it is up to the town to take the lead role in resolving this land's use. And the town has acted to do just that.

The residents believe that the group Preserve Vistoso has not been operating for the benefit of all. They point to a questionnaire that the group sent out that asked respondents whether it was agreeable that a six acre plot mentioned previously be developed (Panel Right). 

The group Preserve Vistoso asked this question in mid July during the time when they were soliciting donations for The Conservation Fund (TCF).  This was at a time when The Conservation Fund ("TCF") was negotiating a land purchase at Fair Market Value with Romspen. TCF will only purchase the land if the land will have no development. They will place the land in a Conservation Trust, protecting the land in perpetuity. 

Residents: The actions of Council Member Solomon and the group Preserve Vistoso may have interfered with the negotiations between TCF and Romspen
We have been told by residents that Council Member Solomon has been in contact from time to time with Peter Oelbaum, managing director of Romspen. Solomon is a sitting Oro Valley Town Council member.  Romspen sought an active general plan amendment that would result in significant property development. This is an amendment that Solomon would be opining upon. Perhaps his involvement held out some hope to Romspen that development was possible.

Then, in July, the group Preserve Vistoso sent out the questionnaire on development of the six acre parcel.  Perhaps, this reinforced Romspen's impression that the community might be amenable to development of some of the property. 

Taken in this light, it makes sense that Romspen rejected the TCF offer. TCF can only offer fair market value for conservation land. Land that can be used for residential development would be far more valuable. Thus, it would be wise for Romspen to reject the offer and see if a better deal would be forthcoming.

Solomon has denied personal benefit from his involvement
Council Member Solomon, in the November council meeting, stated that he had no personal interest in the transaction. He stated that he has been acting on behalf of his constituents.

The group Preserve Vistoso asserts that it has always operated to ensure that the Vistoso property remains open space
Please read our November 24th posting regarding Preserve Vistoso's explanation of their activities. In it, they provide an explanation of their activities which, they assert, are to create a permanent conservation easement on the property.
---
Tomorrow and Wednesday we will post two email communications sent to council by residents. These emails substantiate and provide further detail regarding the assertions in this article.

Thursday, April 23, 2020

Our "Two Cents": Vistoso Golf Course is Romspen's Sugarplum

Update: Romspen asserted the following in a video posted by the town on April 28: They are a mortgage company. They are not land speculators. They acquired the property in a foreclosure of debt in 2012. That foreclosure included 8 other golf courses, all of which continue to operate. The Vistoso Golf Course sustained substantial losses and was closed in 2016. The also assert that this general plan amendment will not "make them whole" on this investment.
---
Today is the last day for residents to opine online on a proposed general plan amendment that would convert the Vistoso Golf Course to high density residential use.

We thought we’d get our “two cents” in.

Oro Valley did not create Rancho Vistoso 
To a great extent, Rancho Vistoso created Oro Valley, because it made the town much bigger, extending its northern boundaries from Tangerine to the mountains.

Rancho Vistoso existed before Oro Valley. It was then and is now a master planned community. It has its own codes. It has its own vision. It has many homeowner associations that watch over it.

Oro Valley was lucky to induce Rancho Vistoso to join the community. And Rancho Vistoso joined because of improved police presence. They did not join because of Oro Valley’s zoning codes and procedures.

What happens in Rancho Vistoso should be a Rancho Vistoso decision unless...
Given the history, it is clear that the decision on whether the Vistoso Golf property should become homes and a senior care facility should entirely be the decision of the residents of Rancho Vistoso. The rest of us don’t live there. We don’t share their wonderful view of the Catalinas. We don’t travel their roads.

But, indeed, we might share their vision.

Their vision is for the Vistoso Golf Course property to be an open space for the entire community to enjoy. It would be the only town run park in Rancho Vistoso. One that all of us could enjoy.

That vision, of course, is contrary to what course owner, Romspen, wants.

Vistoso Golf Course is Romspen's "Sugarplum"
What Romspen wants, their vision, is for the town to grant a general plan amendment that will certainly make Romspen,, the owner, rich. And that is what they are counting on.

They’ve counted on the town making them rich starting the day they bought the property.

“In 2015, Romspen Cub Holdings acquired a golf course in Tucson Arizona. Romspen Club Holdings is operating and preparing the property for future sale and the potential creation of development tracts of land within the property…” (Source: Page 39 of the 12/31/15 annual report to shareholders.) Romspen never planned to operate a golf course when they purchased the property in 2015. Indeed, they planned to either sell the land or develop it. Selling or developing it requires that the zoning and general plan land use be changed.

They are counting on the The Town of Oro Valley to make their dream come true. Buy the property at a price that is less valuable than the value of the land once it is rezoned for an entirely different use.

Sound familiar? It’s what land speculators do. It's been happening in Oro Valley forever.

Romspen expects you to make them rich. And they do it by asking you to rezone the property so that they can sell it to someone who will split it into little lots and build lots of residences.

Miles to go before we rest
While this amendment is being considered, the town is creating a parks and recreation master plan, one that may well designate the Vistoso Golf land as a preserve or a park, designations that fit current zoning.  This would require the town to acquire the property in some fashion. Perhaps get grants. Perhaps find a wealthy individual who wants to leave a legacy for our community.  Perhaps convincing Romspen to settle for a decent tax write-off.

Yep. Lots to consider when it comes to the Vistoso Golf Course.

Thursday, October 8, 2020

Romspen Pulls General Plan Amendment Request On Vistoso Golf Course

No GPA This Year
Romspen LLC, the owner of the closed Vistoso Golf Course, has removed its request for a general plan amendment. According to a press release from the group Preserve Vistoso, Romspen said it anticipates re-application next year (2021). 

It's about money
Last week, LOVE reported that Romspen had refused a fair market value offer from the The Conservation Fund. The purchase would have resulted in the land becoming a nature preserve.  It would be part of The Town of Oro Valley's parks system.

Preserve Vistoso Responds
The group Preserve Vistoso issued the following in a press release Tuesday. 

"Preserve Vistoso Board and members are extremely disappointed that Romspen failed to accept a cash, fair market value offer from The Conservation Fund (TCF) for the purchase of the former Vistoso Golf Course. Romspen failed to understand the commitment this community has to save the property as a Nature Preserve and Community Trail. We made our voices heard with the Town of Oro Valley in 2020 and we will do the same in 2021. Preserve Vistoso intends to continue our outreach and grow our membership. We will be even stronger when Romspen applies again for a General Plan Amendment in 2021."

"The game is afoot"
Real estate deals are tricky deals. They can take years to happen, according to Mike Ford, of The Conservation Fund (Source:  Jim Horn's Oro Valley Podcast). Romspen LLC, a lender of last resort, has every reason, at the moment, to wait this out. Their goal is to maximize their profit investment. They have no vested interest in the well being of Oro Valley.  They have seen how anxious our community is to have this property. 

We suspect that the will wait until either one of the following happens: 
  • The politics of council change via elections in 2022 such that general plan amendments are likely approved
  • Romspen experiences a liquidity crunch and needs to sell the property
  • Romspen decides that it can better employ the funds in a more lucrative investment
  • A legal action compels them to sell the land at fair market value
  • Somebody blinks and they get a much greater offer
We shall see.
---

Monday, October 19, 2020

Vistoso Purchase: The Game Continues

Dickering over property value goes public
The dickering over value between Romspen LLc, the owner of the Vistoso Golf Course, and The Conservation fund went public last week. Romspen attorney Pat Lopez stated in a published article that his client had "...pointed out several erroneous calculations made on the appraisal" of the property, errors that were not addressed. 

Earlier this month, Romspen rejected the offer from The Conservation Fund for the purchase of the property. Eventually, if purchased, the land would become a preserve maintained by Oro Valley. 

Romspen wants to be paid for what the land could be worth if it were rezoned
The "erroneous calculation" is the Romspen belief that the property should be appraised based on the land's value if it was rezoned as Romspen has requested. In other words, Romspen wants to be paid for what might happen as opposed to what actually is happening. That rezoning, if approved by Council, would not happen until next year at the earliest. Council approval is by no means assured. 

The Conservation Fund wants to pay the appraised value
Valuing the land on this basis "...would be contrary to UASFLA guidelines if the appraisers ventured further (without support) in speculating the property would have a 30%, or 50%, probability in obtaining a change in zoning use," according to Mike Ford, Southwest Director of the Conservation Fund. 

In other words, The Conservation Fund will not pay what something might worth in the future. They will pay what it is worth as it is currently zoned.

Posturing will continue
It is a "no brainer" that Romspen rejected the offer. They are a "lender of last resort." They obtain financially distressed properties through bankruptcy and then, through rezoning, add value to the land because it is now zoned for a different use. That is how they earn a profit. That is what they are trying to do here. 

As we have already noted in our prior posting: "The Game Is Afoot."

Romspen has options. The Conservation Fund has options. The group "Preserve Vistoso" has options. The Town of Oro Valley has options.

We will report as events play out.
---

Saturday, October 3, 2020

Rompsen Rejects TCF Offer

Rejection after agreement in principal to negotiate in good faith
Romspen Vistoso LLC, the Canadian based owner of Vistoso Golf Course, has rejected a "fair market value offer" for the purchase of the property by The Conservation Fund. The goal was for TCF to purchase the land so that is could be added to the town's open space system. TCF plans to maintain open lines of communication with Romspen.

Preserve Vistoso to shocked by decision... 
The group Preserve Vistoso has been working tireless for the past several years to bring establish this property as a preserve for all to use. Their comments follow: "Preserve Vistoso members are shocked that Romspen Investments, a $3 billion Toronto investment company, rejected an offer from the Conservation Fund (TCF) to purchase the former 208-acre Vistoso golf course property at fair market value. Preserve Vistoso members invited TCF to negotiate with Romspen to purchase the property so that it would be added to the Town of Oro Valley’s public open space for all to enjoy in perpetuity. TCF and Romspen agreed on the selection of a company to do the property appraisal to determine fair market value. On September 30, Romspen rejected TCF’s offer to purchase the property at the fair market value.

...Seeks communities continued support at October 13 General Plan Amendment Meeting
Our next step is to continue to urge our 1,350 Preserve Vistoso members to voice our opposition to Romspen development plans in our Oro Valley neighborhood. We are urging our members to participate in the October 13 Planning and Zoning zoom hearing on Romspen’s proposal to continue its community hearings. Romspen’s development plans include several hundred new homes in locations throughout the property as well high density development in some areas."
---

Wednesday, January 29, 2020

First "What The People Want" Deep Dive Brings Vistoso Golf To Forefront

Special interest marks first meeting
The Town of Oro Valley launched its first dive into learning what people want when it comes to Parks and Recreation. The deep dive occurred last Thursday at an open meeting session in town hall.  It was a first step in building the 2020 Parks and Recreation Master Plan. There were about a hundred people attending. We will report more about this meeting in a subsequent posting.

One of the things that we were looking for were the special interest groups at the meeting. This time it was the "Perserve Vistoso" people. They represent the residents of the Golf Course at Vistoso.

Golf Club at Vistoso residents want open space
The Golf Club at Vistoso closed in 2018. It closed because Oro Valley is overcapacity in golf facilities. Since that time, the land has been sitting, waiting for something to happen. It was a course built by Conley Wolfswinkel, the developer of  much of the Rancho Vistoso master planned community." It was owned by his sons. The Golf Club at Vistoso opened in 1995 and was designed by [golf pro] Tom Weiskopf." (source) The course simply could not remain competitive in what is a very competitive market.

Preserve Vistoso's concern is possible rezoning that may take place in the defunct Vistoso golf course; rezoning that would allow for development.
They are not advocating that the town should purchase the land or possibly operate a golf course.

One speaker at the meeting made their intent clear:

"I hope this study will underscore that Rancho Vistoso needs a large recreational area where we can enjoy the outdoors without having to dodge traffic. The former Vistoso Golf course could become an asset for our outdoor loving community. It has beautiful mountain views." (Source: Preserve Vistoso email)

Romspen wants to make money
The thing that stands in their way is that the property is now owned by an investment fund,
Romspen Mortgage Investment Fund ("Romspen"). Romspen purchased the property in 2014.  As of the summer of 2018, when the course closed, they had invested $9.5 million in it. (source)

Romspen needs to salvage a bad investment. They can do this by converting the land use from golf to residential. According to the Preserve Vistoso web site, Romspen is "... pursuing rezoning a substantial portion of the property for residential development.... to rezone 109 acres of the 208 acre property from recreational to a combination of low, medium, and medium-high density residences."

This step alone has the potential to put millions in profit in Romspen's pocket.

Romspen will have to "run the gantlet" to make land use change happen
There is more than "land rezoning" required. This will require a General Plan Amendment. That will required a 5 person council majority to approve the amendment. Then, it will required a 4 person council rezoning approval. Prior to all this, there will have to be a number of public meetings.

It's a long road and probably for Romspen, a road that will not be approved by this council. But, there will be future councils. Getting the plan designated as preserve land in the 2020 Parks and Recreation Master Plan will be an added barrier for future councils to overlook.

Tuesday, November 24, 2020

Preserve Vistoso Thanks Council For Attempting Land Purchase

Yesterday, LOVE reported that the The Town of Oro Valley was going to negotiate to purchase the former Vistoso Golf land from Romspen, the owner, with the intent of converting the the land to a permanent town amenity.

The following is statement from the group, Preserve Vistoso. They have been working tirelessly to bring this amenity to our community. We have titled key areas for reading convenience.
---
Preserve Vistoso thanks town council for their unanimous action
"Preserve Vistoso is pleased that the Oro Valley Mayor and Town Council listened to our 1,300 members. Although open Town Council meetings have been prohibited due to Covid-19 restrictions, Preserve Vistoso members communicated to Town Council via emails, letters and open Zoom meetings that we want to retain the recreational zoning and save the Vistoso property as a nature preserve and community trail.

At last week’s Town Council meeting Mayor Winfield proposed that the Town initiate communications with Romspen to negotiate the sale of the former Vistoso Golf Course to keep it zoned as open space. The Council voted unanimously to support this motion. We thank the Town Council for approving this action and we look forward to hearing updates on their progress as they engage with Romspen.

Setting the recored straight: "No side deals ever"
During that meeting a few residents made disparaging and inaccurate comments about Preserve Vistoso. We know that volunteer community boards can face criticism, but it is unfortunate that the Preserve Vistoso board was accused of somehow engaging in backroom efforts to pursue a separate deal. Those comments aren’t true and should not detract from the dedicated efforts of our members and our board to let the Town Council know that we want to protect this beautiful desert property.

Here are some facts
  • Preserve Vistoso is a 501c3. We publicly supported The Conservation Fund (TCF) and its efforts to buy the property. Our members pledged more than $1.5 million to help TCF purchase the property. This included more than $200,000 in pledges from our board. We also fully supported TCF offering Fair Market Value for the property.
  • Preserve Vistoso has never pursued or proposed any side deals with Romspen. We are not working on any other offer. Prior to our partnership with TCF, we distributed Romspen’s development plans to secure input from a few members of our community. Based on community comments, the Preserve Vistoso board agreed to oppose Romspen's proposed development plans. Suggesting that reviewing Romspen's plan meant that we were going to propose a side deal with Romspen is totally inaccurate. 
  • As a community driven organization, we send out regular updates to our members and have an email address available for members to ask questions. We have a website that identifies our board members. We participate at Vistoso Community Association (VCA) board meetings, which is open to all Rancho Vistoso members and we provide information for the VCA monthly newsletter. The public is invited to learn more about us at preservevistoso.org. 
Our commitment is to ensure that the Vistoso property remains open space and is protected by a permanent conservation easement.

Preserve Vistoso "
---

Monday, May 4, 2020

Romspen: "Amendment Will Give Residents Certainty"

The Town of Oro Valley posted a 48 minute video. The video responds to resident questions on the proposed Vistoso Golf General Plan Amendment. The town synthesized the more than 1,000 comments into eleven topics (see panel below).
There's plenty of "meat" to report on this. So, we've segmented our reporting into three posts. This first two posts focus on the answers from Romspen. the landowner. The third focuses on the town's parks and  recreation plan in relation to the Vistoso Golf property.

Please note that all three posting present what the individual said. They are presented without LOVE comment.
---

Plan approval puts uncertainty to rest
To many, the most difficult part of the Vistoso Golf situation is the uncertainty it presents. What happens to the land is in "limbo." The Rompsen proposed amendment brings certainty. There will be residential property in six areas, on 87 of the 202 acres. The remaining 115 acres will be a continuous greenbelt pathway system, donated to a yet to be identified entity.  This system runs around the perimeter of the property.

The only uncertainty left then is what entity will be responsible for maintaining the pathway system.  It could be The Town of Oro Valley, a homeowner association, a conservation trust or other not for profit group. It will not be Romspen.

Eleven Topics
Alternative: Land returns to the desert
Romspen also made it clear what will happen to the land if the amendment is rejected. The alternative, they said, is for the land to lay fallow and to gradually return to desert condition. They will only maintain it to prevent fire hazard. Romspen also made it clear that the land is private property and that those using it now are trespassing. Perhaps they will find a way to enforce this. In addition, though they did not mention this, they will be free to try bring this general plan amendment to future councils.

Won't even make them "whole"
Financially, Romspen claims that the amendment and subsequent land development will not make the company "whole" on this investment. This in contrast to our analysis. They did not provide any substance to back up their comment.  Romspen acquired the course as part of a foreclosure on eight courses. This would indicate that they secured ownership at a value which is the debt owed. Generally, this value is far less than the fair market value of the land.
---
Tomorrow: Romspen Managing Director explains how proposed amendment will stablize area property values.
Wednesday: Oro Valley's Parks and Recreation Director Kristy Diaz-Trahan discusses that the towns parks and recreation plan does not include the purchase of this land.


Monday, April 6, 2020

Romspen Vistoso Golf Plan Substantially Changes Density

This requires a major general plan amendment
Romspen Mortgage Investment Fund ("Romspen") the owner of the shuttered Vistoso Golf Course, and Spectra Properties, based in Memphis have provided a draft request for a general plan amendment for the course. The course is currently zoned  mostly for recreational use. There is a 6 acre area currently designated for high density residential use.

87 Acres at stake
Romspen seeks to amend the YVOF (2016 General Plan) land use designations of approximately 87 acres from ‘Resort/Golf Course’ to ‘Medium Density Residential’ (MDR) and ‘High Density Residential’ (HDR). In the same application, Romspen is asking for the same change to the Rancho Vistoso PAD.

The Romsden Plan
Big money at stake
The area will experience a substantial increase in residential density and the addition of a high density resident senior care facility if the amendment is approved by council.  Romspen will reap substantial profit on their $3 million investment in the course. This is because acreage of residential land in Oro Valley is worth far more in the market than acres of a preserve. There are tens of millions of dollars at stake here.

The Neighborhood meeting requirement presents a barrier to moving this amendment forward
A general plan amendment petition must be submitted to the town by April 30 in order for it to be considered by council by end of this year. State regulations require that a neighborhood meeting occurs before the amendment is submitted (Town Code Section 2.15.F.3.b). "Neighborhood meetings should typically be scheduled on a weekday evening so that working residents may attend, but may be adapted to neighborhood needs, as appropriate."

Every neighborhood meeting that the town has conducted has always been an in person meeting. Such a meeting is not possible because the state, county, and town of Oro Valley require social distancing during the Covid-19 epidemic. It is anticipated that this restriction will remain in place for the month of April. Thus, there can be no in person neighborhood meeting.

Town proposed next step is a electronic information sharing session
According to group Preserve Vistoso, the town plans to post videos on April 10th explaining the rezoning process to residents and asking residents to direct questions and concerns to ask@orovalleyaz.gov or by calling 520-229-4711. The Town also will post a video from Romspen and Spectra that will provide an overview of rezoning applications. Subsequent video presentations will address questions and concerns from residents. In theory, this process more easily allows residents from the entire community to participate.

Still, this is not a neighborhood meeting, based on Oro Valley's established practice. It will, however, give the applicant some indication of what the residents the residents are thinking.

The actual neighborhood  meeting, and there must be two of these, will come when social distancing restrictions are no longer in effect.

The question is: Does an electronic information sharing session meet the neighborhood meeting legal requirement such that the amendment can move forward?
That is something that the legal team in Oro Valley needs to determine. Because, if is not such, then the amendment can not move forward. This legal standing  decision also has implications for an anticipated two more general plan amendments for other properties in Oro Valley.
---

Tuesday, December 8, 2020

Vistoso Residents: Bar Solomon From Town's Vistoso Land Negotiations

Yesterday we wrote about Vistoso resident demands that Council Member Steve Solomon be excluded from council actions regarding the town's potential purchase of the defunct Vistoso Golf Course. The following is one of  two emails to The Oro Valley Town Council stating their position in more detail. Tomorrow we will publish the second email. 

We have removed identifying information regarding the writer in order to promote harmony in the community. This email was sent to council after the council's decision to attempt the land purchase.
---

"Dear Town Council Members:

It was with relief and anticipation that your 7-0 vote to initiate the process to purchase the defunct golf course from Romspen at fair market value was received. Relief, that the council voted down Councilman Solomon's motion to act as our sole agent in a murky, backroom negotiation with Romspen. Anticipation, that the town is now on board with the community in actively seeking a permanent conservation easement for all of the property. The Rancho Vistoso neighborhood has been adamant that we want conservation and limited use for walking and cycling in a natural setting. No development. 

Those of us on the Zoom conference were aghast to learn that Councilman Solomon had been acting as an unauthorized "town agent" to give Romspen a premium and likely a path towards development in order to sell. One is left wondering what his motivations were .... His lack of transparency in responding to inquiries about the framework of his deal was alarming for a town council member. His boasting of "major, $100 Million deals" was telling. He's just a wheeler-dealer; a retired developer that wants back in the game. A Romspen "Fixer". 

For those reasons, I ask you to demand a recusal of Councilman Solomon from any further dealings in the matter of the defunct Vistoso Golf Course property. 

Solomon's opportunistic "Preserve Vistoso" signs stapled onto his re-election signs signaled his intent to support conservation. He talked conservation up during his campaign. Now his actions demonstrate his true intent, which is to create value for Romspen at the expense of our community. He wants to divide our community into winners and losers, depending on where you live around the old course. This is exactly what Mike Ford, The Conservation Fund (TCF) stated in his final communication to us. He said THIS MUST NOT HAPPEN. Mr. Ford knew well the perils of dividing the community with partial development. That is why TCF insisted that their effort to create a conservation easement be for all 208 acres, nothing less. Partial development would tear at the social and financial fabric of our neighborhood. The fear of partial development is palpable and needs to be taken off the table. 

We believe that the best way forward is just what your 7-0 vote calls for - a full conservation easement in perpetuity. It may be a long, hard path to walk but just knowing that the council will stay the course to that conclusion will sustain us. 

Councilman Solomon's motion for creation of a task force included a seat for Preserve Vistoso, (PV), leadership in the deal making. He unwittingly confirmed what many of us have suspected for some time. His comments appeared to be in line with a PV survey that circulated last spring polling residents as to their stance on potentially developing some of the property in order to conserve other areas around the course. I saw the survey. It clearly showed the golf course property right behind our home as available for development. I note that none of the PV leadership's homes were near the areas they thought would be agreeable to Romspen for development. Conservation would take place near their homes. After I saw the survey form, I quickly rescinded my five figure pledge to PV. I then spoke directly to Mr. Ford by phone. He was aware of the survey and told PV to cease sending it out, as it as divisive; it would tear the neighborhood apart and TCF would not be a party to it. The form disappeared quickly. Unfortunately, a seed of doubt has been planted in our neighborhood. What were PV leadership's real intentions? What are they going forward? Are they for creating a conservation easement for ALL of the defunct golf course, or just those areas behind their homes? Is PV really just a self-serving entity? 

I would like to see the Preserve Vistoso leadership offer the community a clarifying statement, so we can better understand their motivations and survey mis-step. Perhaps they can re-affirm their role as a strong, collective voice for our neighborhood regarding the future of the old course. 

The council's rejection of Councilman Solomon's motion to create a task force to codify his murky deal also gives PV an opportunity to step away from him. Instead, they could provide our neighborhood with the much needed clarifications on where they stand on the future of the defunct golf course. While only the town council speaks for us in legally binding matters, PV can be our voice and gathering place to hash out and communicate to you our collective desires in these matters. They are not our negotiators. 

I know the hard road to town ownership of this land will be successful. We have the votes and the will of the people behind the effort. [We] will re-pledge our donation to the purchase of the land if the council stays the course towards a fair market value for the property. Many others in Rancho Vistoso will do the same. As Mayor Winfield said, "We can find the money". We can take the time, too. 

Most importantly, you have the power to just say NO to re-zoning the property. If Romspen sees that the council majority is in favor of a full conservation easement and has not opportunity to develop the land, they will finally sell at fair market value terms. The property has been abandoned. It is subject to condemnation. They will sell when they see our resolve. 

Our neighbor, [name deleted], has asked to sign onto this letter. [Information regarding neighbor deleted for privacy purposes.

[We] and many others share the opinion that Councilman Solomon must recuse himself from this agenda item. We hope the entire town council agrees.

Sincerely"
---

Wednesday, March 18, 2020

Major Change In Land Use Will Be Requested For Vistoso Golf Course

From recreational land use to residential
Romspen Mortgage Investment Fund ("Romspen") the owner of the shuttered Vistoso Golf Course, has a buyer for 38 acres of the 206 acres of the course.

The buyer, Spectra Properties, based in Memphis, is primarily a retail center developer. Spectra has 69 retail center properties located in smaller towns and cities. They have three retail centers in Arizona.

For memory care and assisted living facilities
Spectra has entered the memory care and assisted living business, with one facility operating in Conroe Texas. Spectra is proposing to build an upscale assisted living and memory care on 38 acres of the property, most on what was the driving range.

Click to enlarge
According to Preserve Vistoso: "Currently the plan shows 2 buildings on the driving range but [Romspen] said he would like the option to add a third between Siena and the buildings shown in red on the diagram. Independent Living units would be built to the east of the driving range in the yellow area." The 2-building approach is Spectra's prototype.

Romspen does not have a buyer for the rest of land, 6 acres of which are zoned for high density residential.

Romspen has a lot of convincing to do
The 2016 General Plan calls for this land to be used for recreational purposes. The Rancho Vistoso PAD has it designated as such. The town council will have to approve a General Plan Amendment to change this designation to any other land use. That will require a 5 person council majority, If that is approved, the PAD change will require a 4 person council rezoning approval. Prior to all this, there will have to be a number of public meetings.

It's a long road and probably for Romspen [and Spectra], a road that we believe will not be approved by this council. That is because the four newest members of this council pledged to not amend the General Plan. However, people, especially those in politics, have been known to change their minds. Even if this council does not approve it, there will be future councils.

Preserve Vistoso wants this land to remain recreational use
preservevistoso.org wants the former Vistoso Course designated as preserve land in the 2020 Parks and Recreation Master Plan. If that happens, it will be an added barrier for future councils to overlook. (Source)

Thursday, April 29, 2021

Update On Negotiations To Purchase Vistoso Golf Property

The following is a press release from the organization, Preserve Vistoso
—-
April 26, 2021-- Mike Ford, Southwest Director of Conservation Acquisition for The Conservation Fund (TCF), provided Preserve Vistoso board members an update on progress to purchase the Vistoso  from Romspen Investments. Ford said that the Town of Oro Valley Attorney Jonathon Rothschild and Town Manager Mary Jacobs invited TCF to reengage in discussions for a purchase agreement with Romspen. Any deal is contingent on an appraisal of the property to establish Fair Market Value (FMV). Romspen attorney Pat Lopez agreed to contract for an updated appraisal

Ford said the deal being considered is for TCF to purchase the 202 acres zoned recreational at FMV and place a conservation easement on the property to protect it in perpetuity as open space. Terms of the deal including the purchase price and conservation easement language will be released publicly once the deal closes. The purpose of a conservation easement would be to define exactly what would be allowed and what would be prohibited. It would allow hiking trails, trail heads and parking areas, but ball parks and amphitheaters, for example, would not be allowed on the property.

 In a separate agreement, the six acres where the former club house and parking lot exist, currently zoned high density residential, would be sold to a private developer. Any development of the property would be subject to all existing zoning constraints including building height limits of 35 feet. Ford said that the developer would be known to our community and the plans would be compatible with the 202 open space acres.

If the FMV offer is accepted by Romspen, TCF would hope to close the deal by year end.  While TCF intends to eventually donate the property to the Town, TCF would also select a third party conservation land trust as a steward of the property to protect the natural habitat. 

"This is great news for our community," said Gayle Mateer, President of Preserve Vistoso. “TCF has remained willing to re-engage in the process even after the initial offer to Romspen was rejected last September. Mike Ford's leadership and the Town of Oro Valley's support have made an agreement on the property a possibility. We are cautiously optimistic that Romspen will accept the deal and we can end our three-year nightmare of uncertainty about the property."

—-

Tuesday, May 5, 2020

Romspen: "Amendment Will Stabilize Property Values"

This is the second of three reports on The Town of Oro Valley's video response to more than 1,000 resident questions on the proposed Vistoso Golf General Plan Amendment.  Yesterday, we focused on the "benefit of certainty" Romspen believes the amendment provides. Today, we focus on Romspen's belief that the proposed amendment will stabilize, perhaps enhance property values in the area. Tomorrow, we will present Oro Valley's Parks and Recreation Director's remark that the town will not purchase the property.

Please note that all three posting present what the individual said. They are presented without LOVE comment.
---
A "one of a kind amenity"
Romspen Managing Director Peter Oelbaum addressed the question of the impact on existing property value of the proposed Vistoso Golf general plan amendment. "“Instead of living on a dead golf course with no visibility as to what may happen in the future, people’s homes will be part of a revived community to enjoy, truly, a one of a kind amenity.”


             Video: Romspen Discusses Property Value
Oelbaum believes that the proposed 115 acre multi-use trail will be attractive to many future home buyers.

 To be used by many
“Any study that we have seen says that golf courses are used by less than 25% of the residents that live around them. An amenity, such as we are discussing, could be used by everyone."

His rationale: "There are many more buyers… who would prefer to be beside a multi use path, a fitness trail... an open space providing opportunities to react with nature. In truth, there are more people out there who enjoy nature than there are golfers.”

A best path for restoring property value
Oelbaum believes that the proposed general plan amendment is the best path to mitigate and restore future property value.

He asks residents to compare "home values with a dead golf course and all the uncertainty of all that may happen in the future [to home] value with partial redevelopment that will provide certainty for the future; and [will have] a cherished amenity that can be used by everyone, not just golfers or trespassers.”

Property value impact of proposed residential facilities not discussed
Romspen did not address the impact on existing home values of the proposed high density residential homes or of the proposed senior living facility.

Watch Oelbaum's remarks in the panel above.
---

Friday, November 20, 2020

Town To Attempt Fair Market Value Purchase Vistoso Golf Property By April 1

Town to attempt purchase of Vistoso Golf Property 
Wednesday, the Oro Valley Town Council unanimously passed a motion to actively engage in negotiations to purchase the former Vistoso golf course 208 acre plot. The purchase target date is April 1. Mayor Winfield noted that there is potential monetary support from grants such as the State’s “Water and Conservation Fund". Whatever the town pays would be matched dollar for dollar by that fund. 

Purchase for an elusive "Fair Market Value"
The motion stipulates that the town purchase the property at fair market value (FMV). Romspen, the property owner, has already rejected a FMV proposal from The Conservation Fund. That value is based on the land as it is currently zoned.

Romspen has a different view of the FMV of the property, one, we believe, that values the property as it will be if it is rezoned for home lots as Romspen has requested.

We suspect that the difference between these values is in the many millions of dollars range.

Council rejected proposal to join a negotiating group formed by Council Member Solomon
The motion passed after council rejected (5-2) a motion that would have engage the town with a smaller group, led by Council Member Solomon. At the meeting, Solomon said that he has been in contact with a Romspen representative and that he has devised a framework that, he believe, could result in a resolution of this issue in 60 days. He declined to state what the framework entails.

Members of that group would have included Solomon the Vistoso Community Association, Preserve Vistoso, Romspen and the town’s manager. The town’s involvement would have been more as a facilitator and observer and not as a purchaser. I think we have a real breakthrough here,” Council Member Steve Solomon stated in reference to this approach.   

Eminent Domain is a long a costly process
Another alternative discussed at the meeting, one that appears tabled for the moment, is the town’s condemnation of the property. According to town attorney Gary Cohen, condemnation would require several years to occur and the purchase price would be indeterminate until a later date, if it became a matter for a jury to decide.
---

Friday, March 19, 2021

Jacobs Tries To Provide Clarity To The Status of Former Vistoso Golf Property Purchase Negotiations

Town Manager Mary Jacobs stated the following during her Town Manager’s report to council of March 17. We have provided heading for reading convenience.

—-
The Conservation Fund has never been excluded from negotiations
“For this evening’s update on Romspen on the potential purchase of the Vistoso Golf Course, I wanted to correct some apparent misinformation. The Conservation Fund has never been excluded from negotiations They did their own appraisal last year and they remain engaged in the process. The Conservation Fund provided to the town and to Romspen the parameters by which they can participate in the purchase of this property. And we held our most recent meeting with Mike Ford of The Conservation Fund just last week.

Negotiations are pending Romspen's response
The ball has been in Romspen’s court now for many weeks. Unfortunately, due to personal tragedy that occurred in the family of one of the Romspen negotiators, the town is extending some grace to their team through this very difficult time. So we do hope to hear from them in the near future and, of course we will report back to the community.

Council has been kept apprised of the status of discussions
And I did just want to clarify again: The Mayor and council motion from November 18 specifies that Mr. Cohen and I were given the task “In an effort to negotiate the sale of the former Vistoso Golf Course, zoned open space golf for fair market value on or before April 1.” We were also further instructed to keep the council regularly informed on the status of these efforts. As you know, in any negotiated real estate transaction the party offering to purchase can not force the seller to sell their property nor dictate the purchase price. It is a process of negotiation and sometimes these things take longer than any one of us would personally prefer. Myself included.

As I mentioned last week, the town council is being kept fully abreast of all discussions and developments in the negotiation and this elected body has provided appropriate direction in executive session in accordance with the provisions of state law. Information regarding the town council’s ability to use executive session and the confidentiality of those negotiations has been posted to the town’s website per the Mayor’s request of two weeks ago.” 

[End of Jacobs' statement]
---
Vistoso residents respond
Vistoso residents reacted to Jacobs' statement during the call to audience segment of the meeting. There comments focused on continued confusion as to whether the town has obtained an appraisal of the property. Jacobs statement did not answer that question.

Monday, February 21, 2022

Romspen received $4.25 million for the former Vistoso Golf Course

The beginning of a 202 acre preserve
Friday’s announcement by The Conservation Fund that they purchased the former Vistoso Golf course was fantastic news for the community. It marked the end of a long and difficult negotiation with the property owner. More importantly, however, it marks the beginning of a 202 acre nature preserve for everyone in the community to enjoy.

We plan to tell the story of how this all came about. It is indeed a very complicated story.

Today, we start our story with the result: The settlement agreement that was signed for the purchase of the property.

Resulted from a deal that required a “settlement agreement”

“A settlement agreement is a legal contract that resolves the disputes among all parties by coming to an agreement. It is a legal document where all parties in a court case, in civil law, agree to an outcome of any judgment being made in advance.” (https://www.legalmatch.com/law-library/article/what-is-a-settlement-agreement.html). When it comes to the Vistoso Golf Course, there are many issues that needed to be resolved. The most important of which was what development was going to be allowed on the property. There is after all a 6+ acre parcel that is already zoned for apartments. Then there is the 202 acre golf course including a clubhouse that could have been potentially used for a variety of purposes. The settlement agreement states exactly how all of this was resolved.

The deal has six key elements
  • 202 acres will be a permanent nature preserve.That is the golf courses.
  • 6+ acres, the clubhouse area, will house proximally 132 apartments
  • The apartments will be no higher than two stories. The property is zoned for up to a three-story apartment building.
  • A small portion, roughly 1 acre, adjacent to the the 6+ acres will be available for use for parking for the apartments.
  • No county recapture of property taxes will be incurred by any party as a result of the sale.
  • Romspen will receive funds as detailed in the panel at right
There are four participants in the deal
Romspen (Vistoso) LLC
Romspen LLC is the owner of the property. They purchased it in 2012 in a bankruptcy proceeding. They operated the golf course until 2016. They shut it down and proceeded to spend the next five years concocting various ways to parse the property for development. They received $4.25 million for their effort.
Ross Rulney
Ross Rulney is a Tucson based developer. He developed "El Corredor" which is located at Oracle and Linda Vista. It is a mixed-use development. Rulney took over that property from a company that was trying to build a motel there. They went out of business.  Rulney is going to build the apartments.. He paid $1.75 million to buy the property. 
The Conservation Fund 
The Conservation Fund ("TCF") is the entity that now owns a golf course. They will be donating it to the town once they find a conservator to manage the settlement agreement such that nothing other than a natural preserve will ever exist on the property. Through the efforts of the residents, TCF raised donations sufficient to pay Romspen $1.615 million. That was the appraised value of the land.
Town of Oro Valley
The town of Oro Valley is the fourth participant in the transaction. The town agreed to pay $885,000 to settle all remaining “disagreements.”  This resolved a "legal dispute."

- - - 
Want to learn more? Read the Settlement Agreement here.

Wednesday, December 9, 2020

Vistoso Residents: Only Town, Romspen and The Conservation Fund Should Negotiate Vistoso Land Deal

Monday we wrote about Vistoso resident demands that Council Member Steve Solomon be excluded from council actions regarding the town's potential purchase of the defunct Vistoso Golf Course. Yesterday, we posted an email to council supporting this contention. Today, we post a second email from a different residents.  This email highlights the distrust of some in Council Member Solomon and in the group Preserve Vistoso.

We have removed identifying information regarding the writer in order to promote harmony in the community. This email was sent to council after the council's decision to seek a land purchase.
---

Hello Town Council Members,

We are writing to follow up on the Town Council meeting conducted on 11/18/20, specifically agenda item #2 – DISCUSSION AND POSSIBLE ACTION REGARDING THE CLOSED VISTOSO GOLF COURSE PROPERTY. We were in attendance and unfortunately our request to speak during the meeting (from our land line) must have not been detected by TOV [Town of Oro Valley] staff. Thus, we are writing to provide our input.

[We]  have lived in Vistoso Highlands ... [for] years. We would like to begin by sincerely thanking those Council members who have persevered to uphold the Rancho Vistoso resident’s unwavering choice to purchase the former Vistoso Golf Course (the 202 acres at FMV as green space, in perpetuity). The ONLY parties required to negotiate and finalize this agreement are the Town of Oro Valley, Romspen and The Conservation Fund (TCF). All other non-essential parties MUST stand down. Otherwise, the success of this action will be put at risk.

Personal Experience: 
  1. [We] attended a Preserve Vistoso (PV) sponsored Zoom call on July 7, 2020 in support of The Conservation Fund (TCF) with the goal to participate in the pledge drive. As follow up to this PV Zoom call, we received the attached PV Survey (note 2 attachments – one is the original email dated July 17, 2020. The survey is also separately attached for ease of reference). In summary, we were requested to make significant monetary pledges while the questionnaire clearly is driving to support partial development. Thus interpreted -- we were requested to make a considerable financial pledge to have the property developed behind us – 6th and 7th holes? Imagine how my [We]  felt? 
  2. As of the 11/18/20 Town Council Meeting, Michael Bilodeau, PV President, still continues to deny and spread the false narrative that TCF was not yet involved as of July 17, 2020. This somehow is being used to justify the distribution of the attached survey/questionnaire. This is a blatant misrepresentation - TCF was involved and is the reason we participated in the PV Zoom call. Also, please note, the Pledge form distributed on July 17th clearly reflects TCF (this further contradicts/refutes Michael Bilodeau’s claim TCF was not yet involved). [Insert follows below]
  3. We would like to add that whether TCF was involved or not, PV is a 501(c)(3) and was participating in behavior to the detriment of certain members of the community without full disclosure that partial development was in fact their true mission. The bigger question is “with whom was PV with working regarding the potential development of the parcels on the 6th and 7th holes”? My husband and I attempted to ascertain the motive and facts behind the PV survey. We feel we need to impart the “information/rumors” we subsequently learned which implicate a sitting member of council. The “rumors” indicate there was a targeted 6-acre parcel in this area for development that may have influenced Romspen’s decision to decline the TCF FMV [fair market value] offer for all 202 acres. While these are rumors, we believe where there is smoke there is fire. 
  4.  Thus, to date, we are still withholding our pledge commitment. Our pledge will only be made to TCF. 
Council Member [Solomon] Feedback
  1. Councilman Solomon needs to consider “recusing himself” from further involvement in this matter. 
  2. Councilman Solomon’s comments during the Town Council meeting were alarming and clearly revealed questionable motives (particularly development) with respect to some portion of the property. Is this related to the specific portion highlighted by the PV survey (holes 6 and 7 – including the targeted “6-acre parcel”)? Clearly, he has been working with PV for some time. It was very disconcerting to hear he had already formed and met with his “hand selected committee” that could resolve this matter in 30-60 days. When pressed by residents for his strategy and plan, he had none. 
  3. [We] were very uncomfortable when Councilman Solomon’s motion was discussed. Did his motion set the stage for the compromise and development of the targeted 6-acre parcel? Please note he referred to “his hand selected committee that would include himself, PV leadership and Romspen” and that they could resolve this issue quickly with a handshake and resolution within in 30 – 60 days. Please note he indicated they had already been meeting which further supported the quick resolution. 
  4. Again, could this have possibly been a reason that Romspen declined the TCF FMV deal/offer? 
  5. As stated above, we request Councilman Solomon recuse himself from further involvement in this matter. 
Request for Resident Communication
We would like to request (if possible) that the Town of Oro Valley communicate directly with the Rancho Vistoso residents with respect to information and updates regarding status and future actions of the golf course resolution. This approach will provide the required transparency needed to ensure that all information is fully distributed/communicated to all residents. This will avoid residents having to rely on Preserve Vistoso, an organization that clearly has “some” explaining to do. 

Respectfully,"
---
Publisher note: The group Preserve Vistoso asserts that it has always operated to ensure that the Vistoso property remains open space. Please read our November 24th posting regarding Preserve Vistoso's explanation of their activities.  The group asserts that their goal has always been to create a permanent conservation easement on the property. 

Friday, April 9, 2021

The Conservation Fund Clarifies It’s Involvement In Former Vistoso Golf Course Purchase

The Conservation Fund has clarified its role in the purchase of the former Vistoso Golf Course in the following press release of April 8, 2021. The statement confirms what Town Manager Jacobs presented to the public at Wednesday night’s Oro Valley Town Council Meeting. It also provides detail as to what The Conservation Fund expects to happen as negotiations continue.  We have included Jacob’s remarks to council after this press release.
- - -
The Conservation Fund statement regarding future involvement in purchase of the former Vistoso Golf Course
“The Conservation Fund (Fund) is pleased to announce it has been invited to resume formal discussions and negotiations with the Town of Oro Valley and representatives from Romspen Vistoso, LLC, concerning the purchase of the former Vistoso Golf Course. Yesterday, we met to discuss the proposed framework of a new agreement concerning the prospective purchase of the 202 +/- acres, currently zoned recreational/open space. A separate agreement between a private buyer and Romspen Vistoso, LLC will be executed concurrently for the remaining 6 +/- acres.

Securing the 202 +/-acre property will be contingent upon reaching agreement based upon an updated appraisal establishing current fair market value under mutually acceptable terms and conditions. We expect the report to be prepared quickly and we will announce the actual purchase price once final agreement has been reached.

Under related discussion, it was also agreed the Fund will manage and lead all fundraising associated with any prospective purchase. The Fund will coordinate directly with all interested parties, including Preserve Vistoso and the many residents who have long supported this important effort. The Fund will also develop a concurrent Conservation Easement to ensure the property will be protected and managed for conservation and open space, in perpetuity, prior to transferring the land to the Town of Oro Valley for long-term ownership and management.

The Fund shares the collective passion to preserve this unique property and we will keep everyone advised as details continue to develop. We plan to make a more detailed announcement in the next 30 days, following completion of the updated appraisal. In the meantime, we want to thank everyone for your continued trust and confidence. Your support, financial generosity, and valuable input will be needed now more than ever as we work to create lasting results for everyone.

For any questions or concerns please contact Mike Ford, Nevada and Southwest Director at mford@conservationfund.org.”
- - -
Jacobs’ statement regarding status of former Vistoso Golf land purchase
Town Manager Mary Jacobs provided the following update on the town’s purchase of the former Vistoso Golf Course, at Wednesday’s Oro Valley Town Council meeting:

The town has achieved “...a framework for the purchase of the golf course subject to working with third parties including The Conservation Fund and a successful fundraising effort; and while I’m not at liberty to outline the specifics tonight, this framework is consistent with the town Council‘s November 18th motion to staff.”

Jacobs continued “...this purchase framework has been discussed with Romspen, The Conservation Fund and a third party purchaser for the 6.3 acres [of land currently zone for multi-family housing]; and all parties have agreed to work within the general framework toward a detailed final agreement. Mr. Rothchild and I are working diligently to bring this framework to fruition; and subject to agreements being finalized with Romspen, we hope to then share the details with the community and invite your participation in the near future.”

Monday, March 8, 2021

Multiple Vistoso residents call for the termination of Town Manager Mary Jacobs

Quality of life in Oro Valley at stake
Last week, during the March third "Call to Audience" segment of the town council meeting, a number of Rancho Vistoso residents expressed their dismay regarding the manner in which the town is pursuing the purchase of the former Vistoso Golf Course property.

Our report, "Vistoso Golf Course Purchase Has Gone "Sideways", quickly explains their concerns.  

The level of angst among residents is high. What happens with this property has a direct and lasting effect on their quality of life in Oro Valley.

Many Rancho Vistoso residents had sent messages of concern to the town council prior to last week's meeting. The following is an excerpt from one of these letters. It is representative of their concerns.
---
"Mayor and Council,
Today I call upon you to terminate Oro Valley Town Manager, Mary Jacobs, from her post. What do I base this action on? Read on.

Last November, you voted 7-0 on the Mayor's motion to direct the town manager to initiate a process to purchase the now abandoned Rancho Vistoso Golf Course from Romspen, LLC, based on Fair Market Value, (FMV).  Should an offer based on a town-derived appraisal for the "open space" of the golf course not be accepted by Romspen, then the town would pursue condemnation and take control of the land for the benefit of the community. A well-trodden path.

Clearly, this motion (see panel at right) was a directive to the town manager to act. The motion carried a due date for completion of work by April 1, 2021.

Today is March 1, 2021, and the town manager has not even begun the process. No appraisal has been contracted for (as far as the public has been informed) and the April 1st deadline will not be met and the community will continue to suffer the consequence of the city manager's inability to act on the motion you set forth.

The failure to procure a fair market value appraisal means that no fact-based offer or negotiation can be achieved. The FMV appraisal is the foundation to any solution.

The community has not been kept in the communications loop. We are locked out of transparent communications by Executive Sessions and the town manager's inadequate "two minute" reports that proffer nothing of substance. The town manager's obvious disregard for the community's pent-up need for meaningful information is appalling.

The town must now immediately remove the city manager as she has willfully defied the town council's directive and therefore placed herself in a position of being dismissed "with cause.” Alternatively, you could give her until April 1, 2021 to complete the performance of her duty as outlined in the motion.

The community is now in jeopardy of losing the opportunity to acquire the property. We hear that The Conservation Fund would still be willing to step-up to assist in the solution. I can imagine that the lack of transparency in communications and inaction by the town manager to acquire an appraisal must send the wrong signals about our willingness to accept their generous offer to help create a conservation easement here.

So what has the town manager been doing if not what the council directed her to do? Clearly not making an offer to Romspen for their consideration; no FMV appraisal, no valid offer. Is the town manager making "invalid" offers to Romspen? Are there other "cloaked" offers circulating that is taking up precious time and resources that have not been disclosed publicly? Are there other suitors out there making offers that are so destructive to your unanimous vote for conservation, that she cannot share them with the community? We can only speculate.

The town manager is the impediment to a community and town council supported solution for open space conservation in perpetuity. Let's remove the town manager from her position for cause and bad faith. She is no servant-leader.

Let's move on quickly towards the light of transparent communications and good faith offers as you directed at the town council meeting of November 18, 2020."
---

Thursday, September 9, 2021

Vistoso Preserve Becoming A Reality

Vistoso Nature Preserve to become a reality
Last night, the Oro Valley Town Council met in executive session to finalize next steps regarding the conversion of the former Vistoso Golf Course into a preserve. The council unanimously approved the following resolution:

"...to proceed with a settlement agreement of all disputes [between the town and property owner] Romspen that facilitates The Conservation Fund's purchase of the 202 acres of the former Vistoso Golf Course; that the town council will allow the town to be a party to the resolution of all claims with Romspen and be party to the negotiation to the conservation easement between The Conservation Fund and Romspen, including any consideration acquired by the town; that staff is directed further to the settlement agreement, to involve a third party regarding the purchase of the six acre property owned by Romspen, currently zoned multi family residential."

End of a long journey
Residents are hopeful that his  resolution ends a four year nightmare for the residents of Rancho Vistoso.  Speaking on the motion, Oro Valley resident Rosa Dailey speaking to council observed: "You are going to be known as the council that brought conservation to Oro Valley in a very big way." 

According to Dailey:" This is the end of a long journey."