Showing posts sorted by date for query Parcel 7-I. Sort by relevance Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by date for query Parcel 7-I. Sort by relevance Show all posts

Friday, September 18, 2026

Bits and Pieces

Almost a year now and Gephart still does no know how huge construction sales tax forecasting error happened
LOVE has written for almost a year that the Town badly overestimated FY2025-26 construction sales tax revenue, budgeting about $5.1 million and ultimately collecting only about $2.7 million. At Wednesday’s Council meeting, we learned that staff made a large error in the opposite direction on building permits: residential building permit revenue reached $1.55 million, while total license and permit revenue exceeded budget by nearly $684,000. 

Vice Mayor Melanie Barrett asked the obvious question: How could the Town significantly overestimate construction tax revenue while simultaneously underestimating the permit revenue associated with development? Finance Director David Gephart responded, “I don’t have a good answer for you at this point,” adding that he would have to “go back and look at how the budget was formulated.” 

When Barrett asked for a report explaining the discrepancy, Gephart agreed. 

The construction sales tax problem had been apparent for months, making it reasonable to expect Gephart to already understand how the original assumptions had gone so wrong. The issue is no longer simply that two forecasts missed badly in opposite directions. It now raises a broader question: Is Gephart providing the level of financial oversight the Council should expect?

Council and residents appeal staff zoning decision; Board of Adjustment hearing October 5
The Oro Valley Town Council and nearby Rancho Vistoso residents have appealed a staff zoning interpretation involving the proposed senior-care development on the vacant commercial parcel north of Safeway Vistoso Plaza. The disputed interpretation, issued by the Planning and Zoning Administrator, determined that a “sanatorium” is a permitted use in the Rancho Vistoso PAD’s C-1 commercial zoning district. Under Town procedures, appeals of zoning interpretations are heard by the Board of Adjustment, which acts as a quasi-judicial body and makes the Town’s final decision on the matter. Oro Valley The appeal is scheduled for a Board of Adjustment hearing on October 5. (learn more here)

Town launches pre-approved home plans to cut time and cost
Oro Valley’s new Community Model Homes program is now live, giving residents access to Town pre-approved designs intended to make building a guest house, casita or home faster and less expensive. The initial library includes accessory dwelling units and single-family homes, with duplex and triplex plans expected beginning in 2027. The plans are created by local design professionals and builders and are available for use by interested residents. The Town says the program is intended to expand housing options while reducing permitting time and costs. Visit the town program home page to learn more.

Oro Valley expects 14% CAP reduction in 2027 — but says local supplies are secure
Oro Valley Water Utility says the federal government’s new Colorado River operating framework is expected to reduce the Town’s Central Arizona Project allocation by about 14% beginning in January 2027. Water Utility Director Peter Abraham says Oro Valley is positioned to absorb that reduction because its CAP allocation exceeds what it normally needs, allowing the Town to store excess water underground, and because it has accumulated long-term storage credits that can be used if future CAP deliveries decline further. The Utility also points to its diversified water portfolio — groundwater, CAP water and reclaimed water — and regional partnerships as additional protection against future shortages. (Town of Oro Valley Water, "Behind the meter," Fall 2026 issue)

Fall pavement preservation work underway across Oro Valley
Oro Valley has started its fall 2026 pavement preservation program, with work scheduled from September through November on streets and in neighborhoods throughout town. The Town says the work is intended to extend the life of existing pavement before more expensive reconstruction is required, with streets selected based on pavement condition and prior treatment history. Among the larger areas on this fall’s list are Naranja Drive from La Cañada to First Avenue, Vistoso Commerce Loop, Vistoso Estates and Tangerine Heights, along with numerous neighborhood streets. Work is generally scheduled between 7 a.m. and 5 p.m., and residents in affected neighborhoods will receive notice before construction begins. (Source: Town of Oro Valley Media Release)

Monday, December 13, 2021

DeJa Vu: More Rooftops Sought for Woodburne... Rancho Vistoso Blvd... Tangerine

The "Luxury Leased Home Lifestyle"
Last month, we wrote about "tiny homes" being vetted by the town on a lot located just north of Safeway on Rancho Vistoso Blvd. That project is called "Avilla Rancho Vistoso East".  

There is a companion project called Avilla Rancho Vistoso West. It is also being vetted by the town. The focus is on building 125 detached homes which will range from 700 to 1,300 square feet. 

According to the applicant, Nexmetro, represent by Paul Oland of Pargdigm Land Design LLC, these homes focus on serving the housing need empty-nesters or others who do not want to own their homes. The homes are leased. Oland said that lease rates will be substantially higher than neighboring towns. Generally, in developments like this, only one in six homes will have children. "Women typically make up the majority of the residents, in part because it is a very safe environment".

Traffic a major resident concern
Those who attended a December 2 meeting on the project voiced concern regarding the increased traffic that the development could bring to the community. 

Oland believes that the proposed residential homes will bring less traffic to the area than if the land were used for the currently zoned commercial purposes.  Oland does recognize that the intersection of Woodburne Ave and Rancho Vistoso Blvd is a "awkward intersection that should clean that up." 

The applicant plans to conduct a detailed traffic study of existing conditions, including the impact of these new homes as part of their application. Oland did state that the applicant would remove access to Woodburne from this project if that improved the situation for current residents.

Speaking for the town, town engineer David Laws stated that the town is very aware of the intersection challenges. He also affirmed that developments of this nature do drive increase traffic in the area less than a similar commercial development.

Bait and Switch Feared
Resident speakers at the meeting voiced concern of "bait and switch". One form of "bait and switch" is for a rezoning to be approved for the proposed use, only to changed to another allowable use for that zoning code in the future.  "A substantial change in use from that proposed would require town council approval", according to Town Senior Planner Hannah Oden. 

Another form of "bait and switch" is for the land to be sold by the owner once it is rezoned. This land will become instantly more valuable with high density residential zoning attached to it. Indeed, this tactic is a common real estate play. There is nothing to prevent that sale form occurring.

Not the first rodeo
This is not the first time attempts have been made to rezone this land. Indeed, Oland was involved in more than one. Ten years ago, HSL Properties, with Oland's leadership, wanted to put apartments on this property. At that time we called it "Neighborhood 7, Parcel 7-i" You can read LOVE's many report on that here.  Traffic was such a major concern then that a resident did a traffic study.

Second Neighborhood Meetings Pending
There will be a second neighborhood meeting.

Wednesday, December 9, 2020

Vistoso Residents: Only Town, Romspen and The Conservation Fund Should Negotiate Vistoso Land Deal

Monday we wrote about Vistoso resident demands that Council Member Steve Solomon be excluded from council actions regarding the town's potential purchase of the defunct Vistoso Golf Course. Yesterday, we posted an email to council supporting this contention. Today, we post a second email from a different residents.  This email highlights the distrust of some in Council Member Solomon and in the group Preserve Vistoso.

We have removed identifying information regarding the writer in order to promote harmony in the community. This email was sent to council after the council's decision to seek a land purchase.
---

Hello Town Council Members,

We are writing to follow up on the Town Council meeting conducted on 11/18/20, specifically agenda item #2 – DISCUSSION AND POSSIBLE ACTION REGARDING THE CLOSED VISTOSO GOLF COURSE PROPERTY. We were in attendance and unfortunately our request to speak during the meeting (from our land line) must have not been detected by TOV [Town of Oro Valley] staff. Thus, we are writing to provide our input.

[We]  have lived in Vistoso Highlands ... [for] years. We would like to begin by sincerely thanking those Council members who have persevered to uphold the Rancho Vistoso resident’s unwavering choice to purchase the former Vistoso Golf Course (the 202 acres at FMV as green space, in perpetuity). The ONLY parties required to negotiate and finalize this agreement are the Town of Oro Valley, Romspen and The Conservation Fund (TCF). All other non-essential parties MUST stand down. Otherwise, the success of this action will be put at risk.

Personal Experience: 
  1. [We] attended a Preserve Vistoso (PV) sponsored Zoom call on July 7, 2020 in support of The Conservation Fund (TCF) with the goal to participate in the pledge drive. As follow up to this PV Zoom call, we received the attached PV Survey (note 2 attachments – one is the original email dated July 17, 2020. The survey is also separately attached for ease of reference). In summary, we were requested to make significant monetary pledges while the questionnaire clearly is driving to support partial development. Thus interpreted -- we were requested to make a considerable financial pledge to have the property developed behind us – 6th and 7th holes? Imagine how my [We]  felt? 
  2. As of the 11/18/20 Town Council Meeting, Michael Bilodeau, PV President, still continues to deny and spread the false narrative that TCF was not yet involved as of July 17, 2020. This somehow is being used to justify the distribution of the attached survey/questionnaire. This is a blatant misrepresentation - TCF was involved and is the reason we participated in the PV Zoom call. Also, please note, the Pledge form distributed on July 17th clearly reflects TCF (this further contradicts/refutes Michael Bilodeau’s claim TCF was not yet involved). [Insert follows below]
  3. We would like to add that whether TCF was involved or not, PV is a 501(c)(3) and was participating in behavior to the detriment of certain members of the community without full disclosure that partial development was in fact their true mission. The bigger question is “with whom was PV with working regarding the potential development of the parcels on the 6th and 7th holes”? My husband and I attempted to ascertain the motive and facts behind the PV survey. We feel we need to impart the “information/rumors” we subsequently learned which implicate a sitting member of council. The “rumors” indicate there was a targeted 6-acre parcel in this area for development that may have influenced Romspen’s decision to decline the TCF FMV [fair market value] offer for all 202 acres. While these are rumors, we believe where there is smoke there is fire. 
  4.  Thus, to date, we are still withholding our pledge commitment. Our pledge will only be made to TCF. 
Council Member [Solomon] Feedback
  1. Councilman Solomon needs to consider “recusing himself” from further involvement in this matter. 
  2. Councilman Solomon’s comments during the Town Council meeting were alarming and clearly revealed questionable motives (particularly development) with respect to some portion of the property. Is this related to the specific portion highlighted by the PV survey (holes 6 and 7 – including the targeted “6-acre parcel”)? Clearly, he has been working with PV for some time. It was very disconcerting to hear he had already formed and met with his “hand selected committee” that could resolve this matter in 30-60 days. When pressed by residents for his strategy and plan, he had none. 
  3. [We] were very uncomfortable when Councilman Solomon’s motion was discussed. Did his motion set the stage for the compromise and development of the targeted 6-acre parcel? Please note he referred to “his hand selected committee that would include himself, PV leadership and Romspen” and that they could resolve this issue quickly with a handshake and resolution within in 30 – 60 days. Please note he indicated they had already been meeting which further supported the quick resolution. 
  4. Again, could this have possibly been a reason that Romspen declined the TCF FMV deal/offer? 
  5. As stated above, we request Councilman Solomon recuse himself from further involvement in this matter. 
Request for Resident Communication
We would like to request (if possible) that the Town of Oro Valley communicate directly with the Rancho Vistoso residents with respect to information and updates regarding status and future actions of the golf course resolution. This approach will provide the required transparency needed to ensure that all information is fully distributed/communicated to all residents. This will avoid residents having to rely on Preserve Vistoso, an organization that clearly has “some” explaining to do. 

Respectfully,"
---
Publisher note: The group Preserve Vistoso asserts that it has always operated to ensure that the Vistoso property remains open space. Please read our November 24th posting regarding Preserve Vistoso's explanation of their activities.  The group asserts that their goal has always been to create a permanent conservation easement on the property. 

Monday, February 18, 2019

Guest View: Robert Peters ~ Cresta Morado General Plan Amendment and Rezoning Draws Ire From Neighboring Residents

Background
This 22-acre property at the NW corner of La Cholla and Tangerine is currently owned by Episcopal Church of the Apostles. Neighborhood meetings revealed that the church is having financial difficulties which has led to their decision to sell the land surrounding the church. The presenter, Brian Underwood of The Planning Center, stated, “We started this project because the Episcopal Church of the Apostles was in the hole.”

The General Plan Amendment is to change the land use from Public/Semi-Public to Medium Density Residential. The Rezoning request is to rezone from R1-144 (144,000 square foot lots) to R1-7 (7,000 sf lots).

The third Neighborhood Meeting for Cresta Morado was held on February 7th. There were approximately 40 attendees. I did not see any council members in attendance. However, Councilmember Rodman attended the first two neighborhood meetings in January and October 2018 and Vice-Mayor Barrett attended the first neighborhood meeting in January 2018 while a member of the Planning and Zoning Commission.

Town documents reveal the following concerns of adjacent neighbors:

• the request is not consistent with the vision, goals, and policies of the General Plan
• water issues -- nearby wells are declining
• 2-story homes will obstruct their current views of the Catalina Mountains
• light pollution impacting the existing rural character
• negative impact on wildlife
• they do not support any access via Como Drive
•7,000 sf lot sizes and 2-story homes are not compatible with the rural character of the surrounding area

The tension was palpable
When I walked into the Neighborhood Meeting, I could already feel the tension in the room. This “ambience” would soon deteriorate even further into skepticism and distrust for the presenter who apparently had nothing more in mind than to convince the crowd that this was the best deal that they could expect.

The presentation was given by The Planning Center. (Yes, for once it wasn’t The WLB Group). They, as all other planning groups do, glossed over the impact of this rezoning while patting themselves on the back for moving the recreation area to the west side of the property and reducing the number of lots from 54 to 47.

The discussion grew heated in a short amount of time. Some highlights are below:

• A resident asked why they had to go from the lowest density (R1-144) to the highest density (R1-7). The presenter advised that the builder (Richmond) would probably drop out if the lot sizes were any larger than that.

• A resident complained about the recreation area being moved to the west side of the property. This recreation area would now border the large lot homes on the west side. Surrounding residents want the recreation area located away from their homes.

• Why didn’t the church add this rezoning to the 2016 OV General Plan? The presenter advised that the property wasn't on anyone’s radar prior to 2016 and that the church’s financial problems arose after the 2016 General Plan was ratified.

• A homeowner stated that, “The church’s financial mistakes are not my problem.”

• The presenter advised that they don’t consider the homeowners group as a hostile element, to which one homeowner responded, “You can consider me a hostile element.”

• The discussion finally evolved into a look at zoning for the overall Tangerine/La Cholla area. One homeowner noted that it had been understood when they all purchased property in that area (some residents have lived there since the 1980’s) that the land north of Tangerine would always be zoned low-density and the land south of Tangerine was for medium and high density housing.

The transitional lot sizes and buffer zones are inadequate
This property is surrounded by very large rural lots (rural low density residential) including a 50-acre rural property immediately to the north of the proposed development. The “transitional” lot sizes adjacent to this 50-acre rural parcel are just half-acre lot sizes. This is hardly an adequate transition.

The north side of the property (abutting Limewood Drive) shows a buffer yard of just 10 feet plus a 30 foot conservation easement, for a grand total of 40 feet of buffer between a 50-acre rural lot and this medium density development.

The west side of the property (abutting Como Drive) shows a buffer yard of just 30 feet. Granted, this is double the 15 foot requirement but it’s still not nearly enough of a buffer to separate R1-144 zoning (minimum 3.3 acre lots) from R1-7 zoning (minimum 7,000 sf lots).

For comparison, during the 2015 “Capella” Major General Plan Amendment, neighbors living on large lots along Shannon Road (adjacent to the west side of Capella) negotiated a 200 foot natural desert buffer between their homes and the Capella medium density residential development.

Conceptual Site Plan


My opinion
This rezoning would set a dangerous precedent. We’ve all witnessed that after a rural low density area gets rezoned down to 7,000-10,000 sf lots, it sets the stage for all the undeveloped land surrounding that parcel to also be rezoned down to tiny mass graded lots (with 2-story homes and connecting walls). The developer uses the first rezoned parcel to claim that the parcel next to it should also be rezoned down to 7,000 sf lots in order to be “compatible” with the first parcel. And on and on it goes until there are no rural areas left, roads are widened to four lanes, traffic lights are installed, and the wildlife disappears.

It bothers me that one entity – one landowner, can disrupt so many lives with their development plan, especially in an area that was originally zoned for rural low density. The town has frequently given more consideration to one landowner than to all of the surrounding neighbors that these plans will affect. It isn’t right. But it’s done because greed takes precedence over way of life. It also happens because decision makers see Oro Valley as a building project rather than as a community. In this case, the community is rural residential with unspoiled desert surroundings and solitude.

Town Planner Michael Spaeth stated, “It’s the applicant’s job to demonstrate that what they’re proposing improves upon what’s there today.” Does anyone believe that this plan is an improvement?

The neighbors are justifiably upset.

Editor’s Note: This will most likely be the last Neighborhood Meeting. The proposal will be presented to the Planning & Zoning Commission for a vote. If approved by P&Z, it will be sent to the Town Council for the final vote.

---

Robert Peters is an Army veteran who served in Germany and South Korea. He has a Bachelor’s degree in Russian and Eastern European Studies and a Master’s degree in Business Management. He relocated from New England to Arizona in 2003 and was employed by Raytheon Missile Systems for 12 years, retiring in 2016 after 50 years in the workforce. He’s been active in dog rescue organizations for the past 20 years. He’s also an avid reader and history buff who has traveled extensively throughout the U.S., Europe and Russia. A former hippie, he attended the 1969 Woodstock Festival in Upstate New York.

Wednesday, June 13, 2018

Maximizing profits should not be the rationale for rezoning land in Oro Valley

Below is an excerpt from the speech given by Oro Valley resident, Michael Sanderson, during the May 16th Town Council Public Hearing on the Capella rezoning. Yesterday, we published the speech that Diana Sanderson gave the same evening. We’re publishing these speeches to show our readers that the current Town Council does not listen to the citizens, no matter how well-researched and well-presented those citizens’ speeches might be.

Mr. Sanderson’s Speech
We live in the Canada Hills area. My wife and I sent a letter to each of you at the first of the week. I assume you have taken the time to read it. In the letter, we listed the specific variances proposed in the rezoning for the Capella PAD that are unacceptable to a significant number of Oro Valley residents. We have been meeting with these residents for the last three months.

We, unfortunately, do not have time this evening to discuss each variance, as we did in the letter. Very briefly – they center on the following requests by the Developer:

• In the residential areas: to create dense single-family housing by reducing the size of the lots and placing the homes closer together, beyond existing town code.

• In the multi-family housing: to reduce the open areas surrounding the structures, again, beyond town code.

• In the commercial zone at the NW corner of Naranja and La Cholla: to expand the size of the buildings from the existing code of 5000-9,000 sq. feet to 20,000 sq. feet.

• In the commercial zone at Lambert and La Cholla: to have a super big-box store of 125,000 square feet, more than twice the size allowed by current code – and bigger than any single store in Oro Valley except the Walmart Supercenter at Oro Valley Marketplace.

• In both commercial zones: They are also requesting that commercial buildings in both areas be five feet higher than allowed by code.

The Zoning Code is intended to maintain the character and quality of the town by imposing development standards and to reduce adverse impacts on neighboring property owners. Unfortunately this proposed plan seeks variances that would allow the developer to degrade the character and quality of Oro Valley and have an increased adverse impact on neighbors.

Three of us met with the applicant in an attempt to understand the need for the zoning variances. We, absolutely, appreciate him taking the time to meet with us and provide detailed responses to our questions. Clearly we do not agree with the basis for the variance requests.

Our interpretation of the responses was that they were based on the need to build as many single-family homes, multi-family dwellings, and provide as much commercial square footage as possible to maximize the profits for the current landowners and prospective buyers. This should not be the rationale for rezoning land in Oro Valley.

We support the amendments proposed by the Planning and Zoning commission at their April 3 meeting and approved by a 6-0 vote.

In addition, there must be the 5 conditions that we listed in the letter we submitted to each of you. These conditions for approval of the Capella PAD rezoning have been thoughtfully researched and considered by our group of concerned Oro Valley citizens. We expect you to add these conditions to the amendments unanimously approved by the Planning and Zoning Commission. These combined conditions represent a reasonable compromise to allow this PAD to move forward.

This is your opportunity to demonstrate to the citizens of Oro Valley that you do listen to their concerns.

(Editor's Note:  The council did not listen.  They approved the rezoning with a unanimous 7-0 vote).

- - - - -

For reference, below are the amendments passed 6-0 by P&Z during the April 3rd meeting.

Planning & Zoning Amended Motion:

1. All future site plans for each parcel will go through the Conceptual Site Plan process to be considered by the Planning and Zoning Commission as well as Town Council for further review.

2. Complete an updated Traffic Analysis for each development phase required by Town Code.

3. Parcel M is restricted to 1-story height within 300 feet of the west property boundary.

4. The plans for restrooms and playgrounds in recreation areas must be maintained.

Below are the additional conditions that the Sanderson’s requested in their letter to the mayor and council:

1. All single family homes in the PAD shall meet the requirements of R1-7 zoning regarding minimum lot area, lot width, yard setbacks, and building height; except that the minimum lot area in Parcel H, for homes not located along Lambert Lane, can be 6600 square feet, per the Special Area Policies adopted in 2015.

2. Multi-family residential buildings in the PAD shall meet the requirements of R-7 zoning regarding outdoor open space and outdoor private living space.

3. All businesses in the C-N commercial zone at the NW corner of Naranja and La Cholla shall meet the current C-N zoning requirements for business floor area limits, building height and allowable use.

4. All businesses in the C-1 commercial zones shall meet the current C-1 zoning requirements for business floor area limits, building height and allowable use.

5. A traffic control “island” or curbing shall be placed at the Canada Hills Drive intersection to not allow through traffic to cross La Cholla. (The proposed design will not be sufficient to “not permit eastbound or westbound through-traffic across La Cholla Boulevard” as stated in the current proposal).

Tuesday, June 12, 2018

Analysis: The Town Council views the General Plan as nothing more than “a glossy advertising sales pitch.”

Town Council continues to ignore citizens in order to appease developers
Below is a speech given at the May 16th Town Council meeting by Oro Valley resident, Diana Sanderson, during the Public Hearing portion for the 200-acre Capella Rezoning. This is another example, in a long list of examples, of how, when it comes to development issues, the current Town Council will not listen to anything presented by an Oro Valley resident, even when the resident is citing the voter-approved General Plan in their argument. The rezoning passed by a 7-0 vote.

Ms. Sanderson’s Speech
Thank you for allowing me to speak tonight. I am an Oro Valley resident for almost 3 years. I appreciate my neighbors and community members voicing their concerns regarding the Capella Rezoning project. I want to speak to the entity that has no voice in any of this: The desert wildlife. I sense I am in the minority on this topic, but to me, it certainly doesn’t diminish the importance.

The Your Voice, Our Future General Plan does a very good job of convincing the general public of the following:

From Page 29: “Oro Valley’s exceptionally rich wildlife and vegetation are a big part of the region’s appeal. We cherish Oro Valley’s open space and strive to focus development in appropriate areas.” From Page 33, Policy SD.8: “Encourage development project designs that connect wildlife habitat areas, avoid disturbing significant wildlife habitats and minimize the overall impacts on wildlife habitat areas.”

Policy SD.9: “Provide for the safe movement of wildlife near man-made features which may potentially disconnect wildlife corridors.”

In all the Capella parcel designs offered, it’s difficult to determine exactly where these two policies were a consideration.

Blading of desert landscape does little to promote any of the policies outlined. It’s a fact that blading in the spring and summer months disturbs habitats and kills the young. Anyone that thinks animals move on when development begins is wrong. They simply die.

The Tucson Wildlife Center offers a free service to walk areas scheduled for blading before the process even begins. The purpose is to identify potential habitats of animals that could be safely relocated. They have yet to be engaged on any Tucson or surrounding area development projects. With respect to Mr. Oland [the applicant] and Mr. Spaeth [Town Planner] the 30% of open space that they are leaving in this development is land that cannot be built on.

We are stewards of this planet and should speak for those inhabitants that have no representation and are basically considered development collateral damage.

From Page 33, Policy SD.1: “Identify, preserve and manage an integrated and connected open space system that protects Oro Valley‘s natural resources and provides enjoyment for residents and visitors while recognizing our place in the larger ecosystem.”

That should be our goal, not a politically-correct marketing pitch.

It starts with us. Let’s make the policies in the Your Voice, Our Future General Plan a reality instead of a glossy advertising sales pitch.

. . . . .

Click HERE to read another example of an Oro Valley resident’s well-researched and well-prepared speech being dismissed by the current council. The agenda item on which she spoke, again citing non-conformity with the General Plan, also passed with a 7-0 vote.

Monday, April 16, 2018

Guest View: Diane Peters ~ Mayor Hiremath makes absurd comments during the April 4th council meeting

During the April 4th Town Council meeting, the council voted 7-0 (no surprise there) to rezone 85 acres of pristine desert on the west side of LaCholla between Glover and Naranja from R1-20 (minimum 20,000 square foot lots with custom grading) to R1-7 (minimum 7,000 sf lots with mass grading) to accommodate 178 single-family homes, including 2-story homes.

For some history, this parcel had already been rezoned from R1-144 to R1-20 in 2007 and a development plan for just 74 one-story homes on lot sizes ranging from 1/3 acre to 1.5 acres was already approved by the Town Council in 2014.

Below, Mayor Hiremath explains his “rationale” for why 7,000 square foot residential lots are better than 20,000 sf lots.

Hiremath: "If you have 20,000 square foot lots, there is no capacity or requirement for the homeowner on those large lots to leave it natural desert. Somebody could landscape it, somebody could wall it."

My Rebuttal: So in order to prevent the highly unlikely possibility that a homeowner would mass grade or wall in his 20,000 sf property (approx. ½ acre) or his 43,560 sf property (1 acre), Mayor Hiremath voted to allow a developer to mass grade 52 acres of an 85 acre property that will be all walled in when the development is completed!

1 acre = 43,560 square feet x 52 acres = 2,265,120 square feet!!!

Read that again…Hiremath prefers that the developer mass grade 2.2 million square feet in order to prevent the unlikely possibility of one person mass grading 20,000 square feet. That’s absurd!

How many homeowner’s in Oro Valley have mass graded their 20,000 square foot lot? How many have mass graded their 1 acre lot, their 1.5 acre lot, or their 3 acre lot? The mayor provided no statistics for his claim. I’ve lived in Oro Valley for 15 years and I haven’t seen this anywhere, so just how common is this practice?

It’s far more likely that people who buy homes on large lots do so because they prefer to be surrounded by lush desert vegetation and wildlife and they don’t want a view of their neighbor’s home. So why would they mass grade their property?

Below, Mayor Hiremath tries to convince everyone that mountain views are not important.

Hiremath: "Does every house in the town of Oro Valley have a mountain view?"

Planning Administrator, Bayer Vella: No, but many do.

Hiremath: "So is any house construction going to block the actual view of the mountain? I mean, do people in Oro Valley buy a house, do [sic] every person in Oro Valley buy a house because of the mountain views or is it because they actually like to live in a community at the base of a mountain and they get to enjoy the mountain on their walks, their bike rides, when they go shopping, when they come out of Fry’s, when they come out of Target?"

This is a leading question. He is clearly telling Bayer what he wants him to say.

Bayer: I think it’s the latter. It’s the package. It’s not just any one box amongst a list of many.

My Rebuttal: Hiremath lives on a 1.7 acre hilltop lot with mountain views. Are we to believe that the hilltop location with panoramic mountain views didn’t factor into his decision to purchase that home?

All one has to do is peruse the Oro Valley real estate listings to see that any house with a mountain view is listed as such in the ad. Why would real estate agents bother mentioning the mountain views if no one is interested in homes with mountain views? Obviously, mountain views are a big selling point!

Follow the money trail
So what’s the real reason that Mayor Hiremath (and the rest of the council) voted to rezone this parcel down to 7,000 square foot lots to accommodate 178 cluster homes? Perhaps it’s because the players in this deal (see below list) have donated more than $20,000 to the election campaigns of all 7 current council members and to Yes on 454 in support of the mayor and council’s 2017 pet project, the Naranja Park Bond. Some of these donations are outlined below:

2014-2017    Greg Wexler (land broker, Wexler & Associates) donated a total of $14,410
2017             Jeff Grobstein, President, Meritage Homes, donated $5,000
2017             William Walker, Owner, WLB Engineering, donated $1,000

But wait! There’s more!
Other council members also offered absurd justifications to defend their votes to rezone that property for cluster homes. Their comments and my rebuttals will be featured in upcoming LOVE articles. Stay tuned.

. . . . . . . . . .

Diane Peters has lived in Oro Valley since 2003, moving here to escape the humidity of the East Coast. She’s been involved in OV politics and development issues since 2006. In 2014, she organized a citizens group, Citizen Advocates of the Oro Valley General Plan, who over a 9-month period, successfully negotiated a controversial 200-acre development project. In her past life, she worked in medical research at various University Hospitals in New England. Her interests include reading, writing, nature photography, travel, art galleries, museums, and politics.

Monday, August 22, 2016

Guest View ~ Diane Peters: What you need to know about Bill Rodman


Bill Rodman is a former Oro Valley Planning & Zoning Commissioner (2012-2015) who is hoping to unseat one of the incumbents (Brendan Burns, Bill Garner, Mike Zinkin) on the Oro Valley Town Council. What does Bill Rodman bring to the table?


Rodman’s views on the golf course
When Rodman was asked by two local newspapers how he would handle the financial problems of the Community Center golf courses, he responded:
  • “Provide the oversight necessary to make sure that we’re analyzing it properly.” 
  • “If at some point the expenses continue to outstrip the revenues…the golf courses can be closed, partially closed, leased or sold to a third party, and/or made open space.”
Of note is that neither of these “solutions” are new. First of all, Councilmembers Burns, Garner, and Zinkin have been providing financial oversight since the golf courses opened in May 2015 only to be chastised by the Majority-4 for doing so.

Secondly, Councilmembers Burns, Garner, and Zinkin have already proposed closing or partially closing the golf courses, they’ve proposed leasing one course back to the Hilton (which is allowed per the existing contract), they’ve proposed looking for private entities to lease the other 18-hole course, and they’ve proposed turning one or more courses into a linear natural greenway/park. These are the exact same solutions that Rodman is now proposing.

Isn’t it interesting that the Majority-4 are endorsing Rodman when his “ideas” are to simply replicate what Burns-Garner-Zinkin have already been doing or suggesting all along?

Rodman also stated at the August 10th Candidate Forum that the council shouldn’t make any decisions on the golf courses because, “I believe there is a 5-year plan.” Is Rodman aware that Troon’s own forecast continues to show expected losses of $1.4 million dollars in year-five? Can we even trust that figure when the first year was expected to lose $1.5 million and it actually lost $2.4 million? That forecast was off by almost $1 million dollars!

Rodman’s voting record on Planning & Zoning
On Rodman’s Facebook page, he states: “I spent 4 years on Oro Valley’s Planning & Zoning Commission, serving as Chair, advising the town on how to manage growth and make good decisions.”

Below is a sample of the items that Bill Rodman approved while on P&Z. Is this your idea of managed growth and good decision making?

2015
  • Increased building heights at Linda Vista and Oracle (El Corredor) within the Oracle Rd. Scenic Corridor District (obstructing mountain views)
  • General Plan Amendment, ESL Amendment, and Rezoning for a 5-story retirement community (Nakoma Sky) on 79.5 acres at 1st Ave. and Naranja
  • Increased illuminated window signs for businesses
  • CUP for a Fry’s gas station at 1st Ave. and Oracle Rd.
2014
  • Rezoning of the 39-acre Olsen property from R1-144 to Planned Area Development
  • LaCholla Major rezoning, convert 45 acres from R1-144 to R1-7 at LaCholla and Naranja
  • Amended zoning code to allow property owners to grade right up to the adjacent property
  • Rezoning 149 acres at Tangerine and First Ave. from R1-144 to MDR and commercial
2013
  • CUP for U-Haul business at Ace Hardware on First and Tangerine
  • Rezoned NE corner of Tangerine and LaCholla from R1-144 to Commercial and NCO
  • Major General Plan Amendment of Olsen property from LDR and open space to MDR
  • Major General Plan Amendment of Miller Ranch from LDR to MDR
2012
  • Rezoned 13 acres at NE corner of Linda Vista and Oracle (El Corredor) to HDR (The Canyons Apts.) 
  • Major General Plan Amendment for NE corner Tangerine and LaCholla from LDR to NCO
Were these “good decisions?” Is this how you “manage growth?” By turning every remaining low density residential parcel into medium density or high density or commercial?

Summary
A vote for Rodman (as well as Pina and Solomon) will result in an abundance of 7-0 votes on council with no discussion or debate, no adherence to the voter-approved General Plan, more rezonings to appease greedy developers, and millions of dollars in continued golf losses.

Diane Peters
Oro Valley Resident

---
This article was submitted directly to us by Diane. She also submitted it to the Arizona Daily Independent where it was published last week. We publish it here to insure complete coverage of this election.
---

Monday, June 29, 2015

Meet Candidate Shirl Lamonna

Oro Valley resident Shirl Lamonna will be a candidate for Oro Valley council in the November election.  Lamonna is a 10 year resident and a friend of LOVE.

Lamonna is very knowledgeable of what is happening in Oro Valley She has been following Oro Valley events and participating in the "call the audience" portion of the Oro Valley council meetings. In addition, she is a frequent commenter on LOVE.

Shirl is also very knowledgeable of what is happening in Pima County. She is currently working as research assistant to Pima County Supervisor Ally Miller. "I have the experience and knowledge of government dealings. This will allow for a fast learning curve as I have already researched every type of agenda item for the supervisors meetings am already familiar with many of issues that will impact the residents of Oro Valley."

Lamonna is not new to Oro Valley politics. Together with Oro Valley resident Debra Arrett, she led an effort to seek a public vote on the towns purchase of the El Conquistador Country Club. Were it not for a clerical error that vote would have occurred.

She led the successful effort in 2011-12 to block a rezoning of a parcel known as "7-I". That parcel, located on the northwest corner of Tangerine and Rancho Vistoso Blvd, was scheduled to have been rezoned for apartments. Lamonna mobilized the neighbors and kept our community informed. Read her incisive analysis of the 7-I situation to get an insight into the exceptional fact-based quality of her work.

We asked Lamonna why she has decided to run for council.

"I moved to Oro Valley, like so many, because it was a suburban, small town. It didn't just have the feel of one. It was one. Instead, Councilmembers Hornat, Snider and Waters with the Mayor have given us almost 800 apartments, a doubling of our utility tax, an increase in our sales tax, a $31 million dollar plan for Naranja Park (including an amphitheater and event center) and numerous higher density rezonings. They have changed the entire “dynamic” of life in Oro Valley."

Lamonna continued: "I’ve attempted to change the direction of this Council by using the tools available to citizens – heading opposition to the apartments as previously mentioned, attending Planning and Zoning sessions, speaking at Council meetings, and finally heading up the T.O.O.T.H. Referendum Committee. Nothing has worked. So now it’s time for me to step up to help shift us towards fiscal responsibility, transparency and sensible development."

We asked Shirl what she will bring to council that the current incumbents don't.

"I am an independent thinker who will research and analyze every issue before making a decision. I am running for YOU – to ensure your voice is heard."

Friday, August 1, 2014

Bits and Pieces


Solomon For The Incumbents

Former Oro Valley Appointed Council Member Steve Solomon was soundly defeated in the 2012 election by the minority-3.  Solomon had been appointed to council by Majority-4.  Tuesday, Solomon sent an email to his mailing list endorsing the Majority-4.
---

You Did "Request" An Early Ballot, Right?

Ballots went out yesterday. You should be getting your's very shortly assuming that you did ask for one. (see right panel)

Nearly 16,000 Independents in Pima County have requested early ballots. This is a record, acceding to the recorder's office. (Source)  This is not surprising to us given that the State of Arizona (foolishly) required no chartered cities, like Oro Valley, to mix partisan primaries with non partisan elections, like the Oro Valley Mayoral and Council elections.
---
Roseanne Roseannadana
"Its So Funny I Forgot To Laugh"

The Arizona Daily Star's uber-liberal cartoonist David Fitzpatrick likes to poke fun at Oro Valley:

"Oro Valley. 10,000 Seniors, 3 Safeways, and a speed trap. Oro Valley needs the speed trap. The ticket revenues fund the Viagra Overdose Hotline."

"Oro Valley. It’s so new. The only thing built in the last century are the residents. And they’re constantly having to repair their plumbing."

"Oro Valley. Oro is spanish for gold. Where’s the gold? All 327 Urology clinics."

And how about this knee-slapper:

"Oro Valley is a gold mine for traffic cops. The number one excuse? “I’m late for my colonoscopy.” The number two excuse? “Number two.” I’ll give the motorcycle cops credit. They’ve learned to write tickets fast. (Source)

Obviously, "Fitz" has a fixation with human plumbing!

As Roseanne Roseannadana (Gildner Rander of SNL) use to say: "It's so funny I forgot to laugh."
---
High Visibility Enforcement (HiVE) August Deployments - Oracle Road at Magee and Suffolk

ORO VALLEY, Ariz. (July 28, 2014) - The Oro Valley Police Department (OVPD) will continue with its High Visibility Enforcement (HiVE) efforts during the month of August on Oracle Road at the Magee and Suffolk intersections. OVPD hopes to increase awareness and reduce collisions related to inattention, following too closely and failing to yield to other drivers. The Pima County Sheriff's Department (PCSD) will continue to participate and support the education/enforcement efforts.

OVPD and PCSD will deploy motorcycle officers on the following dates:
  • Aug. 7, 2014:   7 - 10 a.m. 
  • Aug. 12, 2014: 4 - 7 p.m. 
  • Aug. 19, 2014: 7 - 10 a.m. 
  • Aug. 21, 2014: 4 - 7 p.m. 
  • Aug. 27, 2014: 4 - 7 p.m.
Motorists are asked to be aware of the additional enforcement activity and drive safely.
(Source: Oro Valley Police Department)
---
8.62 Acres For A Cool $2.4 Million

Do you have your checkbook ready?

The Southwest Corner of Linda Vista and Oracle is for sale for $2.4 million, $356,000 per acre.  The land is across from the GFRD station. "Also can be sold with adjacent parcel of 5.51 acres located at the SW Corner of Linda Vista and Oracle Rd". (source with pictures)
---
"UPDATE: Melissa Ann Gordy sentenced for sexual exploitation of a minor


A Real Sweetheart, This One
ORO VALLEY, Ariz. (July 29, 2014) - On July 28, 2014, Melissa Ann Gordy, 44 years old, was sentenced for crimes that occurred in Oro Valley beginning in March 2012. Gordy accepted a plea agreement and was sentenced to 40 years in prison and a lifetime of probation for the following crimes: Two counts of sexual exploitation of a minor under the age of 15 (Class 2 felony); One count of sexual exploitation of a minor under fifteen in 2nd degree. (Class 3 felony)."

In 2012, "the grand jury indicted Melissa Gordy on the following charges: 11 counts of sexual exploitation of a minor under the age of 15 (class 2 felony); child abuse (class 4 felony) and one count of evidence tampering (class 6 felony). " (Source: Oro Valley Police Department; KGUN 9)
---

Tuesday, June 12, 2012

Guest View-Shirl Lamonna: Mixed Use's "Trojan Horse"

---
The following are remarks delivered before the Oro Valley Town Council on June 6. The remarks were made in response to item 3 on the agenda. The objective of that item was to make it easier to make amendments to the general plan.  Under this item, many more land parcels would be subject to minor and not major general plan amendment criteria.  A minor amendment requires a 4 vote council majority. A major amendment requires a 5 vote council majority.

Several residents spoke against this measure, including John Musolf and Bill Adler.  Shirl Lamonna delivered the following remarks:
---
We’re all familiar with the story of how the Greeks built a large wooden horse, hid their soldiers inside of it. When the horse was dragged into Troy, the soldiers crept out and conquered the city.  There are changes before council that would simplify changes to the General Plan and Zoning Code.  These changes would make it easier to make amendments to the general plan, by raising the threshold for defining a major plan amendment from 5 to 20 acres.

Such a change is a Trojan horse for "Mixed Use" in Oro Valley.

In deference to the new council members, let’s review how we got here.  As you may know, in 2003 the Council tried to pass a General Plan that included a designated land us of "Mixed Use" despite numerous public hearings where residents objected. That plan was soundly rejected by the voters.  A new plan was not approved until all references to Mixed Use were removed.  

Fast forward to 2011:

I’m sure you all remember the controversy over the proposed apartments on parcel 7-I; the applicant attorney’s desire for an alternate approach to secure the rezoning.  Miraculously, a few weeks later, the Zoning Commission held their first meeting to make changes to the major and minor amendment process to add a Mixed Land Use element to the General Plan. 

A number of Oro Valley residents spoke in opposition that nite.

The Zoning Commission asked Town Staff to secure public input and to address several of their concerns.  We discussed Mixed Use and general plan amendments at 3 of the 4 subsequent Community Outreach meetings.  Panelists were recruited from Phoenix and Flagstaff to tout the benefits of Mixed Use. In my opinion, no one who was originally opposed was convinced that Mixed Use was needed or would be good for Oro Valley. 

The Urban Land Institute’s Handbook on Mixed Use was recommended reading at our first outreach meeting.  It states: “It should never be assumed that a mixed-use concept will lead to greater financial returns or a better urban environment.  Mixed use developments can be failures on either or both counts just as easily as other projects.”

Other recent research shows that mixed use development doesn’t always solve the problems that planners and developers hope it will solve.  For example: high density mixed use development and lower levels of automobile use are not always linked.  Parking can be an issue.  Retail space often remains vacant.  Even Ross Rulney [a developer], when given an option to wait for Mixed Use several weeks ago, declined and chose to stick with only his apartment plans [Northeast Corner of Oracle and Linda Vista].

Oro Valley is not Urban. We do not have the climate, population density, universities, young professionals or public transportation that might make a mixed use concept feasible elsewhere.  Why until today, we didn’t even know how many vacant parcels were in the town or their acreage.  Now we know that changing the acreage threshold to 20 acres leaves only 36 vacant parcels out of 211 (17%) to be reviewed as a Major Amendment. If these changes go thru, most rezoning applications will be approved. Make no mistake: the intent of these revisions is to add mixed use - to get these projects approved quickly and to stifle input from a community that is opposed to it.

I will close with a quote from Sunday’s Arizona Daily Star titled: "Tucson Mayor and Council Disregard Constituents’ Desires": “Somehow the current Mayor and Council view governance as a process that suspends the concepts of representing the interests of the entire community …  The arrogance needs to end.”

A vote to approve the amendments to the Zoning Code and the General Plan is a vote against the citizens of Oro Valley.  Let’s keep representative government in our town and let voters decide on these issues with the next General Plan update.

Leave this Trojan Horse outside the gate.  
---

Monday, April 2, 2012

"Mixed Use Neighborhoods" mean APARTMENTS

---
Friday, John Musolf contributed a very detailed, considered piece defining what he thinks is meant by MUN.

As one of our bloggers noted in an email to me:

MUN "...would allow developers to apply for rezoning to allow multiple uses on their land.  For example, they could have commercial and apartments/condos on the same parcel.  This would be like the apartments sandwiched between the gated community of homes and the Big Five Sporting Goods/Noble Hops strip center at La Canada & Lambert."

So, what does MUN mean?  Given we have heard to date, one word keeps coming up when it comes to MUN:  Apartments.

A few months ago, the Oro Valley Development and Infrastructure Department and the Developer stated, at a  public hearing on Rancho Vistoso Pad 7-I, that there is very little land in Oro Valley zoned for multi-family residential, Apartments.   They both felt that more land was needed.   Perhaps that is why they supported the general plan amendment that would have allowed apartments on 7-I.  Perhaps that is why the Oro Valley Planning and Zoning Commission recommended this change.

At each public hearing the the Oro Valley Development and Infrastructure Department has conducted on  Mixed Use, every mixed used development example provided includes Apartments.

This quote is from a highly reliable source: "It is the intent to make Mixed Use part of a General Plan update - along with other issues - this year."

If a Mixed Use Zoning designation is approved by this Oro Valley Town Council, you should expect to see many requests put forth to rezone properties for mixed use, since mixed used gives developers much more flexibility regarding what can be built on a property: Like apartments.

This designation, once placed on a property, will also make it much more difficult for residents to oppose apartments if they don't want them since the zoning code mixed use will already include a permission to build apartments.

In other words, one never knows what will actually be built on a property once the mixed use designation is placed on the property.  Who knows what property 7-I or the Ford Property in Rancho Vistoso would have become if it had been designated under this MUN code.  

The mixed use zoning designation was rejected by the Oro Valley voters in approving the 2005 General Plan.  So, if the Oro Valley Town Council moves to approve such a designation, they are going directly against the will of the people.

Thing is: Adding this zoning designation to the Oro Valley codes is a major, not a minor change to the General Plan. Therefore, shouldn't it be for the people, not the council, to make this change? That would occur, if approved, in the 2015 General Plan.
---


Friday, March 30, 2012

Guest View-John Musolf: Mixed Use Neighborhood ("MUN") is Not Mixed Use

---
There is confusion between what the Oro Valley Development and Infrastructure Department terms Mixed Use Neighborhood (MUN) and Mixed Use (MU).

Having attending the Oro Valley Development and Infrastructure Department's informational meetings on "Mixed Use"and having studied the accepted meaning of "Mixed Use," I have concluded that Oro Valley is talking about something quite different than the generally stated definition of "Mixed Use".

Why is knowing the difference between these two terms important?  It is important because, at some point in the near future, the Oro Valley Town Council will be asked by the Oro Valley Development and Infrastructure Department,  as approved by the Planning and Zoning Commission, to vote a General Plan Amendment to add this zoning code. It is important because they will vote on this without a proper, clear definition of what it is.

Mixed Use Neighborhood

On December 7, 2011 at the Town Council Regular Meeting, Agenda Item 6, there was a Public Hearing where Resolution 11-82 was passed by Council amending the General Plan. This General Plan Amendment  applied to a property of 20 acres. The amendment split the parcel into two different zoning uses:
  • The amendment changed the land use category from Neighborhood Commercial-Office (NCO) to High Density Residential (HDR) for 13 acres located in the rear of the property in proximity to the northeast corner of Linda Vista Blvd. and Oracle Rd, for the purpose of building an apartment complex of approximately 215-220 units. 
  • The 7 acres fronting Oracle Road remained Commercial and 5 buildings were proposed to house restaurants, cleaners, and other retail or commercial use. 
Thus, the property would now have two separate uses approved for it.  This is what is called segregated land used on one parcel.  It is not what one would call "Mixed Use" as generally defined.

Please, read on.

Mixed Use

On January 3, 2012 the Oro ValleyPlanning and Zoning Commission approved what they called a Minor General Plan Amendment to add a Mixed Use (MU) land use category to the General Plan (OV1111-006).  The General Plan does not include a category which allows a mixture of land uses on one property. This was a generic proposal since no applicant or property was involved in this item. Some of the citizens in the audience felt they needed further definition on Mixed Use

The Oro Valley Development and Infrastructure Department has offered several outreach educational programs on mixed use.  A definition sheet was handed out at the first outreach program on January 31, 2012 on Mixed Use. The first paragraph offers this explanation: This designation denotes areas wherein a range of land uses are planned as an integrated development.

"The mixed use designation is intended for residential, commercial, office and employment uses, creatively designed based on new urbanism principles. Such areas should be reflective of a village concept wherein there is an opportunity for residents to live, work and recreate within the same neighborhood."

On Tuesday, March 27, 2012 at the third Oro Valley Development and Infrastructure Department outreach program, a panel discussion was held with Roger Eastman (Flagstaff Planning), Don Keith (Phoenix Community Planning) and Ross Rulney (Tucson Developer) on the subject of mixed use. All three gentlemen discussed mixed use that matched very closely to the explanation on the definition sheet handed out at the first outreach program on January 31, 2012. “Such areas should be reflective of a village concept wherein there is an opportunity for residents to live, work and recreate within the same neighborhood”.

Mixed Use Neighborhood v. Mixed Use

The keyword constantly referred to in discussing mixed use is integration of many uses on the same property.  It is the building of a village that is self-sustaining.

The Linda Vista and Oracle facility is an example of what the Oro Valley Development and Infrastructure Department is talking about.  It is, by no means, integrated.  The 200 plus residents will not work in the "neighboorhood." Like everyone else in Oro Valley, they'll drive to work somewhere.  Their children will not go to school in the "neighborhood." They will be bussed, like many others in Oro Valley.

Mixed Use, as the town is educating us, is about building a complete village for "residents to live, work and recreate within the same neighborhood".   On paper, in theory, this sounds like an appealing concept. In reality, though, this is not what Oro Valley Development and Infrastructure Department is talking about.

When the Oro Valley Development and Infrastructure Department says Mixed Use they are talking about multiple zoning uses on one parcel, a concept the voters rejected when they finally approve the 2005 General Plan.

Splitting parcels to make them usable for multiple zoning purposes does not create a village.  It simply creates a "hodge-podge" of uses on one parcel.
---

Wednesday, January 18, 2012

Guest View: Mary LaSala Traffic, Neighborhood 7 and Parcel 7-I

---
[Our neighbors have labored diligently to uncover and develop factual information relevant to the now "defunct" PAD Amendment on property F-I.  One such effort is presented here. It is a very detailed, thorough study of the traffic impact of apartments on this property. This study was sent to every Oro Valley Town Council member on January 17, 2012]
---

Dear Council Member:

Please find attached a traffic report with information and traffic volume projections for the Rancho Vistoso roadway which will be most impacted by the proposed apartment complex at Parcel 7-I.

This report was prepared by a group of Rancho Vistoso neighbors who conducted research and traffic observations over the last two months.

Our projections indicate that the proposed apartment complex will have the effect of adding at least 10% more traffic volume to an already congested area.

Our intent is to respectfully request that you consider our recommendation to not vote for a rezoning of Parcel 7-I which would permit construction of the proposed apartment complex.

Thank you for your consideration.

All the best,
M. LaSala

---

Guest View-Shirl Lamonna: Your 7-I Guide


Tonight, the Oro Valley Town Council will not discuss item number 3; a request to amend the  Rancho Vistoso PAD Amendment for Parcel 7-I. It has been pulled from the agenda. The request has been withdrawn. The request was to amend the PAD to allow apartments. The town's Development Infrastructure Services Department and the town's Planning and Zoning Commission approved this request.The residents of the adjacent community were 100% opposed to it.

The following "Guest View" was prepared prior to the withdrawal. We felt that we should publish it anyway because we don't think that the "issue" of requests to change the use of this property will ever be settled until it is built upon.
---
On January 12th, approximately 50 to 75 Oro Valley homeowners attended the Venture West informational meeting at Town Hall concerning the proposed apartment development on Parcel 7-I.    

Fred Steiniger, one of the Venture West partners, persisted in a presentation - from a developer’s perspective – of why apartments are a more desirable option than unknown commercial development. 

Concerns were addressed as follows:

Why not build apartments on parcels already zoned for HDR? - “Just because a parcel is zoned for apartments, does not mean it’s a good location for them.”  But from a homeowner’s perspective: sometimes legitimate businesses are simply not appropriate use of a given parcel of land  – as in this case where the apartments would be located in close proximity to single family homes and situated on the scenic Tangerine Road corridor.

Steiniger cited data provided by OV Planning & Zoning staff: Oro Valley currently has 11.8% of its housing stock as multifamily while that number is 33.4% in Scottsdale.  Using the same US Census Bureau source, one will find vast differences in several other key factors that apparently were not analyzed:


ORO VALLEY
SCOTTSDALE
POPULATION
41,011
217,385
# BUSINESS FIRMS
4,180
37,104

Perhaps Scottsdale’s greater need for apartments relates to a larger population & the higher volume of businesses that are 5.3 and 8.9 times greater (respectively) than that of Oro Valley??    

What about the increased traffic?  – Venture West proposed the apartments would be gated with an ADOT approved single entrance/exit onto Tangerine Road.   A bridge would be constructed over the protected wash area with a second exit (right turn only) onto Rancho Vistoso Blvd.  This would necessitate a traffic light on Rancho Vistoso Blvd in close proximity to the current one at the Tangerine Rd intersection.  One can only imagine the congestion that would be created when 200 or more apartment tenants began to exit for their morning commute!  Woodburne would not be impacted until the commercial section of 7-I was developed.  Wait!  Apartments and commercial on 7-I?  Wouldn’t that make this a Mixed Use parcel?  Didn’t the Zoning commission just vote in favor of a General Plan Amendment that will go before the Town Council for review?

Will the apartments overload schools? – The assistant superintendent of Amphi School District assured Michael Carlier, Venture West’s Broker, that elementary students living at the apartments would be provided with bus service directly to Copper Creek Elementary.  Therefore, the Painted Sky Elementary (with 32+ students in some classrooms) would not be overcrowded.  Both Carlier & Steiniger appeared surprised to learn that this solution may not be effective due to a 1994 Arizona state law that allows students to apply for admission to any public school, based on available classroom space.

Venture West made several attempts to enlist community members for committees designed to assist them in mitigating neighborhood concerns.   They asked to “reset the clock” and to have homeowners negotiate with HSL so that they could approach Town Council together on the 18th for another continuance.  This fell flat with the homeowners in attendance who were largely unresponsive to the pleas while united in their opposition to rezoning.

At the end of the night, it was apparent that the homeowners were firm in their conviction that apartments are not a good fit for 7-I; that the parcel should remain C-1 Neighborhood Commercial which will ultimately provide valuable community services. 

Of interest: Town Council came to the same conclusion in 2004 when they denied WLB Group’s request, on behalf of Vistoso Partners, to amend the 1996 General Plan to change a 14 acre portion of Parcel 7-I from Community Commercial to Medium High Density Residential.  Yet with the 2011 application, the Zoning Commission approved WLB/Venture West’s request for a PAD Text Amendment/Special Policy to clarify that apartments were already allowed?  Shouldn’t Staff & the Zoning Commission have reviewed past history and considered their “clarification” logic could be faulty?  Shouldn’t they have consulted with Legal Counsel prior to moving forward with this application? 
   
It is regrettable that a quality real estate developer such as Venture West – who has brought some good projects to our community – was so ill advised by Town Zoning Staff who neither understood the existing zoning laws nor grasped the pulse of the community earlier in the planning stages. 

The January 18th Town Council meeting should prove interesting.  See you all at 6 pm in Town Council Chambers.    

Shirl Lamonna
January 16, 2012 
---      

Monday, January 2, 2012

Do Carlier and Venture West Run Oro Valley?

---
Michael Carlier of Carlier and Company and Venture West now run Oro Valley.

" I hope that you can attend the meeting Venture West has established on January 12th at 6pm in the Council Chambers."

This quote is from an email Carlier sent one of the residents of Neighborhood 7; a resident who opposes a PAD Amendment to allow apartments on parcel 7-i.

Can anyone set up a meeting to use town council chambers?

There is little doubt that the Oro Valley Economic Development Department ("Planning and Zoning Department"), the Mayor, and Council Members Waters, Hornat, Snider and appointed Council Member and now 2012 council candidate Solomon are giving Carlier and Venture West every opportunity to subvert the will of the people.

First. they allow an unprecedented delay in a public hearing before council on Parcel F-1.  Then, they continually question Town Council Rosen about other ways to approve this PAD amendment without a super majority requirement.  At meetings, they allow developers to talk for hours about what is intended to be built when there is no such decision to be made.

Yes. We do not trust this council.

Nor do the people.
---

Monday, November 28, 2011

Guest View-Don Cox: Reflections

---
In recent weeks there have been several General Plan amendments brought forward for consideration by the Town Council. The public has been invited to provide input on at least four occasions for each amendment. State law requires that two formal public hearings be held at two separate locations for each amendment. Town code requires that at least two neighborhood meetings be held in addition to the formal hearings. I attended at least one of the neighborhood meetings in each instance as well as both Planning and Zoning Commission meetings.

At many of the meetings I heard a few common issues brought forward that relate specifically to the General Plan and I wanted to make an attempt to clarify how the Plan guided me in making my decisions.

Other than the language contained in the first paragraph on page 13, there is no weighting system outlined in the plan. In other words no single word, phrase or section carries any more weight than any other. It is a document that is purposefully left open for a certain amount of self-interpretation and weighting. And it is in those self-interpretations that many time people differ in their opinion.

There was an oft repeated comment that the General Plan was a document that was voted on by the citizens of Oro Valley and individual citizens should not have the right to change what the citizens voted for. However beginning on page 10 of the plan are specific guidelines on how the plan can be changed and whether the change is considered a major or minor change. These provisions were also approved by the citizens. It is my opinion that this section is a blessing. I can’t imagine having to deal with a document that was created in 2004/5 that did not allow for us to have the latitude necessary to soundly operate in the financial conditions we are experiencing in 2011/2.

A second opinion offered at many of the public meetings was that there is no provision in the General Plan for large scale apartment developments and therefore their construction would be a violation of the plan. Element 7, “HOUSING”, begins on page 59. I find two statements within this section that do support large scale apartment developments. The first is under the paragraph titled, “GROWING SMARTER/PLUS REQUIREMENTS”. In this paragraph it states that the plan should be “Designed to make equal provision for the housing needs of all segments of the community regardless of race, color, creed or economic level". Later on the same page under the title, “RANGE OF HOUSING OPPORTUNITIES”, we are presented with the following: “Over a person’s lifetime, a broad range of housing types will be required, ranging from entry-level rental…..”. I interpret “entry-level rental” as apartments.

I found through the course of my study and while listening to all who presented verbal and written input that all of the proposed amendments substantially met all of the change requirements. My only objection to the change on the parcel located at Rancho Vistoso and Vistoso Commerce Loop was that it took away a significant section of property in a corridor that I view as having far more ‘commercial/light industry’ value to the Town than would a residential use.
---

Sunday, November 27, 2011

You Be The Judge

---
One of the things that our friend Art kept driving home before he "retired from active blog posting" was that the 2010 elected members to the Oro Valley Town Council were financially supported by special interest groups.  Our definition of that is any group that can seek financial gain from the decisions of Council.

The special interests to which we refer are those in the Land, Development and Construction industries; but there are others.

We have not wanted to be precipitous in our judgement of the influence of special interests on any council member; so we have, for the past 17 months, "steered-clear" of drawing or publishing any such judgement.

One way to assess "influence" is to review the political contributions to the campaigns of the then mayoral or Council Members.  So, we have (painstakingly) gathered this information for you to see.  It is located on a new tab on or blog, near the top entitled: "2010 Campaign Contributions."

We want you to be the  judge of whether or not special interests have an influence.

Here's something for you to do.

Take a currently-pending decision, such as the requested General Plan Amendment request for parcel 7-I.  List the interested parties.  Then, look at the information provided in the "2010 Campaign Contributions" tab.  Did any individuals from any of the interested parties (Venture West, Vistoso Partners) make contributions to candidates? If so, which candidates?  Ask: Is it possible the highly unusual Town Council action of delaying a decision on property 7-I have anything to do with this influence?

So, please, do a little homework.

You be the judge.
---

Saturday, November 19, 2011

The Skinny On The 7-I "The 60 Day Hold"

---
Wednesday evening, the Oro Valley Town Council agreed to defer discussion of the General Plan Amendment for parcel 7-I for 60 days. This delay is based on a request from the Developer.

We are not privvy to the Developer's strategy but here is our guess:  Their strategy for getting the approval of Town Council is to get the vote for this measure to be a simple majority of four votes and not a super majority of five votes, as Town Attorney Tobin Rosen has advised them.

Why is this important?

We think that there are four solid "yes" votes for this Amendment: Mayor Hiermath, Joe Hornat, Lou Waters, and Mary Snider. As we will subsequently post, each is beholden to the special interests that contributed to their campaigns.

So, this Amendment will pass based on a simple majority.

But a super majority will require one  more vote. And we don't think it is there.  Citizen-centric council members Bill Garner and Barry Gillaspie will never vote for this Amendment as long as the residents oppose it.

That leaves the vote of Steve Solomon.  For political reasons, we don't think that this appointed council member will vote for this Amendment.  His council seat is up for election. He is running for election to Council this spring.  If he votes for this measure he will most certainly lose that election.

What will the Developer do with the 60 day continuance?

1.  Try to convince the residents who live nearest to the property to withdraw their protests. If they can get a sufficient number to rescind, then there will be no need for a super-majority approval by town council.

"Oland and Carlier have been going door to door on the streets across from 7-I asking homeowners to withdraw their protests."

They are not presenting the documents that were included in the packet the town discussed on Wednesday. Nor are they being truthful regarding the fact that this property can be built with access to Woodburne. So, residents, beware of the slick talkers.

2. Have their "big name" attorneys find a loophole somewhere in the PAD such that the council can interpret the request to be an interpretation of the PAD and not an amendment. 

If either of these eventualities occur, then you will see Apartments on 7-I.
---