Showing posts sorted by date for query 454. Sort by relevance Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by date for query 454. Sort by relevance Show all posts

Tuesday, January 19, 2021

Naranja Park... Building Over Time... Meeting Resident Needs

Naranja Park: A long time in coming
The Oro Valley Town Council approved a plan to develop Naranja Park on November 6, 2013.  This happened after eleven years of wrangling on the part of six town councils and hundreds of residents and non residents on what to put there.

The goal was always to build a regional park out of the 213 acre site: A former crushed rock, sand, gravel, hot-mix asphalt, and ready-mixed concrete facility owned by CalMat.  The town acquired the land in purchases in 1996 and 2000. (Source: 11-7-2017 Town of Oro Valley press release)

There had been thirteen years of thoroughly vetted and eventually rejected grandiose master plans. The amounts of $154 million and $48.6 million were bandied about to pay for what was proposed.  The voters rejected a $48.6 million bond in 2008. The idea of what to put there lay in wait. The, in 2012,  the town opened the archery range that is visible from Naranja. 

In 2013, the town council agreed to move forward with a "pay as you go" plan of $2.3 million.  The town was to bring utilities to the site and to construct: A dog park(1.1 acres) with separate areas/entrances for small and large dogs with a grass interior with dirt perimeter and a ramada in each area; two multi-sport (300' x 200' each) with turf borders and lighting; and a chip-sealed, striped and lit parking lot.

Groundbreaking was on November 27, 2014.  It was a start. Finally, an industrial eyesore was going to be something beautiful.

Then, in 2017, the town got off track again... asking residents to approve a property tax to pay for a bond of $17 million ($28 million in total cash flow) to fund ball fields at Naranja Park.  70% of the residents rejected it. Read more on that here.

  Naranja Park: Its come a long way
Today, Naranja Park has four multi-purpose (soccer) lighted fields, two dog parks, the archery range and a newly opened kids play area.  The play are features a climbing tower and rope climb (both pictured at left), zip lines, a ramada, picnic tables and seating areas. 

There is also a grass centerpiece which, unfortunately, looks like it needs some work as it is quite lumpy. The town has added paved roads and pave parking lots.  It's a work in progress.

Naranja Park: Building it the right way
Naranja Park is being created over many years, involving today's generations in what will be their park, rather than being built at one time based on the wants of one specific generation.

There's a difference in results. Look at the plans in the panel that follows (click to enlarge) These are what what has been proposed over the years.

Imagine if the town built the Naranja Park that was dreamed in 2001. There would be no soccer fields. Instead, there would be baseball and softball fields, fields that are now nicely provided at Kreigh Park. There would be no dog park. There would be no archery range.  

Imagine if it had built what was imagined in 2007. There would be a community center and tennis courts, both of which were opportunistically purchased by the town when it bought the El Conquistador golf courses in 2015.  

The 2015 plan is different from what the town proposed in Prop 454.

And , if the town had moved in any of these directions, it would have been saddled residents with significant bond debt that would last yet another twenty years from now.  Instead, the town has taken a steadier approach, incurring no debt.

Let's hope that the town stays the course because things are shaping up nicely.
---
Visit the town site to learn more about Naranja Park.

Thursday, February 21, 2019

Does the Town care about Town Policies?

Oro Valley has adopted 11 Town Policies (Policy 1 was rescinded in 2005) but one might wonder if anybody at the Town cares about them or is even aware of them. Examples of three of these policies being violated or ignored are discussed below.

Town Policy 2 ~ Council/Staff Relationships
“The Council should give instructions to the Town’s staff in a manner according to the principles of the council/manager system. For example, assignments should be directed to the Town Manager and should originate from a consensus directive of the Council, not with individual council members. Council members should contact staff directly ONLY when the purpose is to communicate information; e.g. to report conditions, describe a problem, or request information. Council members SHOULD NOT contact staff with special project requests or utilize large blocks of staff time in order to pursue individual areas of interest.”

Potential violation: According to the Executive Summary on the February 20th council agenda, the town’s Legal Services Director, at the request of council members Rodman and Pina, undertook a review of the Animal Control Ordinance. This appears to be a violation of Policy 2 since two council members do not represent a consensus (a minimum 4-3 vote of the council).

The Town’s Legal Director does not work for the Council, he works for the Town Manager. If the Executive Summary is correct, why didn’t the Legal Services Director refer Councilmembers Rodman and Pina to Policy 2?

Town Policy 6 ~ Unbudgeted Expenditures
“All requests for expenditures not budgeted for in the Town’s budget, shall be forwarded to the Town Manager. Upon review, the Town Manager will forward said request(s) to the Town Council for approval. It shall be the decision, by way of a majority vote of the council, to either approve or disapprove said requests for expenditures.”

Potential violation: A few months ago, Town Manager, Mary Jacobs, chose to extend the Troon contract an additional six months (from June 2019 to December 2019). This extension is not budgeted due to the fact that the current budget runs out on June 30, 2019. The policy mandates the Town Manager to take the unbudgeted request to the Council. To date this has not been accomplished. Is the current Council mandated to approve this 6-month extension of the Troon contract in the upcoming budget?

Town Policy 9 ~ Council Liaison to Amphitheater School District Governing Board
Among other things, “The Council Member Liaison will meet quarterly with the Town Manager, the Amphitheater School District Superintendent, and President of the Amphitheater Board to discuss subjects of mutual interest, such as establish Intergovernmental Agreements if needed; promote joint-use facilities when possible…”

With the recent failure of Prop 454 (the proposed property tax to fund improvements at Naranja Park), do you think the previous Council liaison (former Councilmember Mary Snider) ever met with the above individuals to discuss the possibility of utilizing Amphi playgrounds during the summer months to expand the town’s playgrounds availability?

Awareness is key
One would think that all new Council members would be briefed by staff as to the Council policies. However, after observing the Town Manager violation of Policy 6 and the possible Councilmember violation of Policy 2, one wonders if anyone in staff is even aware of these policies.

Wednesday, October 17, 2018

Guest View: Mike Zinkin ~ The mayor’s Halloween “trick”

The Council meeting on September 19, 2018 included another amendment to the General Plan.
“Discussion and possible action regarding an amendment to the General Plan future Land Use Map from Commerce/Office Park (COP) to Medium Density Residential (MDR) for a 15-acre property located at the northwest corner of Rancho Vistoso Blvd. and Vistoso Commerce Loop."
It was six weeks before Halloween but the mayor was already wearing his disguise
During the discussions, Mayor Hiremath erroneously educated the members of the council that this was not an amendment, but, rather, an option that would add MDR to the current land use of COP.

Mayor Hiremath stated:
"I want to make it clear to this council that the General Plan Amendment request that's being asked today is NOT to put up residential but is to offer ANOTHER POTENTIAL USE...This gives the new council flexibility...It's going to be up to them whether they want to have that flexibility to choose residential…or to let it remain tech park...If the future council decides that they don't want to go residential, then too bad, it just has to remain tech park. However I think this council owes it to the next council to afford as much flexibility on all the available properties left."
A blatant misrepresentation on the part of the mayor
The facts were revealed in a follow-up communication between an Oro Valley resident and the Planning and Zoning Administrator who described exactly what the council voted to approve that night:
“Town Council formally changed the General Plan designation to Medium Density Residential…By code and state law, a rezoning must be in compliance with the General Plan designation. So a presumption to favor approval of a residential rezoning has been established.”
As you can see, this was not an option for a potential use. This was a land use designation change from COP to MDR. The only option for the incoming council to decide is what form of residential will be allowed on this property.

Mayor Hiremath was his usual disingenuous and deceitful self. He had no regard, as usual, for the People’s input into the General Plan and was likely communicating for the applicant and campaign donor, Rodger Ford of Anthem Equity Group, who donated a total of over $7,000 to the re-election campaigns of the incumbents and to YES on 454 in support of the Naranja Park Bond.

Councilmembers Rodman and Solomon were complicit

Solomon said:
"I want to confirm what the mayor had said...if we approve this tonight, all we'd be doing is allowing the option for residential? It could still have the current zoning placed on it? It basically gives us more flexibility on this parcel?"
Keep in mind that Solomon is a developer and fully knows what a General Plan amendment entails. Rodman is a former member of the Planning and Zoning Commission and also knows the ramifications of a General Plan Amendment. Yet neither of these individuals attempted to correct Hiremath’s explanation. Hiremath has been mayor for 8 years. He also knows how a General Plan Amendment works. None of them are ignorant on this issue which makes it highly suspect that this was done deliberately.

The Town Attorney and the Town Staff also never corrected the mayor. Perhaps this was because the mayor had already torn into the Planning Director and the Economic Director for recommending that the council deny the land use change.

Snider and Pina voted against it (the first time that Snider has voted against the mayor in her 8 years in office and the first time that Pina has voted against the mayor in her 2 years in office). Therefore, if Solomon and Rodman had been honest and not acquiesced to Hiremath’s deception, the amendment would not have passed. They (along with Hornat and Waters) knew exactly what this was but they went along with the mayor’s disguise.

Hiremath, Hornat, and Waters will soon be gone, but Solomon and Rodman have another two years left on their terms. Let’s hope that the new mayor and three new councilmembers who were elected to provide a new direction, will steer these two individuals in a direction that is pro-citizen rather than pro-developer.

Monday, October 1, 2018

2018 Election Five Key Factors: #2 "No Property Tax"

Prop 454 electrocuted the election campaign of the Majority-4
There are two "three rails" in Oro Valley politics.  These are concepts that, if touched, will electrocute you.

One is a property tax.

No sitting council has ever survived the next election when proposing  a property tax. Mayor Paul Loomis was Mayor from 2002 to 2010. He had proposed a property tax to pay for a "theme park of wishes" in Naranja Park. The referendum on that tax was rejected by a resounding majority of voters.

Loomis did not make it past the primary when he ran for a third term in 2012.

In this election, Hiremath didn't make it past the primary either.

A huge political blunder
Proposing a property tax was a huge political blunder by the entire Oro Valley Town Council.

No property tax is the mantra of Oro Valley. The town was founded on that concept. Through the years, when proposed, a property tax has never received more than a 30% voter approval.

On what basis, one should reasonably ask, did the Oro Valley Town Council, which includes the Majority-4, conclude that it was a good idea to ask the voters to approve a property tax?

What made all seven members of the council think that residents so trusted their judgment to enable what will be a forever hand on the resident's wallets?

After all, the council was already wasting valuable dollars on a golf course and a community center that virtually nobody wanted. To do this, the council had diverted dollars from a "pay as you go" field building approach to Naranja Park to the golf course. In essence, as the voters most certainly saw it, Prop 454 was merely a way to help the Majority-4 make up for their huge golf course mistake.

Hubris
Apparently, the council simply did not do their homework; or, perhaps, and we think this is much more likely, the council was so convinced of their power, after the 2016 council election of Solomon, Rodman and Pina, that they could do whatever they wanted.

Voters woke up in 2017...Their enthusiasm carried into 2018
Voters awoke on 2017. They rejected Prop454.
And, then, as one would expect, they remembered just 10 months later, who put this proposition on the ballot and they rejected them too.
---
Next Up:
#1 Reason
"Worthy Challengers"







Monday, July 30, 2018

Guest View: Susan Ross ~ Hiremath’s Character?

I was amused by retired General John Wickham's letters (Arizona Daily Star and Explorer) extolling Mayor Hiremath's character. The mayor of Oro Valley was also endorsed by Reverend James Briney in a "Special to the Arizona Daily Star.” Seriously? They must be speaking about a different Hiremath than the one I have observed in his role as the mayor of Oro Valley.

Hiremath’s Misrepresentations
The Hiremath that I have observed has misled residents and has been far from forthcoming with the media. These are some examples of Hiremath's misrepresentations:

"It wasn't a backroom deal."
"Golf will be profitable in year four."
"The town got a turnkey community center."
"We put the 454 bond on the ballot to respond to the outcry for youth fields."
"We had no skin in the game."

And so it goes…on and on.

Hiremath’s Character
Hiremath called council member Bill Garner a liar on talk radio. Hiremath wrote the Arizona Bar Association in an attempt to get council member Brendan Burns disbarred. Hiremath led an unsuccessful recall of council member Mike Zinkin including authoring incendiary opinion pieces in the Explorer.  All of these actions are beneath the accepted standards of the office of mayor.

Hiremath began his re-election campaign by calling his opponent, Joe Winfield, "disingenuous" for highlighting the $6.9 million in town-reported golf operating losses. Hiremath has tried to hide the extent of these losses through an accounting shell game which treats sales taxes as golf revenue. No, Mr. Mayor, my sales taxes are not “green fees.”

If the residents desire a leader with true character, then Joe Winfield is the candidate for whom they should vote.

-----
Susan Ross is a former college professor who has lived in Oro Valley since 2014.  She has a Master’s degree in History.   She enjoys swimming.   An avid reader, she reads dozens of non-fiction books per year.

Monday, April 16, 2018

Guest View: Diane Peters ~ Mayor Hiremath makes absurd comments during the April 4th council meeting

During the April 4th Town Council meeting, the council voted 7-0 (no surprise there) to rezone 85 acres of pristine desert on the west side of LaCholla between Glover and Naranja from R1-20 (minimum 20,000 square foot lots with custom grading) to R1-7 (minimum 7,000 sf lots with mass grading) to accommodate 178 single-family homes, including 2-story homes.

For some history, this parcel had already been rezoned from R1-144 to R1-20 in 2007 and a development plan for just 74 one-story homes on lot sizes ranging from 1/3 acre to 1.5 acres was already approved by the Town Council in 2014.

Below, Mayor Hiremath explains his “rationale” for why 7,000 square foot residential lots are better than 20,000 sf lots.

Hiremath: "If you have 20,000 square foot lots, there is no capacity or requirement for the homeowner on those large lots to leave it natural desert. Somebody could landscape it, somebody could wall it."

My Rebuttal: So in order to prevent the highly unlikely possibility that a homeowner would mass grade or wall in his 20,000 sf property (approx. ½ acre) or his 43,560 sf property (1 acre), Mayor Hiremath voted to allow a developer to mass grade 52 acres of an 85 acre property that will be all walled in when the development is completed!

1 acre = 43,560 square feet x 52 acres = 2,265,120 square feet!!!

Read that again…Hiremath prefers that the developer mass grade 2.2 million square feet in order to prevent the unlikely possibility of one person mass grading 20,000 square feet. That’s absurd!

How many homeowner’s in Oro Valley have mass graded their 20,000 square foot lot? How many have mass graded their 1 acre lot, their 1.5 acre lot, or their 3 acre lot? The mayor provided no statistics for his claim. I’ve lived in Oro Valley for 15 years and I haven’t seen this anywhere, so just how common is this practice?

It’s far more likely that people who buy homes on large lots do so because they prefer to be surrounded by lush desert vegetation and wildlife and they don’t want a view of their neighbor’s home. So why would they mass grade their property?

Below, Mayor Hiremath tries to convince everyone that mountain views are not important.

Hiremath: "Does every house in the town of Oro Valley have a mountain view?"

Planning Administrator, Bayer Vella: No, but many do.

Hiremath: "So is any house construction going to block the actual view of the mountain? I mean, do people in Oro Valley buy a house, do [sic] every person in Oro Valley buy a house because of the mountain views or is it because they actually like to live in a community at the base of a mountain and they get to enjoy the mountain on their walks, their bike rides, when they go shopping, when they come out of Fry’s, when they come out of Target?"

This is a leading question. He is clearly telling Bayer what he wants him to say.

Bayer: I think it’s the latter. It’s the package. It’s not just any one box amongst a list of many.

My Rebuttal: Hiremath lives on a 1.7 acre hilltop lot with mountain views. Are we to believe that the hilltop location with panoramic mountain views didn’t factor into his decision to purchase that home?

All one has to do is peruse the Oro Valley real estate listings to see that any house with a mountain view is listed as such in the ad. Why would real estate agents bother mentioning the mountain views if no one is interested in homes with mountain views? Obviously, mountain views are a big selling point!

Follow the money trail
So what’s the real reason that Mayor Hiremath (and the rest of the council) voted to rezone this parcel down to 7,000 square foot lots to accommodate 178 cluster homes? Perhaps it’s because the players in this deal (see below list) have donated more than $20,000 to the election campaigns of all 7 current council members and to Yes on 454 in support of the mayor and council’s 2017 pet project, the Naranja Park Bond. Some of these donations are outlined below:

2014-2017    Greg Wexler (land broker, Wexler & Associates) donated a total of $14,410
2017             Jeff Grobstein, President, Meritage Homes, donated $5,000
2017             William Walker, Owner, WLB Engineering, donated $1,000

But wait! There’s more!
Other council members also offered absurd justifications to defend their votes to rezone that property for cluster homes. Their comments and my rebuttals will be featured in upcoming LOVE articles. Stay tuned.

. . . . . . . . . .

Diane Peters has lived in Oro Valley since 2003, moving here to escape the humidity of the East Coast. She’s been involved in OV politics and development issues since 2006. In 2014, she organized a citizens group, Citizen Advocates of the Oro Valley General Plan, who over a 9-month period, successfully negotiated a controversial 200-acre development project. In her past life, she worked in medical research at various University Hospitals in New England. Her interests include reading, writing, nature photography, travel, art galleries, museums, and politics.

Wednesday, February 21, 2018

Editorial ~ The Sign Tamperer. Part 2. “The Smoking Gun”

Part 1 was published on Monday. Please scroll down to read it if you haven’t already done so.

Crime Scene Investigation
The photograph that was published was an overhead shot. A few days after it was published, three Oro Valley residents (including a former law enforcement officer using binoculars) walked the site of the “crime” and could not find a camera attached to either a pole or a building that could have taken the picture from the angle at which it was taken (from above and to the right of the sign).

A security camera on the old Sports Authority building was aimed at the parking lot, not at the area with the sign. This camera was tested nonetheless and found to be inactive. So what happened to the “surveillance” camera? Who put it there, when, and why? It appears to have been removed right after the picture was taken. This leads us to wonder if this “crime” was a staged event.

The Smoking Gun
Also of interest is who filed the complaint. The person who made and posted the sign should be the one who filed the complaint since they are claiming that the sign was their property. This means that the OVPD now knows the identity of the person who deliberately posted many of those same signs directly in front of Axe the Tax signs in an effort to block them from view. This is a Class 2 misdemeanor under ARS 16-1019. Why hasn’t the OVPD issued a citation against them?

Collusion?
Axe the Tax dealt with sign issues for weeks…stolen signs, signs found thrown in a wash, signs bent in half, signs covered by “Why Ax Kids Sports?” signs deliberately placed directly in front of them.

In these instances, the State Statute does apply since these signs were paid for and placed by a PAC. (Axe the Tax PAC).

It’s suspicious that the OVPD turned this “non-story” into front page news and that they pulled this stunt just one week before the election, just in time to make the last issue of the Explorer before election day. Was the OVPD (via marching orders from the mayor) colluding with the Yes on 454 folks to damage the character and credibility of Axe the Tax supporters in a last ditch effort to garner more votes for their $28 million dollar “desperately needed ball fields?”

After all, similar stunts have been pulled in past Oro Valley elections. Remember the “Lou Waters was assaulted by a ream of paper” story that they pulled out during the 2015 Recall Election in order to smear the character of the challengers? That case went to court. Waters lost. We have to wonder what ploys they will conjure up this year in order to tip the scales in their favor for the Town Council election in August.

It bears repeating
We will end Part 2 of this article the same way we ended Part 1. This whole thing smacks of political maneuvering and LOVE does not take kindly to our police being involved in politics.

Monday, February 19, 2018

Editorial ~ The Sign Tamperer. Part 1.

With another Town election coming up in August as the mayor and three Town Council members run for a third term, LOVE would like to report on a campaign problem that is likely to rear it’s ugly head again in a few short months.

Background
Back in early November 2017, many of you saw the photo on the front page of the Explorer of a person who was allegedly seen tampering with a “Why Ax Kids Sports?” sign near the intersection of First and Oracle. The caption accompanying the photo indicated that the “OVPD is asking for the public’s help with a criminal damage investigation.” This seemed a little excessive considering that the sign was not an official campaign sign protected under Arizona State law, but rather, would be considered the equivalent of a Yard Sale sign.

Who’s the Boss?
After you read this article, ask yourself these questions:

• Why is the OVPD putting this much time, effort, manpower, and taxpayer money into investigating the equivalent of someone tampering with a homemade “Yard Sale” sign?

• Does this merit a 3-month long (and counting) investigation? Why are they going to such great lengths to find the “perpetrator” when no campaign laws were violated? Don’t our police have more important things to do?

•Who’s orchestrating this?

• Would the police launch a “criminal damage investigation” if someone had tampered with a Yard Sale sign? Would they post a picture of the person on the OVPD Facebook page AND on the front page of the Explorer newspaper asking for the public’s help in finding this person? Of course not. So why did they do it in this instance?

• Why are they maneuvering to keep the Police Report from the public?

OVPD Withholds release of Police Report
LOVE wanted to report on this story back in November, but in order to report the whole story, we needed to obtain a copy of the Police Report. One of our LOVE readers has been trying to obtain this report since November. The OVPD initially said that it couldn’t be released until the investigation was closed. When the case was finally closed in mid-January and the LOVE reader attempted once again to obtain a copy of the report, the case was suddenly reopened because “new information has been obtained in furtherance of the investigation.”

It’s suspicious that new information was obtained which bars the release of the report just as the report was about to be released under the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA). Someone does not want that file to be released.

After waiting patiently for more than three months, LOVE has decided to report on what we know at this time. We’re also reporting on it now because the repeated delays in releasing the Police Report have become a story all on its own.

Why is this story important?
The etiology of the complaint is an important piece of this investigation. The owner of the “property” must be known and identified for any item to be considered “property” under law. Additionally, no complaint is valid or actionable by law enforcement unless a complaint is filed by that “property” owner. Once a complaint is filed, it is required to be disclosed upon any request under Federal FOIA and Arizona Public Records law.

During the Naranja Park Bond election, numerous “Why Ax Kids Sports?” signs were illegally placed directly in front of campaign signs that had been posted by the Axe the Tax PAC. Axe the Tax filed a complaint with the Town. When contacted by the Town Clerk about the illegal placement of these signs [a Class 2 misdemeanor under ARS 16-1019] the Yes on 454 PAC claimed that these signs did not belong to them.

Being that there was no “Paid for by…..” disclosure statement on the signs, it appeared that they were placed by an individual who was not associated with any political action committee. Therefore, it was assumed that they did not belong to the YES on 454 PAC.

Irresponsible Allocation of Town Resources
Since no campaign laws were violated, the amount of time and effort being spent on this investigation is disproportionate to the “crime” that was allegedly committed. The question remains…why? This whole thing smacks of political maneuvering and LOVE does not take kindly to our police being involved in politics.

Part 2 will be published on Wednesday.

Wednesday, November 29, 2017

Editorial ~ Speak up and Stop the Development of Big Wash

Big Wash General Plan Amendment and Rezoning
Wednesday, December 6, 2017 at 6:00 PM
Town Council Chambers, 11,000 N LaCanada Drive

PUBLIC HEARING: Big Wash General Plan Amendment and Rezoning discussion and possible action regarding approximately 108 acres located north of Tangerine Road between the future Moore Road loop on the west and Rancho Vistoso Blvd. on the east. The applicant seeks to change the existing development rights on the property. (Details below under Two New General Plan Amendments.)

The Building Frenzy
The Oro Valley building frenzy that we are all witnessing will continue as long as there is money to be made and as long as Mayor Hiremath and his submissive council are in office. Builders and developers have been feeding at the trough for the past year taking advantage of the passive 7-member pro-development council.

Let’s take a drive
A drive up First Avenue from Oracle Road to Rancho Vistoso Blvd. vividly shows Oro Valley’s new skyline -- Cat and Komatsu bulldozers and tractors framed against our once magnificent view of Pusch Ridge. This has become the new normal with our developer-run town. The picture below shows the grading that is already underway.

• Able to reap tall buildings in a single council meeting
At First and Lambert Lane we see the south entrance to Nakoma Sky, our new assisted living complex. This property will feature a 5-story building that was approved by Mayor Hiremath and Councilmembers Hornat, Snider, and Waters (who received $65,654 in campaign contributions from builders, developers, realtors, and brokers during the 2015 recall election). It was also approved by current councilmember Bill Rodman when he was on the Planning & Zoning Commission.

You can be sure that this 5-story building will set the stage for the introduction of more high-rise structures in Oro Valley to solve the developer “problem” of diminishing buildable land.

• South of Tangerine – Palisades
Further north on First at Naranja Drive we see the main entrance to Nakoma Sky where the natural ridge has been bulldozed for stop light access to the project whose boundary extends east to the CDO wash.

Continuing north towards Tangerine we pass construction and grading on both sides of E. Palisades road. The earth moving is so extensive that E. Palisades has been severed to allow graders free movement north and south across the road. We can only speculate the traffic and access problems these projects will add to our trips.

• North of Tangerine – Moore Road
Crossing Tangerine to Rancho Vistoso Blvd. we see that all the flat ridge lots to the east have been developed.

But at the juncture with Moore Road, a major change is occurring. A traffic light is being installed and Moore Road has been extended into a new development to the east. This is not an access road into another plateau development, but a serious traffic mover. The road curves around the model homes and dips down into big wash where the pavement stops. The roadway continues as a graded entrance for - you guessed it - Cat and Komatsu earth movers now tearing up Big Wash for more homes.

Two new General Plan Amendments
As if this isn’t enough wanton destruction of our once pristine desert surroundings, our “never met a developer they didn’t like” mayor and council will most likely amend our 2016 voter-approved General Plan to rezone Big Wash and Honeybee Wash parcels to change land use and zoning designations for undeveloped parcels loacted along Honeybee Wash and Big Wash. This will allow 408 homes in two additional subdivisions.

The western development will contain 166 homes with minimum 6,000 square foot lots and building heights of 30 feet (two stories). Moore Road will be extended and loop south through the wash back to a point of connection with Arrowsmith Drive.

The eastern development will contain 242 homes at the juncture of Big Wash and Honebee Wash. The development will require its own access road from Rancho Vistoso Blvd. – between Sun City Oro Valley and the Big Wash Bridge – that will loop around the Estates at High Mesa to access the new homes.

View the LOCATION MAP here.  View the TENTATIVE DEVELOPMENT PLAN here.

Let’s Make a Deal
The applicant is Paul Oland of the WLB Group. William Walker (owner of WLB) donated $1,000 to the YES on 454 PAC in support of the $17 million dollar Naranja Park Bond that was supported by the mayor and council. As previously reported on LOVE, The WLB Group frequently appears before council to request land use changes, rezoning requests, and grading waivers to accommodate their Oro Valley developments. Since history has shown that the town council always acquiesce to these requests, LOVE has always viewed these developer donations as a Quid pro quo.

It’s time to show up and speak up
Over 100 pages of opposition letters were already submitted to Planning and Zoning for their October 3rd and November 8th meetings. Despite these letters of opposition, P&Z recommended forwarding the application to the council for a vote. Therefore, we urge you to add your voice to the opposition.

Let the council know that residents do not want these General Plan and PAD Amendments and that this rampant development and destruction of nature, wildlife habitat, and our peaceful surroundings has got to stop.

Keep the momentum going
Keep in mind that the recent 71% to 29% defeat of the Naranja Park Bond was a huge blow to the Town Council who had previously convinced themselves that the citizens of Oro Valley are in agreement with the direction in which this council has taken our town.

A large resident turn-out at the December 6th meeting in addition to the recent landslide defeat of the Naranja Park Bond will send them a message that citizens are informed and are tired of being dismissed.

Tuesday, November 28, 2017

The Surprise of the Prop 454 Election (Part 2)

Yesterday we expressed our surprise on the Prop 454 Election vote. We were surprised that 71.4% of the voters rejected the proposal to fund an acceleration of the construction of Naranja Park. This rejection exceeded the 58% no vote in 2008, when voters opined on a much more expansive Naranja Park bond proposal.

So, we ask:  Why was the 'no' vote more resounding this time around?

Here's our analysis:

Prop 400 had something for everyone. Prop 454 did not. 
Council Member Joe Hornat observed during a council meeting in 2015 that the only way to get voter bond approval for Naranja Park was to include something for everyone. Prop 454 was not that. It was a limited purpose bond. It was a bond that focused on one part of the resident population, families with children who play sports and a handful of senior softball players; and on the building of infrastructure. That's it. On the other hand, Prop 400 had goodies for many, including a theatre for performing arts and a community-type center. Even with that, it was rejected by the voters but not by as large a margin. 

Prop 400 was an "all or nothing deal" for Naranja Park, whereas Prop 454 impacted only the timing of Naranja Park development 
No compelling reason was presented to support accelerating building the fields at Naranja Park. The current council had formulated a plan to build the park on a "pay as you go basis." That presents no visible burden on the voter. Besides, sometimes, as we tell our kids, you will just have to wait for that new smart phone!     

The "AXE" PAC made a difference 
There were two PAC's participating in this election. There were none in 2008. Perhaps the "Axethetaxov" PAC was more effective than the "Yes On 454" PAC in reaching the voter. This despite the fact that "Yes on 454" outspent the "AxetheTaxov" Pac by 15:1! Big money special interests bet on a win in 2017. There were no special interest donations in 2008. Perhaps voters were turned off when they learned that the "Yes On 454" PAC got 76% of its money, some $35,000, from the development community. This is the same development community that has poured hundreds of thousands into the election of current council members. Of even more significance, however, was that the "Yes On 454" PAC received less than 1% of its donations from the public, including from the very people who would benefit from the approval. Of further interest: No sports organizations donated to the PAC. In fact, the Yes PAC returned a $250 donation that they received from Little League Baseball. 

'No' on Prop 454 Voters were far more energized 
There were 2,184 more votes in total cast in 2008 than in 2017. The decrease in the number of votes cast is directly related to the 3,100 fewer votes cast in favor of the bond. On the other hand, there were more 'no' votes in total in 2017 than in 2008: 11,565 and 10,669 respectively. 

Those are some of our initial thoughts. 

Please write us (see comment form on right panel) to let us know what you think.
---

Monday, November 27, 2017

The Surprise of the Prop 454 Election (Part 1)


The final results from the Prop 454 election confirm a huge plurality in favor of retaining the status quo: Continue to develop Naranja Park on a "pay as you go" basis.

Those who supported this effort most certainly must have felt that it would pass. After all, they employed the same strategy and consulting firm that works for the Mayor and six council members in previous elections. Those who opposed it most certainly must be surprised that it was rejected by 71.4% of the voters.

Early votes comprised 88.4% of all votes.  28.9% of early voters favored the proposition. On election day, though,  a smaller percentage of voters, 25.95 of favored it.

The results were different based on voting locations. Almost 80% of Sun City voters opposed the proposition. While 67% of those voting at Church of the Apostle (La Cholla) opposed it. Still, even with that difference, there was no area of the town that was even close to wanting this proposition to succeed.

There are two surprises regarding the election results.

First, the plurality against Prop 454 was much larger than the plurality against park development the last time we voted on it in 2008
The plurality is huge, not just in terms of it being 71.4% 'no' votes, but huge in comparison to the last time voters opined on building Naranja Park.

That was in 2008.

In 2008, the Oro Valley Town Council, and the Mayor at that time, Paul Loomis, promoted Prop 400, an $85 million Naranja Park Bond. The voters rejected this proposition. In that election, the park bond was rejected by 58.5% of the voters.

That's right. Fewer voters supported a smaller bond in 2017 than they did a bigger bond in 2008.

2008: 7,584 voted to approve Prop 400
2017: 4,965 voters to approve Prop 454

That is 2,719 fewer 'yes' votes even though 1,234 more votes were cast in total in 2008 than in 2017.

Second, the Oro Valley Town Council was so out of touch with the average citizen that it did not foresee the massive voter rejection of a property tax
The council voted unanimously to put this proposition on the ballot. That vote cost you about $150,00 in costs related to it. Perhaps, the council has bad judgment. Perhaps, this council is so far out of touch that they no longer speak for you, the Oro Valley resident who works hard for the money, has limited sources, and really just wants to live in our community to enjoy some peace and serenity. So, really, one could ask quite reasonably: Who do they speak for?

Tomorrow
We will present other thoughts on why the results were as they were!
---

Wednesday, November 15, 2017

The Watchdog Report: September 2017 Community Center Financials

Continued losses
In September, the Community Center Fund (CCF) finished $86,016 in the red. (At this time last year, the CCF had a positive balance of $161,744.)

For the first quarter of this fiscal year (July 1 through September 30th) the fund has lost $307,862. This takes into account the fact that the sales tax revenues for the first quarter were $507,985, which is $22,557 more than last year during the same time period.

Troon (golf, food, beverage, tennis, non-aquatic center swimming) is performing about the same as this time last year. In the first three months of this fiscal year, Troon has lost $754,307, while last year at the same time the losses were $760,069.

Member dues are down by nearly $8000 dollars
So far this fiscal year, member dues are $178,621, while member dues last year at this time were $186,537. Why do we still cater to the members when their support of the investment is dwindling? Meanwhile, Troon continues to feather its own nest as the payroll and employee benefits through September 2017 were $39,863 higher than the same period in 2016.

Food and Beverage losses
Food and beverage, primarily the Overlook Restaurant, lost another $8,333 in September 2017. This brings the total losses so far this fiscal year to $34,034.

The National Golf Foundation Study spoke loud and clear
The losses are continuing and there appears to be no end in sight. The contracted National Golf Foundation study (for which the Town paid $50,000) states:

“This facility is aging and has seen declines in activity and is now operating at a deficit, up to $2.1 million+. The loss on operations is a result of several influences…a recent recession, increasing competition, declining physical condition, and declining interest in golf.”

“The current financial condition [of El Con Golf] is worse than most public sector golf operations in the U.S. where 67% of municipal golf course operations are able to cover on-site expenses.”

"El Conquistador G&T is well-located in Oro Valley, but has limited appeal for customers beyond the local Oro Valley area. With an offering of multiple golf courses, ECGT can provide service to a wide range of golf customers, but the club is having difficulty filling up all 45 holes of golf.”

Oro Valley Voters spoke loud and clear
One might think that after the landslide defeat of Prop 454 (The Naranja Park Bond), that the Council would start to take a closer look at their irresponsible spending. The Citizens told them loud and clear... "We are tired of all the taxes, we are tired of not being your first priority, we are tired of our Town Council only looking out for the developers and builders who fund their campaigns.”

Financial Update through September 2017 hidden in Consent Agenda
The Fiscal Year 2017/18 Financial Update through September 2017 is on the Consent Agenda for the November 16th Town Council Special Session. In fact, the entire agenda for this session is made up of a Consent Agenda. As in past council meetings, don't expect the financials to be removed for discussion and don't expect this meeting to last more than 45 minutes.

Mike Zinkin has a Bachelor’s degree in history and government from the University of Arizona and a Master’s degree in Social and Philosophical Foundations of Education from California State University, Northridge. He was a commissioned ensign in the United States Navy Reserve in 1969. He worked as an Air Traffic Controller for 30 years. He and his wife moved to Oro Valley after retiring in 1998. Mike served on the Oro Valley Development Review Board from 2005-2009, the Board of Adjustment from 2011-2012, and the Town Council from 2012-2016. During his time on council, he was named as one of 23 Leadership Fellows for the National League of Cities University, he was a member of the National League of Cities Steering Committee for Community and Economic Development, and a member of the Arizona League of Cities Budget and Economic Development Committee.

Wednesday, November 8, 2017

Developer Donations Could Rule Tonight's General Plan Amendment Hearing


Some of the money that developers have poured into Oro Valley's Prop 454 election can be seen in action tonight as the Oro Valley Planning and Zoning Commission hears 3 general plan amendments [Agenda].

The amendments involve changes to the general plan. This is the general plan  that voters approved just last year. The plan took more than 2 years and several hundred thousand dollars to develop. It took thousand of person hours. It was thoroughly vetted. Yet, not even one year into its approval cycle, requests are being made and are being heard.

These are the requests:
  • Changing land destination in Innovation Park from commercial to medium density residential. This is proposed by developer Ford Acrewood, LLC - Anthem Equity Group, Inc. Theyonated $5,000 to YES for Prop454;

  • Taking 302 acres of state land on the western town boundary and designating it as a "Master Planned Community."
    Several developers might have an interest in this land, developers who contributed to YES. These includes Mattamy who donated $5,000, Don Diamond $5,000, Jeff Grobstein $5,000 (who told Town they needed to annex the land so they they had more room to build), and maybe even HSL $5,000.

  • Change land use in several areas of Rancho Vistoso.
    In one instance the change is from golf course to residential; in the other, it is from mixed used to medium density residential. This one is proposed by VWI Vistoso Development $1,000 and William Walker owner WLB Engineering $1,000
The meeting starts at 6PM in Oro Valley Council Chambers.
---

Tuesday, November 7, 2017

Early Election Results Show Resounding Defeat For Prop 454

Election results on Prop 454 have been posed by the Pima County Recorder. These results are as of 8:04 PM. We suspect they are for mail in ballots only:

Yes: 4,050
No: 10,209
---

Friday, November 3, 2017

Editorial ~ Fields of Dreams are already here

LOVE has compiled a list of 14 nearby ball fields to counter Yes on 454’s claim that more ball fields are “desperately needed” because “there simply aren’t enough fields to go around.” The following parks are located close to Oro Valley. Hours vary between 6 AM and 10 PM and all include restroom facilities.

Many of these parks also include basketball courts, tennis courts, ramadas, etc., but for the purpose of this article, we are providing information only on the availability of Little League, soccer, and multi-use fields.

Ann Day Community Park
7601 N Mona Lisa Road
baseball/softball fields
soccer field

Arthur Pack Regional Park
9101 N Thornydale
7 baseball fields
2 softball fields
1 soccer field

Continental Ranch Community Park
8900 N Coachline
4 Little League
2 soccer/multi-use fields

Continental Reserve Community Park
8568 N Continental Reserve Loop
2 Little League fields
2 soccer/multi-use fields

Crossroads at Silverbell District Park
7548 N Silverbell Road
3 lighted ball fields
2 lighted soccer/multi-use fields

Curtis Park
2110 W Curtis Road (off LaCholla)
1 lighted baseball field
2 lighted Little League fields

Dan Felix Park
5790 N Camino de la Tierra
4 lighted soccer fields

Denny Dunn Park
4400 W Massingale Road (near Old Father and Magee)
2 baseball fields
soccer field/football field

Flowing Wells Park
5510 N Shannon Road
2 lighted baseball/softball fields

George Mehl Park
4000 E River Road
4 lighted baseball fields
1 lighted soccer field

Gladden Farms Community Park
12205 N Tangerine Farms Road
2 Little League fields
1 soccer/multi-use field

Ora Mae Harn District Park
13250 N Lon Adams Road
5 lighted ball fields
1 lighted soccer/multi-use field

Wade McLean Neighborhood Park
8000 N Silverbell
1 Little League field
1 soccer/multi-use field

Wildwood Park
6201 N Parsley Road (near Orange Grove and Shannon)
1 softball field
soccer/multi-use field

But wait, there’s more!

Below are excerpts from Jack Stinnett’s two LOVE Guest Views, “Solving Oro Valley’s Little League Field Crisis” published on September 25th and “Solving Oro Valley’s Sports Field Crisis” published on August 30th.

A quick count shows that there are over 30 baseball fields within 8 miles of Naranja Park, many lightly used. The two parks located in Oro Valley are described below.

J.D. Kriegh Park is the home of the Canyon del Oro Little League. It has two excellent lighted competition fields and three practice fields used for baseball and softball. The park has restrooms, a snack bar and is well-maintained by Oro Valley Parks and Recreation.

Riverfront Park is the center for youth softball and has two lighted and well-maintained fields. Riverfront Park also has two lighted soccer/multi-purpose fields. This park has playgrounds, picnic areas for families, a nice walking path, and draws softball players from NW Pima County.

Listed below is a summary of Amphi baseball fields in and around Oro Valley:

Canyon del Oro High School……….…2 competition fields -- 3 practice fields
Ironwood Ridge High School……….…2 competition fields -- 2 practice fields
Wilson Middle School……………….…2 competition fields -- 2 practice fields
Coronado Middle School………………2 competition fields -- 3 practice fields
………………………

Editor’s Note: The FY 2017/18 budget already includes $1.046 MM for two new ball fields at Naranja Park…and more fields could be built with the $2 million dollar FY 2016/17 budget surplus. Rather than saddle homeowners with a $28 million dollar, 20-year long secondary property tax, Oro Valley sports youth could utilize the above-mentioned existing fields as we continue with the pay-as-you-go plan.

Thursday, November 2, 2017

UPDATE: Naranja Park Bond Campaign Finance Reports

Since LOVE’s last report on the campaign finances of “Axe the Tax” and “YES on 454,” the following donations to both PAC’s have been reported to the town:

Additional contributors to YES on 454 include:

$1,100 from individuals contributing more than $50.00
Zero from individuals contributing $50.00 or less

Once again, there are no contributions from the parents or coaches who are crying about “the desperately needed fields.”

$2,500 from Diamond Ventures
$2,500 from Southwest DVI Properties (another Diamond Ventures entity)
$100 from Tim Overton, Banker at Vantage West Credit Union
$1,000 from William Walker, Owner WLB Engineering

TOTAL $6,100

NOTE: WLB is the development group that represents landowners in the majority of new home and commercial developments in Oro Valley. They frequently appear before council to request land use changes (to the voter-approved General Plan), rezoning requests, and grading waivers to accommodate their residential and commercial developments. (e.g. Big Wash General Plan Amendment, LaCholla Major General Plan Amendments, Estates at Capella, Saguaro Viejos, Sanctuary at Silverhawke).

Of note also is that Oro Valley Little League Baseball donated $250 which was later refunded back to them. Was this because all the “big league players” donated so much money that the Little League group didn’t feel a need to contribute to their own cause?

Additional contributors to Axe the Tax include:

$417.22 from individuals contributing $50.00 or less
$482.52 from individuals contributing more than $50.00*
$96.80 from Toggle Enterprises, LLC

TOTAL $996.54

*Three of the individuals are Oro Valley residents and one is from Tucson.

You can read the previous LOVE article on the campaign finances of Axe the Tax and Yes on 454 HERE

Tuesday, October 31, 2017

Mayor Hiremath's View of Sports Tourism In Oro Valley

Mayor Hiremath discussed Oro Valley's sports tourism objective in his 2017 "State of The Town" Speech.  In these remarks, Mayor Hiremath defines Prop 454 as an economic development initiative. The following is excerpted from his speech.
---
“Earlier this year, members of the community—including youth sport parents, athletes and Oro Valley user groups—asked Council to take action to construct additional sport fields at Naranja Park. While the Town Council adopted a 2015 Naranja Park Master Plan, our pay‐as‐you‐go approach to phased development was progressing too slowly to keep pace with user demand. So, after many conversations with user groups, stakeholders and a design firm, a proposal that meets the community’s request was presented, along with a plan for financing.

The proposal is a partial build‐out of the Master Plan, and includes only the elements that the community and park user groups have identified as being in greatest demand. The project would be funded through the issuance and sale of $17 million in general obligation bonds to be repaid through a secondary property tax, which sunsets after 20 years.

By law, Town Council cannot impose a property tax—only the voters can. So, this November, Oro Valley voters will decide on Prop 454.

I’m not going to advocate that you vote for or against this bond. But I am going to advocate that you learn the facts of Prop 454 so that you can make an informed decision on Election Day. Please visit the Town’s website to learn what’s included in the project and what it will mean for Oro Valley taxpayers. The fact that this item is even on the ballot for voter consideration is a direct result of Council’s willingness to adapt to the community’s needs. Whether or not it passes will be entirely up to the voters.

And in case you hadn’t heard: Major League Soccer has arrived in Oro Valley!

Thanks to our ongoing partnership with FC Tucson, the Hilton Resort and Visit Tucson, Major League Soccer rolled into Naranja Park in 2016 with Sporting Kansas City and Columbus Crew. And earlier this year, the New York Red Bulls used our fields for practice, and put on a free scrimmage game against FC Tucson.

I am pleased to announce that Major League Soccer will once again return to Naranja Park in 2018!

And here’s some news hot off the press: I’ve just learned that the finish line for the 2018 Tucson Marathon will now be right here, in Oro Valley.

Whether you’re a sports fan or not, it’s important to remember that these major events are coming to Oro Valley because we have invested in the development of recreational facilities that are of such high quality, they meet the standards for national competition, and when they aren’t in use for competition, our residents have daily access to those very same, world‐class facilities.

More importantly, sports tourism is a 9 BILLION dollar industry nationwide. These events bring thousands of athletes and guests into our hotels, restaurants and shops, where their sales tax and bed tax dollars are invested right back into the Town of Oro Valley.

That translates into financial resources to fund Town services and amenities. This is why the Town of Oro Valley continues to invest in economic development opportunities that support our businesses and attract visitors, all while simultaneously improving quality of life for our residents.”

Source: "2017 State of the Town" Speech
---

Monday, October 30, 2017

Prop 454: It's All About Sports Tourism

The term "sports tourism" has been bandied about in Oro Valley.  It is used when people refer to the Aquatic Center; the tennis courts at the El Conquistador Country Club; and now Naranja Park-Prop 454.

By now you should have read enough on LOVE's pages to know exactly what Prop 454 is. Our shorthand version: It is a property tax to pay for a bond whose proceeds will be used to accelerate the development of Naranja Park.

The effort to convince residents to vote "Yes" is funded entirely by the development community. This funding includes the "usual suspects" who funded the campaigns of current council members. The driver behind the effort, as unveiled on LOVE, is Mayor Hiremath. From personal experience, we know that he does not always tell you everything you need to know in order to make an informed decision.

So, what if this accelerated development isn't really about us, the residents having an opportunity to use these parks. What if it's really about making Oro Valley a sports tourism destination. In other words, it may not be about the "kids" at all. It may be about "...takin' care of business."

In October of 2014, the late Bill Adler opined his thoughts on sports tourism in Oro Valley at a council meeting. We thought you would want to hear his words.  Bill was a 'patriot' for Oro Valley. He believed that town government should be about serving residents above all else.

In speaking of the plans the town had constructed for Naranja Park, Bill pondered:
"Is the objective [of Naranja Park] to serve people who live here or is the objective to create an economic development incentive to create revenue. I think these are two different things."
We know what sports tourism means to Oro Valley. We have an aquatic center. It is used by a handful of residents at a fairly high cost per season. It is also used for swim meets. And, of course, there the annual Oro Valley Triathalon is staged there. For the ordinary Oro Valley citizen, however, the aquatic center has no direct value.

So what of these improvements at Naranja Park?

Will they too be used by only a handful or residents and sports teams?

We don't know. We can, however, look to other communities. The town of Westfield, Indiana spent millions on sports fields so that they could become a "sports tourism" destination. Residents are disillusioned because they can't use the fields unless they are part of an organized effort. In addition, the facility has fallen far short of revenue projections such that the town has had to support it to the tune of $6 million out of pocket in one year!  Read about their dilemma. Losses like this when added to the losses of the Oro Valley Community Center money pit would be disastrous!

So, vote as you wish; but just be aware the "things are not always what they appear to be.

Tomorrow: Sports Tourism In Mayor Hiremath's own words
---

Friday, October 27, 2017

How and Where To Vote In The Prop 454 Election

Oro Valley Special Election November 7, 2017

Oro Valley has consolidated polls for the special election on November 7, 2017. There will only be 7 locations instead of the usual 15 polling locations. They are listed below.

You can find your precinct number on your voter registration card (PCT.)

If you can’t locate your card, you can find your precinct number by going to this link and entering your address.



IMPORTANT ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
  • Early ballots must be received by Pima County by 7 pm on election day or they will NOT be counted.
  • You can drop an early ballot off at any polling place in Pima County. (But this delays the final tabulation of results.) 
  • If you received an early ballot but prefer to vote at your polling location on election day, you will be required to vote a provisional ballot. A provisional ballot is a regular ballot that is sealed in a special envelope rather than tabulated in the polling place. Since voters have until 7:00 p.m. on Election Day to return an early ballot, the County must verify that you did not return your early ballot before the polling place ballot can be counted. Once that is verified, your provisional ballot is verified and tabulated. (NO double voting)

    SUGGESTION: If you have an early (mail-in) ballot, mail it in the return envelope by November 2nd. 
 (Source: AxTheTaxOV)
---

Thursday, October 26, 2017

Axethetax: 6 Things You Need To Know About Prop 454

The AxeTheTax PAC  identified 6 things they believe you need to know as you consider your vote on Prop 454. These were listed in a release they sent us yesterday
---

"6 THINGS YOU NEED TO KNOW ABOUT PROP 454 THE NARANJA PARK BOND - PROPERTY TAX
  • It’s NOT just a $17 million dollar bond. Prop 454 is a 20 year, $28 million property tax (principal & interest.) Full build out of the park is projected to be $33 million (without interest.) Millions more will be required to complete the park master plan.
  • It's NOT a request petitioned by the community for more fields. The online petitions that were submitted had only 167 signatures from Oro Valley residents. The remainder of the 10,000 signatures were from other states and foreign countries. The Town did not validate the signatures.
  • It’s NOT about the kids. Other than fields for team sports, there's only one playground. The skate and bike park were eliminated. This bond is to fund the infrastructure for a future event center hidden on Town bond materials.
  • It's NOT financially supported by parents. Ninety-nine percent of the $36,650 of donations to YES on 454 came from developers, builders and HSL/Humberto Lopez, the man who dumped his revenue losing three golf courses on the Town.
  • It’s NOT a park for the community. It's a park for Sports and Event Tourism that will cause light and air pollution, traffic congestion, and noise for the surrounding residential developments.
  •  It’s NOT what we requested in the 2014 Parks & Recreation Survey. We asked for playgrounds, ramadas/picnic areas and walkways/paths for our families. We never asked for an event center or golf courses. Let's stay with the "pay as you go plan."
    VOTE NO ON PROP 454"
    (Source: AxeTheTax PAC)
---