Thursday, March 20, 2008

Read What Phil Richardson Says About Golder Ranch Fire District

Phil Richardson, our Oro Valley neighbor and friend, has studied the entire Golder Ranch Fire District ("GFRD") issue from before their merger with Rural-Metro Fire Department until the present time. Please read what Phil has to say----especially if your neighborhood has not yet been annexed.

Before any property owner signs to be annexed into the GRFD, wait. There may be an alternative on the horizon.

Art
**************************************************************************************

Fix The Fire District Fiasco

The attempt to disguise by slight-of-hand semantics an ever-encroaching Golder Ranch Fire District Property Tax during the first part of the Council election is annoying, and sure to prove very costly in a short time. Those who garnered fewer votes than Salette Latas and Bill Garner, namely Helen Dankwerth, Barry Gillaspie and Terry Parish, said they were opposed to a “Primary Property Tax,” but not to a property tax that goes to the Golder Ranch Fire District.

We are certainly inviting ridicule when we feel a need to contend with them or any other person about whether a tax on our properties is anything other than a property tax.

In any case, what the reader may not realize is that this “Secondary” tax item on your bill from the Pima County Tax Collector is based on the full assessed value and not the “discounted” valuation from the Assessor. So, it’s even worse than you might have supposed.

When you get your tax bill, you need to look at the items listed thereupon. Believe us please, when we predict that far worse is yet to come – that is, if we can’t persuade the Town Council to rescind a monopoly given to the Golder Ranch Fire District

Our serious bit of advice to those in areas not yet annexed is included in this mantra: “When Fire Districts Compete, You Win.”

Yeah, we plagiarized and paraphrased this apt slogan from a very successful Mortgage Banking advertising campaign.

Folks living in areas annexed into GRFD have already gotten a bitter taste of what is bound to come in future Pima County Tax bills: A far heavier tax rate will be imposed to if the Catalina Based Fire District is allowed to capture the rest of the OV precincts stretching from mid-town down to the newly annexed areas south of Magee Road. In a few words, Council Members beholden to Golder Ranch Fire District have protected a little known measure that precludes us from inviting other eligible and competent Fire Districts from competing with Golder Ranch Fire District.

The Chief Architect of protecting GRFD is Council Member Barry Gillaspie, who killed a report from practically every staff member working for Oro Valley which, in a long-researched but little known official report, soundly trashed the idea of giving Golder Ranch a monopoly.

With the results of the Town election in, what we are faced with now is the famous “Lesser of Two Evils” conundrum. Terry Parish, a candidate who will now contest with Gillaspie, demonstrated at a forum sponsored by the Suffolk Hills Property Owners Association that he would not even listen to a plea to let those not yet annexed by Golder Ranch FD pick another Fire District that contracts with Rural Metro Corp for Firefighters and equipment. Parish is the self-described lapdog for developers bent on despoiling the desert round about, and then making us pay the cost of infrastructure, if not the loss of some of the prettiest views, not to mention the unique ambiance of Oro Valley.

We hope that Barry Gillaspie might relent in his adamant position; and give thought to a better alternative to the prohibitively expensive Golder Ranch Stealth Annexation Plan. It is designed to put an unbreakable lock guaranteed by law well into eternity on the ability to exact an ever-increasing property tax RATE that is sure to grow in quantum leaps.

–Phil Richardson

5 comments:

Richard Furash, MBA said...

Can the Council change the agreement with GRFD and create a situation where those of us who have not been annexed can get a competitive bid?

If so, how?

Robla said...

There is much more to this than is touched on this article. How about unequal protection for different citizens of the town. There should be focus on the level of service and protection for the tax rate, not just the tax rate itsself. Also, what happens when Rural-Metro pulls a Scottsdale and pulls out? Do some research and get both sides of the story. I just hear the howls if Oro Valley decided to do the same thing with Police protection that they have done with our fire service. Let's just contract it out to save money on protectingc our largest investment. Makes sense to me? I don't think so.

all_seeing_eye said...

You should do your homework. Rural Metro "pulled" out of Scottsdale as the department transitioned to a municipal department. All the firefighters stayed the same. And you obviously have fallen for the propaganda. A closer look will reveal that the level of service is the same. The issue is about letting La Canada Fire District annex into southern Oro Valley, period, and giving the residenta a choice. If you like being lied to and having your fire service crammed down your throat through intimidation and shady politics, then the current situation is right for you.

Robla said...

It is not propaganda, but facts. Rural Metro poured hundreds of thousands to defeat a public referendum to create a municipal fire department in Scottsdale and then announced within 6 months they were pulling out of the fire service in lieu of providing ambulance service (where the money is). I have great respect for the men and women who work for Rural Metro, but it is a corporation and management decisions are always based on that. I think we could privatized almost anything, but public safety should not be included in that.

I also find it interesting that anyone who seems to have a differing point of view on this blog has always "fallen for the propaganda".

Unknown said...

Phil Richardson apparently didn't go into much depth in his study, since he fails to mention the more than 15 year history of outstanding performance by GRFD to those of us fortunate enough to have had their service pre-merger.